If you achieve focus lock, hear a beep, and then complete the
press, then surely the bird has shifted forwards to SOME degree
from the point in time the focus lock is achieved and the actual
shutter depress takes place.. this is where predictive auto focus
might come positively in play? From the time you process the
beep in your head and until you actually depress the shutter
release, some measurable time elapses (any care to venture a guess
how much, on average?.. but probably at LEAST as much time, if not
more, than the actual shutter lag itself!)... I don't know the
average time this takes a typical person off the top of my head,
but I do know it's very likely measurable enough to allow the bird
to move towards you. Then, depending upon the DOF achieved, and
considering the DOF is typically shallower towards the front and
deeper towards the back, the directional movement forward is
certainly the direction one would expect this to show in a more
pronounced manner, I would think. You also mentioned that the ones
where the bird was closer were worse.. and I'd expect so, since the
DOF was likely even shallower unless you changed aperture on those
closer shot to maintain a DOF roughly consistent with the further
away shots(?).. again, forward movement of the bird plus the time
elapsing factors mentioned above are all at work and, if the DOF
was shallower, then the timing is even shorter before the bird
leaves the focused zone.
So, add the brain-hears-beep-to-finger-completing-release delay,
the bird moving towards you, into the shallower portion of DOF, and
the actual shutter lag from a prefocused 300D and you are probably
seeing the combined results in the OOF bird, with the feet
appearing more in focus by the time the shot is actually taken?
Using a faster shutter speed will help "some", but is not likely to
be a cure-all for the factors at work. It will only solve/aid a
small portion of the issue.. by reducing the slice of time during
which the shutter is open and shortening up the distance the bird
will travel during that period of time.. but even at 1/500 or
1/640, I don't think this is the chief culprit. the rest of the
delays will still exist.
You've probably already checked this.. but, where is the focus
point recorded as being? Did you check the shots in Canon's File
Viewer Utility to see where the red box(es) are? It might give
some more hard data to consider.
At any rate, I'm not convinced that the camera involved is the
chief contributor. Certainly, it's one contributor and a faster
camera (1D, for example) would help.. but probably not enough to
eliminate the issue. It would be a $5000 disappointment until
other factors are reduced enough to compensate for their own
influences on the OOF condition.
Just my opinion.. I could be wrong, but I believe the factors I
mentioned are all at work and all working against obtaining an
in-focus shot. It's not an impossible task to overcome, I don't
believe, just not an easy one with a single magic bullet (like a
faster responding camera). I'd love to hear from some pro Sports
shooters or someone else more keenly aware of all the things
involved and working against the shooter in these situations and
how to best conquer them? Likely that "practice, practice,
practice" (to improve technique, lower human response time, find
optimal settings), "shoot many, many shots" and "use continuous
shooting mode" will be buried inside of that advice?! ;-)
BTW, I love the shots and certainly can appreciate the difficulty
involved in getting them at all, let alone perfectly. Keep up the
good (hard) work!
icmp
I guess i can't complain since it's a whole lot better than most
non slr cameras, but there is definately shutter lag or i'm losing
my mind. I spent 4 hours yesterday shooting osprey inflight shots
and almost every shot of the bird flying towards me was slightly
out of focus. If he was flying parallel to me then it was sharp.
My camera/lens might be backfocusing sligtly as well since it seems
if it's flying away from me they tend to be sharper.
heres' the best shot flying towards me from today.
now here's one of the bird flying parallel to me.
kind of hard to tell with these processed pics, i'll follow this up
with some unprocessed 100% crops.
--
http://www.pbase.com/paulyoly/root