What I'm hoping is that over time, one of these alternatives will take off. People won't have to look to find it, it will be the de facto "next thing" (ie will become well known in the industry--the go-to site). This won't happen overnight. It may take a few years. Meanwhile, the clone sites should be enough to keep sharing Sigma information, product developments, and the like--for now. Basically, with DP closing, it creates a vacuum for someone else to fill that space. Maybe a few dozen sites will spring up. There's enough talent to make it happen. Then over time, most of us will coalesce around the most professional high-quality site. It's not like people won't stop reviewing equipment or posting about it online. It's just it will take time to get back to the level of *this* site. Fortunately, the user forums are much easier to duplicate and keep going.Having been through a number of forum transitions before the 2 most important things areI just read that they have a software programmer now.My personal website hosting service gives me unlimited space and doesn't care (AFAIK) what I put up there.The main problem of new DPREVIEW clones being created is that they will not have enough resources (disk space, flexibility, etc) to implement similar to a DPREVIEW structure.
"they" are using pre-coded software, not starting from scratch, see:And there are too many bugs when they start.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_Internet_forum_software
Resources are easy to overcome, that's not an issue. Getting the features ironed out, and attracting users and good content is a bigger issue. You can have a great option, but if people don't use it or know about it, then it just sits there.
I'm willing to give them three months, even six months to get things up and running. i plan to use one of the clones, whichever is more popular. There's plenty of resources on the internet to spend my time on. I already know which devices I want to buy (a medium format film or digital) and/or the Sigma FF camera, whichever comes first. I have a ton of film scanning also to get to work on.
a) Wherever the community lands, whomever is in charge is both respected AND has a long history of running forums. It's fun for a few months or even a year or two. It becomes a chore after that - so for that reason landing in a place that has a track record of hosting communities is important.
b) Yeah - that people show up and use it. People always get lost along the way - even die hards will fall off for whatever reason - the dopamine hit isn't the same or whatever. And with DPR - some people may only visit once a month or once every few months, all those people will have a hard time finding the new place. (I mean seriously - less than one month notice? Then again Amazon employees - including DP Review staff have it much worse.)
There's plenty of open source forum packages out there. The debate between this interface or that - threaded or not - is a niggle. Some people will always prefer one over the other. Actually finding a place for the community that lasts will be the big thing.