Thanks a lot for your comment.
With so many opinions I read else where against hdr I wasn't sure i what I should think of it. I thought maybe I was some kind of easy-to-impress post-processing beginner (which I am, actually)
I was wondering WHY, regardless of some negative comments I still liked the second one so much!
You're right: it's an effect. But so is black-and-white, in my opinion. Unless you're color blind, black-and-white has also little to do with reality, at least from a color perspective
Let's just think of some of the great black-and-white lanscapes by -Master- Ansel Adam. Well mastered, the Zone System has the ability to make things look not only great but kind of impossible and unrealistic too...
The bottom line is that I found that all the people I showed the pictures to and who were not "into" photography liked the HDR look. So my feeling is that as the majority of the people will apreciate such picture, whithout making any distinction such as "yeah, it looks good but it's not a real/natural picture (...)"
anyway, happy holidays to you all!
best regards,
Phil G
I like the effect--and it is an effect.
Your point is well taken in the sense that it does not have a
realistic/natural photograph look.
But the effect, as it turned out, is an exquisite graphic art effect.
--
'I talk way too much about camera and lenses: I gotta start shooting something!'
http://www.philippegratton.blogspot.com/