Learning why people use Raw

Yup. Shooting RAW I don't ever care about white balance. I just shoot, and worry about white balance later, when I develop the RAW file.

The WB info is still embedded by the camera in the RAW metadata, so the software can take a hint. But it's up to you to use it or not. And usually it's assumed you're smarter than a piece of silicon. ;)

--
Florin Andrei
http://florin.myip.org/
 
I can think of a million reasons why you should shoot RAW. I can only think of one reason to shoot .jpgs. That reason would be that you don't have the ability to shoot RAW at that time.

That could be due to a number of factors like in camera burst speed, in camera ETC, you don't have a RAW processor at that time, or you simply need to upload the pictures quickly or directly from the camera(Wifi enabled SD card).

Other than those reasons it would be RAW all the way.

--
GH2, GF1, & ZS3 Sample movies
http://www.youtube.com/user/mpgxsvcd#play/uploads
http://vimeo.com/user442745
GF1 Pictures
http://www.dpreview.com/galleries/4222674355/albums
 
I also tend to agree with the camera's auto white balance when shooting outdoors. It just seems good enough for me in most cases.

Artificial light, however, is a different problem. I end up tweaking WB on all pictures I take using artificial sources of light (except the onboard flash which seems good enough for me).

--
Florin Andrei
http://florin.myip.org/
 
It's not just WB, mate. RAW has a much higher dynamic range and resolution than JPEG. For MFT 12-bit RAW, you can get like 10 bits worth of DR out of RAW vs 8 out of JPEG. JPEG is also a lossy compression format so you lose resolution that way, even with "best" compression.

What do you lose in RAW? You lose the JPEG engine of the camera. For Panasonic, it's not much of a problem (at least with the GH1). For Olympus, it's a much more significant problem due to Olympus' renowned colour. I have never managed to replicate true Oly color via RAW, even using Oly software. It's just slightly different.

Nevertheless, I do RAW almost exclusively unless testing JPEG.
Here, in a very brief nutshell, is what I've learned. If the camera's auto white balance was always perfect, I doubt many people would shoot raw, because we can adjust contrast levels etc for in camera jpg. But white balance is different. Once a picture has been converted to JPEG, with the Gamma curve imposed and each color represented by 8 bits, it is pretty much impossible to make major corrections to white balance. I know, I've tried in the past. On top of that, you get to play with black level, brightness, and noise reduction ... it's really powerful and amazing to me. But I think white balance = color temperature is the key adjustment.

So this past weekend was my wife's mother's 80th birthday and there was a celebration in her house. In that house, the kitchen is lit by cool florescent, the dining room by incandescent, and the room with the TV is lit by a floor standing lamp with warm florescent bulbs, and a yellowed shade. In short, the lighting differs dramatically. So I shot raw + jpeg, and figured I'd get my first real use (not just practice) with ACR.

It turns out the the camera did rather well with cool florescent and really well with incandescent; I didn't even bother to mess with some of the .rw2 files. But it was WAY off and inconsistent (by a couple of hundred degrees in color temperature) in the room with the warm florescent under the yellowed lampshade.

Below are two versions of one of the worst jpegs. The lamp with the yellowed shade is off to the rigt. The first version is the out of camera jpeg, the second is the ACR conversion from .rw2. Shot at ISO 800, AWB, G10 with kit lens. (The couple are friends of my wife's parents).

By the way, at ISO 800 in ACR I raised Luminance noise suppression to 35 or 40, that really got rid of the noise. Chroma noise reduction default is 25, I left that alone. I did once reduce it to 0 to see that there was indeed chroma noise; 25 gets rid of it.
--
=============================
The Rotary Shutter: http://paper.li/maptung/rotary-shutter
My Flickriver: http://www.flickriver.com/photos/testdasi/random
 
This has turned into a very interesting thread! I'm still learning, and thanks to everyone who took the time to post.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top