>> Challenge 42: Vote Here <<

[peggy]

Exhibition:
4pts Lilacs and a Song by Johnny B.

and in no particular order:

1pt Getty Center Trellis by Sarah
1pt Strong Contender Mark J
1pt red leaf by Harry Behret
1pt A tulip bouquet Carlos Chacon
1pt caterpillar food by Babe
1pt Angels in the Outfield by Krymedog
1pt Moonlight by Ura Samonov
1pt Framed by Linda L
1pt Muppet flower by Helen Betts

this was way too hard to vote on -- good job everyone!

--
peggy... also known as miaowcat!
-- Sony Mavica CD1000, CD400 (and former DSC S85)
http://www.pbase.com/puck

 

[Ann Chaikin]

You have Aorta by Joe Reilly twice. I think that 4 is the max you can give it, right MFC? You might want to pick another image for a point. Ann

Eligible psephology:

Aorta -- Joe Reilly 4 pts

One point to each of the following:

Missing in Action -- Eric
Burr -- Irish Eye
Gerbera's Reprise -- Mark J
My Gerbera -- Mark J
Smoking Grass -- Irish Eye
Succulent -- Faye
Yellow -- Saf1
Vase of Flowers -- Lisafx
Aorta -- Joe Reilly
Unexpecteed Development -- Helen Betts
Single -- Antoine
Good Morning STF -- Cindy

Another fun one! Happy Shooting.

--
also known as PT Kitty > ^..^
http://www.pbase.com/ptkitty/galleries
http://www.annchaikin.com

 

[Earl Sprouse]

You are correct Ann, thanks. Four points for Aorta. Add Symbiosis -- Ori, for one point.

Eligible psephology:

Aorta -- Joe Reilly 4 pts

One point to each of the following:

Missing in Action -- Eric
Burr -- Irish Eye
Gerbera's Reprise -- Mark J
My Gerbera -- Mark J
Smoking Grass -- Irish Eye
Succulent -- Faye
Yellow -- Saf1
Vase of Flowers -- Lisafx
Aorta -- Joe Reilly
Unexpecteed Development -- Helen Betts
Single -- Antoine
Good Morning STF -- Cindy

Another fun one! Happy Shooting.

--
also known as PT Kitty > ^..^
http://www.pbase.com/ptkitty/galleries
http://www.annchaikin.com

 

[MFC]

Marvin,

Do you want to pick another photo for the single point you awarded "Aorta"? You awarded "Aorta" the 4pt max already.
Just clarify what you would like to do, please. Thanks, Ann.
Thanks alot,
Mike Callahan

 

[MFC]

Marvin,
Do you want to pick another photo for the single point you awarded
"Aorta"? You awarded "Aorta" the 4pt max already.
Just clarify what you would like to do, please. Thanks, Ann.
Thanks alot,
Mike Callahan

 

[hifive]

Eligible gallery

4 points Missing in action ...... eric
2 points Vase of Flames ...... Lisafx
2 points Sun Star ....... Faye White

Exhibition
4 points Framed ....... LindL
4 points Mushroom Kid .....eric
2 points Iris ...... W R (Bill) Somsky

Wow!...two really wonderful gardens blooming with SO MANY beautiful
and interesting plant photos. The collective creativity and ability
displayed is so inspiring...what a great group of gardeners you ALL
are! Thanks for supporting this theme with so much enthusiasm...it
was really a joy to host. I'll come back to stroll through the
gardens often.

After reviewing the debate on the voting changes made in the last
challenge, I'd like to try something a little different. Because of
the way this new system will work, I'm asking you to please vote in
SOME way for BOTH galleries. I think people in both galleries would
appreciate a pat on the back. Everyone, please feel encouraged to
vote...whether you entered photos or not. You'll have 48 hours to
cast votes.

Voting Guidelines:

• Vote within this thread.

• Cast 4 points for your very favorite single photo in each gallery.
• You can then award up to 12 more points in each gallery. You

are not required to cast any or all of these 12
points....or to cast them the same way in each gallery.
Vote according to your style preference. Maximum points allowed
per photo is 4.

• Honorable mentions & comments...as many as you would like.
• To show appreciation for each other's work, in the traditional,

friendly spirit of the challenges, please vote for photos
other than your own.

• Here is the format for voting:

Eligible:
4pts_ Title by Artist
(?)pts_ Title by Artist (This repeats as you see fit)
Exhibition:
4pts_ Title by Artist
(?)pts_ Title by Artist (This repeats as you see fit)

This is not very complicated; and it accomodates a wide variety of
voting style preferences. I'm happy to be the "guinea pig" for
this method and tally your votes, however you cast them. Your
favorites will still rise to the top. At the very least, this can
serve as a "poll" indicating how voters prefer to vote. Let the
voting begin, and try having some fun with this part of the
challenge too. The "task" of voting should be a little more
enjoyable, given a personal style choice...but, please, do cast
votes

Thank you,
Mike Callahan (MFC)
Here is the link for viewing the Challenge 42 gardens and deadline
chart:
http://www.pbase.com/stfchallenge/challenge_42_plants

 

[lochinvar]

Mike, thanks for this challenge. It was the right theme at the right time. I discovered plants and blossoms during the challenge period, i never recognized before. Your voting system worked good to me, i was able to bring more pics into the votes. Considering that the number of entries increased, this system is a good solution.

Eligible gallery:

4 pts: thre generations by bezucho – many macros and close ups in the challenge, this image stands out in a "competitive market". Reduced, noble, very clear.

3 pts: Bouquet? by Ori – the harsh colors underline the scenery. What a hard job this women have.

2 pts: Mayapple in the Woods by Bill Borne – i like the perspective. The huge trees in the background, like a dome and the little sharp plant in the foreground. Good view!
2 pts: Blurr by irish_eye – colors, composition, dof. Great image.

2 pts: The Venus Trap by Fremiet – creative as usual and a very, very good layout.

1 pt: Wet Petunias by JB707 – friendly and modest. A photo for a second view.

1 pt: Gone, but... by JamieZX – i like the mood and the thought we are all a part of nature

1 pt: Water and Green by Michele Pesta – the color and shades and the sharpness of this image. Very striking.

HM:
Rabbit’s Sunset by MxCat
Half Dressed by Helen Batts
Red Geraniums by Hamili

Exhibition gallery:

4 pts: Perseverance by kudbegud – most interesting scene, the art of life and survivel. And a very good photo.
3 pts: plant by JoeSchmoe – unique interpretation
3 pts: sunset lillies by Klaus Wiese – simply a good photo.

2 pts: Creepy by Hamili – i like the light, the color and the decentered composition.

2 pts: Primavera by Doris Baillet – reminds me of many holidays i spent in Italy, i can smell this pic.

2 pts: One Dalton missing by Willem – it’s a Willem. Great technique and a good sense of humor.

HM:
Leeves by Kenan Oran
Autumn Leaf by Antoine

So many good images, congrats to all of you. And hey – congrats to me! I have a ticket for a Bruce Springsteen concert tomorrow!

Heidi

 

[1ofUs!]

Thank you Mike for being a great grounds keeper on this one.

4 pts. Our Garden by KY
1 pt. each for the following:
Looking Up by Bluto
Curly by Sprouse
Return of Nature by Lochinvar
Coastal Wildflowers by Michael Puff
Golden Sunflower by Peggy
For my Mommy by Cara Davis - original chopped
The Second Life by LanceD
Vase of Flames by Lisafx
Grande by Sprouse
Leaves with Shadows by AnnC
Dry Grass Heads by Kudbegud
Wrong Way by Peggy

--
CindyD or SarahD
If one of us is laughing, and the other one isn't, one of us must be wrong...

 

[K Miller]

I've been away for way too long. It is great to see everyone grow and improve. It really inspires me. Hopefully life will allow more participation in the future.

Eligible:

4pts. The end of Spring....Helen Betts
3pts. Simple Beauty ... Michele Pesta
3pts. Good morning STF ... CindyD
3pts. Orchid Sprig ... LisaFX
3pts. On the Fence...Ann Chaikin

Exhibition

4pts. Little Blue Flowers ... Boris Sidis
3pts. Caterpillar Food ... Babe
3pts. Tickled Pink ... LindaL
3pts. Abstract Flower ... MarkJ
3pts. Dandelion at Sunset .... WR (Bill) Somsky

BTW, Mike.....great job!!!

 

[jr60004]

Mike.
Brilliantly generic topic enabeling so many to compete.
Many rookies earning points also.

I'll keep it short because you have been doing a herculean (sp) amount of reading and typing in the last two weeks. and post moving...heheheee

Eligible

4 pts
On the Fence by Ann Chaikin

2pts
Orchid Sprig by Lisafx

2pts
for my Mommy by Cara Davis Conomos

2pts
Succulent by Faye White

2pts
Simple Beauty by Michele Pesta

2pts
Old Yeller' by Johnny B.

2pts
red white and green by JoeSchmoe

Sorry exhibitionists! I did not have enough time to review the whole gallery.
In fact right now I am supposed to be shooting "callbacks" for my wife's show.

Again, this is my first entry but I believe you have set a benchmark for hosting!
Thank you
Mikeeeee Mattis Jr.

 

[Michael Puff]

Mike - I add my kudos to you as a most gracious host. It's deeply appreciated that you've worked so hard to make this a rewarding and fun challenge. Thank you.

Eligible:
4pts_ On the Fence by Ann Chaikin

1 point to each of the following:
yellow tulip by Harry Behret
Missing in Action by eric
Gerbera's Reprise by MarkJ
the return of nature by lochinvar
Wet Petunias by JB707
golden sunflower by Peggy
Gone, but... by JaimeZX
for my Mommy by Cara Davis Conomos (original)
Water and Green by Michele Pesta
Pond by willem
Dry Grass Heads in Old Bottle by kudbegud
Vase of Flames by Lisafx

Exhibition:
4pts_ Bleeding Heart by Bev Brink

1 point to each of the following:
Autumn Ferns by Sara D
Rasberries by canadian_ann
Soft Petals by MarkJ
sunset lillies by Klaus Wiese
-x by upsidedown
Lupine by Willem
A Day Early and A Dollar Long by Bill Somsky
plant by JoeSchmoe
A Tulip Bouquet by Carlos Chacon
Mushroom by Flashlight by Fremiet
Tulip Dancers by GPSteve
Primavera by Doris Baillet

 

[Michael Buckman]

Great hosting job Mike, you make everyone feel at home - your support is terrific as reflected in the numerous entries. Thanks

Eligible

4 pts - Purple Rose - Michele Pesta

2 pts - My Gerbera - Mark J
2 pts - Missing in Action - Eric
1 pt - Just a Rose #1 - Hewy
1 pt - Water and Green - Michele Pesta
1 pt - On the Horizon - Willem

Exhibition

4 pts - Sunflower - Boris Sidis

2 pts - The Back Shed - El-See
2 pts - Gradient Calla - Mark J
1 pt - Daphodils Forever - Dave McMillan
1 pt - Mushroom by Flashlight - Fremiet
1 pt - Just a Drop - Boris Sidis
--
What's with all these auto settings?
Do that many people take pictures of cars?
http://www.pbase.com/bbucks

 

[Scutellata]

Eligible:
4 Points Sun Star by Faye White

1 Pt each for the following:
Bump Image 01 by EmnmE
Missing in Action by eric
Rabbit’s Sunset by MxCat
Curly by Sprouse
Closer to Heaven by Eric
Costal Wildflowers by Michel Puff
Shooting Star* by mlynn
Nepenthes Coccinea by Faye White
The Second Life LanceD
Take a Cup of Flower and…….. by Fremiet
Midnight Wasp by David Cappello
Vase of Flames by Lisafx

 

[Joe Reilly129599]

Incredible gallery and extremely tough going at the ballot box. As one might infer from my votes, I think Michele Pesta had one heckuva showing and set the bar for the gallery. Lisafx also lit it up with the best I've seen from her. Excellent showing from some familiar (because they're consistent) names...

(4) Purple Rose by Michele Pesta: Perfect. About as professional as it gets.

(3) couple ... and the others by bezucho. Wonderful story, wonderful picture. Makes me grin every time I see it.

(1) On the Fence by Ann Chaikin
(1) Water and Green by Michele Pesta
(1) ME & Love by Saf1
(1) Dry Grass Heads in Old Bottle by kudbegud
(1) My Gerbera by Mark J
(1) Vase of Flames by Lisafx
(1) The End of Spring by Helen Betts
(1) Nepenthes Coccinea by Faye White
(1) stargazer lily by Katherine Kenison

Others having strong impact on me...

• Pink Orchid Trio by Lisafx
• nEwness by irish_eye
• wrong way by Peggy
• Simple Beauty by Michele Pesta
• Roses, dutch master style by Hewy

--
Joe
DSC-F717, http://pbase/misterpix

 

[JaimeZX]

4pts - Lupine by Willem
4 pts - Mushroom by Flashlight by Fremiet
3 pts - Esssense of Beauty by Antoine
1 pt - Strong Contender by Mark J
1 pt - Indian Summer in May by Krymedogg
1 pt - Sunset Lillies by Klaus Wiese
1 pt - My Daffy Dill by K Miller
1 pt - Lilacs and a Song by Johnny B

Great work to EVERYONE!!

 

[Roberta F.]

Mike,

Thanks for a great challenge! I love your closing image. I enjoyed everyone's work and I appreciate the comments!

Eligible Gallery:

4 pts. Burr by irish_eye (Unique and stunning image)
3 pts. Water and Green by Michele Pesta
2pts. Wet Petunias by JB707
2 pts. Single by Antoine
2 pts. Aorta by Joe Reilly
2 pts. Our Garden by Ky
1 pt. On the Horizon by Willem

Exhibition Gallery:

4 pts. Strong Contender by Mark J.
3 pts. Sunflower by Boris Sidis
2 pts. Caterpillar Food by babe
2 pts. Essence of Beauty by Antoine
2 pts. Bright Peony by Ann Chaikin
1 pt. Leaves by Kenan Oran
1 pt. Thanksgiving Rose by Lisafx
1 pt. Angels in the Outfield by Krymedogg

Roberta
http://www.pbase.com/roberta
Sony 717, Olympus C-3000, Nikon FM

 

[Fremiet59632]

.....having to pick out a winner is quite beyond me. I would decline, except that then the rest of my votes wouldn't count. Life ain't easy. Let me heartily endorse all the positive comments about Mike's attention to the challenge. A better host is hard to imagine.

To anyone not getting a point from me ....I didn't have enough to go round...BUT, Mike, the system is the best so far....at least there is the chance to honor more people.

Sorry I did not leave more comments, but I've been confronted with a million crises to solve and events to attend at school....and that comes first.

Unofficially and most importantly from my perspective I award everyone a point because posting one's work takes a certain something which calls for recognition and needs to be honored.

Single (official) points to
Burr by irish_eye
Discoloration by florg
On the fence by Ann Chaikin
Wildflower in the woods by Bill Borne
Missing in Action by Eric
Guava Blossom and Bud by Richard R
The Return of Nature by Lochinvar
Nepenthes Coccinea by Faye
Old Lady by Pedro Teixeira
Vase of Flowers by LisaFX
Generations by Bezucho
Dry Grass by Kudbegud
Red White and Green by Joe Schmoe

3 extra points to Anne Chaikin for on the fence because I love fences like that and the flowers are great.... icing on the cake and sooo alive.
Guava blossom came mighty close though......... and so did .....and so did......
--
http://www.pbase.com/fremiet

 

[MarieB]

Eligible:
4pts On the Horizon by Willem
3pts Before the Grand Opening by Deb
2pts Lady's Mantle after the Rain by Carrie Woeck
2pts Sun Star by Faye White
2pts Water and Green by Michele Pesta
2pts Hey! Who Invited You... by Deb
1pt Flower Under Glass by eric

Exhibition:
4pts Primavera by Doris Baillet
3pts White Balanced Weed by Willem
3pts Tulip by upsidedown
2pts Sunburnt by babe
2pts Campo en invierno by Doris Baillet
1pt Love by Ura Samonov
1pt Field of Dreams by Fremiet

Beautiful stuff! Don't know how to really choose!

I like the new voting...

Thanks,
Marie

 

[Deb K.]

MFC, thanks for a fun and interesting topic w/which to work. I really like this method of voting, but I must say that we always have so many wonderful images that no matter how many points we are given to award it will remain tough to cast votes.

Kudos to all who participated. It was once again a pleasure to tiptoe through the tulips, and irises, and lilies, and...

Here are my votes;

ELIGIBLE

4 PTS--- Purple Rose/Michele P

1 Point each to the following images;

Leaves/Ann Chaikin
Burr/irish_eye
The Sky's the Limit/Helen Betts
Pink Orchid Trio/LisaFX
Coastal Wildflowers/Michael Puff
Sunstar/Faye White
The End of Spring/Helen Betts
In the Rough/David Cappello (Been there, done that)
Vase of Flames/Lisa Fx
Trinity/Ori
Green Fan/Carlos Chacon
Green Rose/Syncpuls

EXHIBITION

4PTS---Happy Birthday/kudbegud

1 Point each to the following images;

Daisy Macro/Roberta F
Soft Petal/MarkJ
Pink Sunrise/Marie
Before the Plow Comes/Marie
Dandelion at Sunset/WR Somsky
Fenced In/Bluto
A Tulip Bouquet/Carlos Chacon
Sunlit/Babe
Angels in the Outfield/krymedog
Framed/Linda L
Keep Guessing/Mike Fitzgerald
Sunflower/Peggy

Honorable Mention...See? Still not enough points to go around!

Orange Rose/Clemson Chan
The Muppet Flower/Helen Betts

 

[Bernd Taeger]

Exhibition
4 pts = Inside of a Tulip by Bill Borne
4 pts = Esssence of Beauty by Antoine
2 pts = Mushroom by Flashlight by Fremiet
2 pts = Runneth Over by Cara Davis Conomos

Eligible
4 pts = Dry Grass Heads in Old Bottle by kudbegud
2 pts = On the horizon by Willem
2 pts = Red Caribaea Heliconia by kudbegud
2 pts = Water and Green by Michele Pesta
2 pts = Leaves with Shadows by Ann Chaikin

--
Bernd Taeger