-
Welcome to the new forums! Please read this first. For known issues we are working to resolve, click here.
Can Computers Create Art?
- Thread starter lylejk
- Start date
tbcass
Forum Pro
Regardless of what the video says in my opinion ART has to be a 100% human creation while using tools to create the persons vision. It also should be something not created previously. If you think that when a person manipulates AI to create their vision it is art then it's not AI. AI has to be completely independent of human interaction. AI as it stands today is not true AI because it's not capable of independent thought but only emulates what humans have created previously.
--
Tom
--
Tom
Last edited:
Doesn't look like it lacks imagination to me. If you hadn't told me I would have never know you used it to create this. Those tools are available in PS and others.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
--
Funny how millions of people on an internet platform where they can communicate instantaneously with people on the other side of the world using incredibly powerful handheld computers linked to orbiting the satellites hundreds of miles in space don’t believe in science. Neil deGrasse Tyson
tbcass
Forum Pro
It's lacking imagination because it's simply emulating what has come before. I see no originality in that picture.Doesn't look like it lacks imagination to me. If you hadn't told me I would have never know you used it to create this. Those tools are available in PS and others.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
--
Tom
ppage
Veteran Member
Personally, I've always felt that "artificial intelligence" is a misnomer and that the term we should be using is "simulated intelligence".
How would someone know what came before unless you told them? Besides that is subjective. I could say that for any artist who paints any picture or any photographer that takes a shot. I love Ansel Adams work. I've been in conversations with people who were not impressed at all.It's lacking imagination because it's simply emulating what has come before. I see no originality in that picture.Doesn't look like it lacks imagination to me. If you hadn't told me I would have never know you used it to create this. Those tools are available in PS and others.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
--
Funny how millions of people on an internet platform where they can communicate instantaneously with people on the other side of the world using incredibly powerful handheld computers linked to orbiting the satellites hundreds of miles in space don’t believe in science. Neil deGrasse Tyson
Yes there have been a few conversations about that. AI is just easier to add in conversion because it's the most common term apps/companies have used for years. Data which is the most coveted thing by corporations is just mushed into complex algorithms and continually trained.
Has anyone seen the movie I Robot? Remember the unexplained characteristics they talked about. When older models were put out of commission and left in the dark why did they huddle together? Of course that is a science fiction book/movie but the top five are now seeing unexpected behaviours from their AI.
Kaj E
Forum Pro
Loos awful. Would not call that art.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
AI seems to lack taste.
--
Kind regards
Kaj
http://www.pbase.com/kaj_e
WSSA member #13
It's about time we started to take photography seriously and treat it as a hobby.- Elliott Erwitt
Last edited:
What is your opinion of this?Loos awful. Would not call that art.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
AI seems to lack taste.
--
Funny how millions of people on an internet platform where they can communicate instantaneously with people on the other side of the world using incredibly powerful handheld computers linked to orbiting the satellites hundreds of miles in space don’t believe in science. Neil deGrasse Tyson
I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
I seriously think that my crop makes this landscape"more artistic"
--
If you want to be equal, you have to be better...
I agree. You added your personal touch.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
I seriously think that my crop makes this landscape"more artistic"
--
Funny how millions of people on an internet platform where they can communicate instantaneously with people on the other side of the world using incredibly powerful handheld computers linked to orbiting the satellites hundreds of miles in space don’t believe in science. Neil deGrasse Tyson
tbcass
Forum Pro
True but the time may come when a computer is capable of independent intellectually superior thought at which point maybe we can start thinking of what it produces as art. What we have now is AS, artificial stupidity!
Kaj E
Forum Pro
That looks better. Reminds me of something by Nicholas BottWhat is your opinion of this?Loos awful. Would not call that art.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
AI seems to lack taste.
--
Kind regards
Kaj
Galleries by Kaj E
www.pbase.com
It's about time we started to take photography seriously and treat it as a hobby.- Elliott Erwitt
Kaj E
Forum Pro
Some people seem to think that name recognition by doing strange things, and throwing money to show they can, is worth it.
Never heard of him. We had cottage in the Canadian Boreal forest and had a few of their prints on our walls. Not the one above.That looks better. Reminds me of something by Nicholas BottWhat is your opinion of this?Loos awful. Would not call that art.I asked CoPilot in CGPT5 mode to "create impressionist style art of a Yorkshire Dales sunset and it produced the art shown below. This perhaps lacks imagination but much better than I could ever do.
AI seems to lack taste.
Group of Seven (artists) - Wikipedia
--
Funny how millions of people on an internet platform where they can communicate instantaneously with people on the other side of the world using incredibly powerful handheld computers linked to orbiting the satellites hundreds of miles in space don’t believe in science. Neil deGrasse Tyson
Is it question of can it? I think it's a little late for that question.
“AI God” by Ai-Da. An abstract portrayal of computing pioneer Alan Turing.
Sold for $1,084,800 at Sotheby's in 2024
Ai-Da created in 2019 is regarded as the world’s first humanoid robot artist.
There are a few elephants who are continuously creating paintings that routinely sell in the 5 figure range.
“AI God” by Ai-Da. An abstract portrayal of computing pioneer Alan Turing.
Sold for $1,084,800 at Sotheby's in 2024
Ai-Da created in 2019 is regarded as the world’s first humanoid robot artist.
- Cameras in her eyes allow her to “see” subjects.
- AI software analyzes visual input to interpret shapes, tones, and proportions.
- A robotic arm then creates physical drawings and paintings.
- It also produces sculpture, poetry, and performance art
There are a few elephants who are continuously creating paintings that routinely sell in the 5 figure range.
Last edited:
Similar threads
Keyboard shortcuts
- f
- Forum