Thank you for returning to comment. I didn't mean to appear evasive - my questions are honest questions. I can see that the second image has much more focus on 'music', and I should put the architect in me behind for the assignment.
I don't feel you were evasive at all, and I admire you for being an architect. I seriously considered studying architecture as a college student good at math over 50 years ago, but my passion for music won out. Best regards.
This one looks, to my eyes, better. the composition is more "instrument" and the instrument is immediately visible - no "what is that... oh, it's a contrabass clarinet". So yes, I think it is more fit for purpose.
Thank you. I feel very nervous with people as I see so many beautiful portraits, but the musician is a very good friend so I wanted to help him out if I could.