In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
It's not conclusive proof, but if you look at the DP Review image comparison page you can see that the GX85 has separate settings for Standard and E-Shutter (suggesting a difference in bit depth) whereas the GX9 does not.
 
Re: « I bought the GX9 to use as a street camera - small, all black [I put tape over the Lumix logo] and with the flip screen, better than fully articulated for sneaky picture taking. »

OK; this might have been a good technique in the days of Cartier-Bresson when privacy laws were non-existent, but nowadays, if you take a picture of someone unawares AND publish it, you could get into big trouble. Oh, and BTW, after 45+ years of picture taking using a mix of black-body and "two-tone" cameras, I have yet to notice a difference with the awareness of my "subjects". You just can't disguise a 200mm+ telephoto lens aiming at you and you can't expect a camera using a 35mm lens at close distance to be stealthy just because it is black...
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
I have confirmed it multiple times and am not going to go back & look it up to satisfy your passing around FUD. Check it out before asking questions you don’t have any idea about.
Sorry I don't mean to be confrontational. I just meant to say I don't remember reading anything 100% conclusive. A quick search didn't find anything (but DP Review's search tool doesn't work very well). If you have proof, feel free to post links to it.
 
Last edited:
Quick update

so I was able to play with my new camera for a while this week and I gotta say I’m loving the speedier focus, improved IBIS and especially the kit lens. 12-60 is an excellent all round focal range. It allows me to frame my two boys (5 and 3) from near or far and if they move too quickly (which is most of the time), I’m able to refocus/zoom and get them in the shot.

i ordered the eyecup for the GX9 (I have one on my GX7 as well) and find it excellent for blocking light sneaking in on the EVF,. Otherwise I’m loving the camera and really enjoying the ergonomics as well,.

Just have to customize some buttons/dials and I’ll be ready for all the summer shooting up here in Winnipeg!

cheers and happy shooting!

Mike F
 
Last edited:
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
This has been model-specific. My G3 and G6 dropped to 10 bits, but my GX1, GX7 and GX8 didn't.
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
It's not conclusive proof, but if you look at the DP Review image comparison page you can see that the GX85 has separate settings for Standard and E-Shutter (suggesting a difference in bit depth) whereas the GX9 does not.
One of the reasons DPR does this is to illustrate the effect of shutter shock, if any. These test shots won't tell you anything about bit-depth unless you download the RAW files and lift the shadows at least 2-3 stops.
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
It's not conclusive proof, but if you look at the DP Review image comparison page you can see that the GX85 has separate settings for Standard and E-Shutter (suggesting a difference in bit depth) whereas the GX9 does not.
One of the reasons DPR does this is to illustrate the effect of shutter shock, if any. These test shots won't tell you anything about bit-depth unless you download the RAW files and lift the shadows at least 2-3 stops.
i do not believe lifting shadows will tell you anything about bit depth.
 
Especially with small primes. I hope you enjoy your purchase!
 
Quick update

so I was able to play with my new camera for a while this week and I gotta say I’m loving the speedier focus, improved IBIS and especially the kit lens. 12-60 is an excellent all round focal range. It allows me to frame my two boys (5 and 3) from near or far and if they move too quickly (which is most of the time), I’m able to refocus/zoom and get them in the shot.

i ordered the eyecup for the GX9 (I have one on my GX7 as well) and find it excellent for blocking light sneaking in on the EVF,. Otherwise I’m loving the camera and really enjoying the ergonomics as well,.

Just have to customize some buttons/dials and I’ll be ready for all the summer shooting up here in Winnipeg!

cheers and happy shooting!

Mike F
My GX85 arrived yesterday...went out in the afternoon for some street / urban shots with the 12-32mm - very pleased with the handling, metering and the JPEG output! The AF in daylight is so fast I didn't have to half-press and wait for the beep - just hit the shutter all the way down in one movement with focus release set in the menu - (great for capturing things moving into the scene). As the GX9 is presumably even better, I can see you're going to be really happy with it :-)

I'm wondering about the eyecup also. I developed a technique yesterday of holding the body in a way that shielded the EVF (left eye shooter) but I think the cup is available for the GX85 as well as the GX9? I must have a look at the 12-60mm lens - the 12-32mm is surprisingly good and compact, but it would be nice to have a little more reach from time-to-time.
 
Hello Elyharbour

I just ordered the eyecup for the GX9 yesterday off eBay,. Couldn’t find it on Amazon.ca and it was more expensive on Amazon.com,.. it’ll take 2-4 weeks to get here but at least that’s before summer! Lol

cheers

Mike F
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
It's not conclusive proof, but if you look at the DP Review image comparison page you can see that the GX85 has separate settings for Standard and E-Shutter (suggesting a difference in bit depth) whereas the GX9 does not.
One of the reasons DPR does this is to illustrate the effect of shutter shock, if any. These test shots won't tell you anything about bit-depth unless you download the RAW files and lift the shadows at least 2-3 stops.
i do not believe lifting shadows will tell you anything about bit depth.
And some people do not believe the Earth is round. Can you provide any actual information?
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
It's not conclusive proof, but if you look at the DP Review image comparison page you can see that the GX85 has separate settings for Standard and E-Shutter (suggesting a difference in bit depth) whereas the GX9 does not.
One of the reasons DPR does this is to illustrate the effect of shutter shock, if any. These test shots won't tell you anything about bit-depth unless you download the RAW files and lift the shadows at least 2-3 stops.
i do not believe lifting shadows will tell you anything about bit depth.
And some people do not believe the Earth is round. Can you provide any actual information?
Lifting shadows may give some indication of sensor ISO Invariance, though most sensors are really not invariant and if they are, usually, only within a specific range. Plus, you will often, over wide ranges, get software processing effects that were not built for that type of poor exposure.

Best that you explain how you can measure bit depth by what you suggest...and show some documented examples.
 
I initially didn't buy the extra grip, but decided to give it a try after using the camera for a few weeks. I ended up returning the grip. Without the grip my fingers curled downwards. Kind of the side of my fingers held camera. It was ok but not great. I thought the extra grip world help. But with the grip my fingers curl into the body and don't have enough room. It's less comfortable to me with the grip. So now I bought grippy stickers of various shapes on Amazon and placed them at strategic locations on camera. These, along with nice wrist strap, work great for me. Also, the added grip prevented me from comfortable holding camera downward with extended straight fingers.
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
It's not conclusive proof, but if you look at the DP Review image comparison page you can see that the GX85 has separate settings for Standard and E-Shutter (suggesting a difference in bit depth) whereas the GX9 does not.
One of the reasons DPR does this is to illustrate the effect of shutter shock, if any. These test shots won't tell you anything about bit-depth unless you download the RAW files and lift the shadows at least 2-3 stops.
i do not believe lifting shadows will tell you anything about bit depth.
And some people do not believe the Earth is round. Can you provide any actual information?
Lifting shadows may give some indication of sensor ISO Invariance, though most sensors are really not invariant and if they are, usually, only within a specific range.
Here you're thinking of lifting all shadows values in a linear fashion. I'm talking about stretching the tonal range of shadow areas, such that the lowest value remains 0, but the lightest values lifted shift from, say 40 to 80. The fewer bits you have, the more unsmooth the transitions between the values in this stretched tonal range will be.
Plus, you will often, over wide ranges, get software processing effects that were not built for that type of poor exposure.

Best that you explain how you can measure bit depth by what you suggest...and show some documented examples.
Bit depth determines the number of tonal values available to represent a given range of brightness. The number of values is much less in shadows than in highlights, which is the whole rationale for ETTR. Lifting shadows can reveal unsmooth transitions between values due to insufficient bits to represent subtle differences in tone. Hence, a 10-bit capture may show less smooth transitions between shadow values than a 12-bit capture. I have found that lifted shadows fall apart faster with a 10-bit file than a 12-bit file. If you stretch the tonal range of shadow areas, the resulting histogram will show more and bigger gaps among values for a 10-bit file than for a 12-bit file.

--
"I learned long ago, never to wrestle with a pig. You get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it." - George Bernard Shaw
http://jacquescornell.photography
http://happening.photos
 
Last edited:
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
When I got my GX9 I tested the eshtr modes of this and my gx80. Looking At the RAWs with rawdigger the GX9 produces indistinguishable files for both mechanical and electronic shutter. The GX80 RAWs are markedly different between eshtr and mechanical.

Conclusive? It is to me and I use GX9 in ESHTR unless I need to use mechanical.
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
When I got my GX9 I tested the eshtr modes of this and my gx80. Looking At the RAWs with rawdigger the GX9 produces indistinguishable files for both mechanical and electronic shutter. The GX80 RAWs are markedly different between eshtr and mechanical.

Conclusive? It is to me and I use GX9 in ESHTR unless I need to use mechanical.
I'm an engineering type and I prefer quantitative and repeatable results, so I did my own analysis using a repeatable method (which anyone can do themselves with free software). There was another post that said when a camera switches to 10-bit it ignores the lower 2 bits. So I used dcraw to convert the RW2 to a grayscale PGM file (keeping all unscaled/uninterpolated RAW data). I then examined it in a hex editor (I used HXD) and value of the lower 2 bits are "11" for almost all pixels in the 10-bit files (not the case for 12-bit). I wrote a program to count the occurrence of all the different values of the lower 2 bits to make things easier. I got e-shutter samples from the exposure latitude comparison tool in DPReview or searching through galleries of imaging resource or photographyblog for rw2 samples at shutter speeds higher than mechanical (I verified shutter type was electronic with exiftool).

The results I got was as below:

10-bit e-shutter:
GM1
GM5
GX85
G7
GH4

12-bit e-shutter:
GF7
GX850 (GF9)
GX8
GX9
G85

Need a e-shutter RW2 sample to determine:
GX7
GH5
GH5S
G9

As you can see, the 10-bit e-shutter also occurred in cameras after the GX8 (GX85 came after), but 12-bit also was before, even in the entry level cameras. I was a bit surprised at some (like how GF7 has 12-bit while GM series didn't). I think Panasonic mainly made a decision on each camera (slower readout vs 10-bit at faster readout), not really a set pattern or a specific date they decided to do one way or the other.

This is getting very off topic, so I will perhaps start another thread for reference, but I'm still missing a few samples of the modern cameras.
 
Last edited:
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
When I got my GX9 I tested the eshtr modes of this and my gx80. Looking At the RAWs with rawdigger the GX9 produces indistinguishable files for both mechanical and electronic shutter. The GX80 RAWs are markedly different between eshtr and mechanical.

Conclusive? It is to me and I use GX9 in ESHTR unless I need to use mechanical.
I'm an engineering type and I prefer quantitative and repeatable results, so I did my own analysis using a repeatable method (which anyone can do themselves with free software). There was another post that said when a camera switches to 10-bit it ignores the lower 2 bits. So I used dcraw to convert the RW2 to a grayscale PGM file (keeping all unscaled/uninterpolated RAW data). I then examined it in a hex editor (I used HXD) and value of the lower 2 bits are "11" for almost all pixels in the 10-bit files (not the case for 12-bit). I wrote a program to count the occurrence of all the different values of the lower 2 bits to make things easier. I got e-shutter samples from the exposure latitude comparison tool in DPReview or searching through galleries of imaging resource or photographyblog for rw2 samples at shutter speeds higher than mechanical (I verified shutter type was electronic with exiftool).

The results I got was as below:

10-bit e-shutter:
GM1
GM5
GX85
G7
GH4

12-bit e-shutter:
GF7
GX850 (GF9)
GX8
GX9
G85

Need a e-shutter RW2 sample to determine:
GX7
GH5
GH5S
G9

As you can see, the 10-bit e-shutter also occurred in cameras after the GX8 (GX85 came after), but 12-bit also was before, even in the entry level cameras. I was a bit surprised at some (like how GF7 has 12-bit while GM series didn't). I think Panasonic mainly made a decision on each camera (slower readout vs 10-bit at faster readout), not really a set pattern or a specific date they decided to do one way or the other.

This is getting very off topic, so I will perhaps start another thread for reference, but I'm still missing a few samples of the modern cameras.
Nice piece of work (so far 😀) . Confirms since GX8, e-shutter does not drop from 12 to 10.

GH5 & G9 are known to be 12/12. Gh5S is 14bit, not sure if changes on e-shutter.
 
The one thing I don't like on my GX9 is that the buttons on the back are not just tiny, but they are nearly flush with the back of the camera and hard to feel. My fingers get lost if I'm trying to hit a button without looking at the back of the camera. I'm considering a drop or rubber cement or silicone on them so they're easier to feel.
 
I'm an engineering type and I prefer quantitative and repeatable results, so I did my own analysis using a repeatable method (which anyone can do themselves with free software). There was another post that said when a camera switches to 10-bit it ignores the lower 2 bits. So I used dcraw to convert the RW2 to a grayscale PGM file (keeping all unscaled/uninterpolated RAW data). I then examined it in a hex editor (I used HXD) and value of the lower 2 bits are "11" for almost all pixels in the 10-bit files (not the case for 12-bit). I wrote a program to count the occurrence of all the different values of the lower 2 bits to make things easier. I got e-shutter samples from the exposure latitude comparison tool in DPReview or searching through galleries of imaging resource or photographyblog for rw2 samples at shutter speeds higher than mechanical (I verified shutter type was electronic with exiftool).

The results I got was as below:

10-bit e-shutter:
GM1
GM5
GX85
G7
GH4

12-bit e-shutter:
GF7
GX850 (GF9)
GX8
GX9
G85

Need a e-shutter RW2 sample to determine:
GX7
GH5
GH5S
G9

As you can see, the 10-bit e-shutter also occurred in cameras after the GX8 (GX85 came after), but 12-bit also was before, even in the entry level cameras. I was a bit surprised at some (like how GF7 has 12-bit while GM series didn't). I think Panasonic mainly made a decision on each camera (slower readout vs 10-bit at faster readout), not really a set pattern or a specific date they decided to do one way or the other.

This is getting very off topic, so I will perhaps start another thread for reference, but I'm still missing a few samples of the modern cameras.
Nice piece of work (so far 😀) . Confirms since GX8, e-shutter does not drop from 12 to 10.

GH5 & G9 are known to be 12/12. Gh5S is 14bit, not sure if changes on e-shutter.
Actually the GX85 (announced 4/2016) that came after the GX8 (announced 7/2015) does drop from 12 to 10. So, as I said the GX8 is not a break point. I don't have samples for some of the later cameras (and also the GX7). The sensor datasheets suggest they should be full 12-bit, but I don't want to put that unless it is actually verified.
 
In relation to the “street photography” thing,. Anyone I wonder how to silence the shutter? I tuners down all the sounds to zero (same as my GX7) but I find when I press the shutter release the camera makes a sound like the shutter flaps about 3 times and it’s not quiet at all,.

Not a major issue but I would prefer if I could quiet it by at least half!
Did you enable electronic shutter already (REC > Shutter Type > ESHTR? Note that ESHTR may drop to 10-bit RAWs instead of 12-bit.

The other way is instead of turning all sounds to zero manually, just set the camera to silent mode in the custom menu. You can assign this to a function button if you want to toggle it on and off quickly.

If it's still making sounds, it may be the aperture of the lens. M43 focuses wide open and then stops down the lens when taking the picture. If you want to avoid this you can set the camera to "Constant Preview" in the Custom menu (note only works in M mode). This will have the aperture stopped down the entire time. Note that it may make focusing slower and also preview slower (as it simulates the shutter speed also).
I believe that with the GX8, and since, all Panasonic cameras do not drop bit rate when in ESHTR.
There was never any conclusive test done for the GX85 and GX9 that I have read, so it's unknown. For earlier cameras however it was known that the bit rate does drop.
When I got my GX9 I tested the eshtr modes of this and my gx80. Looking At the RAWs with rawdigger the GX9 produces indistinguishable files for both mechanical and electronic shutter. The GX80 RAWs are markedly different between eshtr and mechanical.

Conclusive? It is to me and I use GX9 in ESHTR unless I need to use mechanical.
I'm an engineering type and I prefer quantitative and repeatable results, so I did my own analysis using a repeatable method (which anyone can do themselves with free software). There was another post that said when a camera switches to 10-bit it ignores the lower 2 bits. So I used dcraw to convert the RW2 to a grayscale PGM file (keeping all unscaled/uninterpolated RAW data). I then examined it in a hex editor (I used HXD) and value of the lower 2 bits are "11" for almost all pixels in the 10-bit files (not the case for 12-bit). I wrote a program to count the occurrence of all the different values of the lower 2 bits to make things easier. I got e-shutter samples from the exposure latitude comparison tool in DPReview or searching through galleries of imaging resource or photographyblog for rw2 samples at shutter speeds higher than mechanical (I verified shutter type was electronic with exiftool).

The results I got was as below:

10-bit e-shutter:
GM1
GM5
GX85
G7
GH4

12-bit e-shutter:
GF7
GX850 (GF9)
GX8
GX9
G85

Need a e-shutter RW2 sample to determine:
GX7
GH5
GH5S
G9

As you can see, the 10-bit e-shutter also occurred in cameras after the GX8 (GX85 came after), but 12-bit also was before, even in the entry level cameras. I was a bit surprised at some (like how GF7 has 12-bit while GM series didn't). I think Panasonic mainly made a decision on each camera (slower readout vs 10-bit at faster readout), not really a set pattern or a specific date they decided to do one way or the other.

This is getting very off topic, so I will perhaps start another thread for reference, but I'm still missing a few samples of the modern cameras.
All good but my method is equally repeatable. Same image taken with electronic and mechanical shutter. In Rawdigger when there is a drop in the bit depth it is clear to see the more sparse data in the shadow end of the histogram... or look at the data values if you so desire but it is not necessary.

GX80 clearly 10-bit e-shutter

GX9 clearly same as mechanical
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top