"Tasco's Revenge" - The Cosina 100-400 F4.5-6.7

Adam-T

Veteran Member
Messages
64,380
Solutions
6
Reaction score
11,416
Location
Northwest, UK
Tasco's revenge -- The Cosina 100-400 F4.5-6.7*

"What Looketh like a Toy Telescope May be better than you think?"

£200s worth of pump zoom plastic in shiny Silver livery (the 100-300 was White!) it even has a red ring around the end and a metal lens mount - WOW, must be good .. Before you think that I've totally lost my marbles, I was on the city shooting some stock photos of the racecourse and popped into my dealer for a nosey at the 100-400L IS (which hadn't arrived) , but spotted this - errr "Alternative" so thought i'll have to give it a second go (the first time I used one was ages ago , a used example owned by an Elan-7 owner and it was awful) so thought that I'd try and make the best of it and report here ---- SOMEONE might be interested ..

The lens comes in one of those boxes you'd swear that had been used for Chinese fireworks in a previous life and it comes with a hood (Unlike the £550 canon 100 Macro) don't even think of operating the zoom straight out of the box , I thought it was locked at first, but , nope - it's really stiff, so mount it on the camera and slowly pull it (Don't do this on a Pre-Ti Rebel folks, you'll pull the lens mount out of the camera !) it DID zoom and smoothly , I have to report that it was quite easy by the end of the shoot and would be self-zooming in a week no doubt ..

Anyway on we forge - Luckily I had the 10D with me as F4.5-6.7 isn't the fastest aperture on the planet , so ramped it up to ISO400 for the Dingey conditions .. AF isn't noisy or even that slow for the price and it locked on sure and sweet ..

I shot the below shots handheld - they are the sharpest parts of course, only a couple front focussed, obviously the 10D was too quick for the lens ;-) ... to sumarise the quality - it's not as bad as the last one I tried, sharpness is actually not bad but the lens suffers very weak contrast and CA is terrible, as bad as the Canon 20-200 in fact ..

Given enough light, you'll get 8x10s from this lens after a bit of Photoshopping to up the contrast etc ! - great for 5x7s , I'd class this as a real casual zoom for small prints with respectable sharpness for the price , ideal for those places you don't want to take a 100-400L or 50-500EX - OR if you use this range rarely - don't go shooting sports on it is all I'm saying ..

Canon 10D on standard settings, ISO 400 - 100% Crops Wide open - Slight contrast adjustments to make up for the muggy day otherwise untouched ..



--
Please ignore the Typos, I'm the world's worst Typist

My Ugly mug and submitted Photos at -------->
http://www.photosig.com/go/users/userphotos?id=27855

 
It looks exactly like a silver painted Soligor AF100-400mm/F4,5-6,7 which my dealer gave to me while I was waiting for my delayed 70-200 L.

My conclusion from my test last year: surprizingly fast AF, but nothing else to write home about.
After my 70-200 arrived I gave it back without (besides testing) having used it.

--
Some digital cameras, some lenses, 2 eyes

http://www.tom-crowning.com
 
Mmn....more trips down to jessops!! HAHAHA!.....BOUGHT THE WRONG PLASTIC FAN~ LAST TIME!! better get this one right aye?

keep up the good work mate....we cant all blow wedges of cash on gear, and to find someone willing to at least show a little divergence is very welcome..

great web site too…..

walshy
 
If I ever got pictures as muggy and bland as that (esp. AFTER upping contrast) out of my 10D, I'd pitch it out the window with extreme prejudice.

Great lens for the price? Sure! On a rebel G.
 
Also Have a look at the used lenses - though avoid the Canon 100-300USM, it's softer than that Cosina - don't pay Jessops prices either, price match them from Camera world or whatever ..

Cheap old used Telezoom lenses to look out for are the 70-210USM (Bit soft at the long end but servicable) the 100-300 F5.6 (Not actually tried one but supposed to be OK for under £100 - the L version IS superb and goes for about £350 - f5.6 is pretty slow though and AF is also)

--
Please ignore the Typos, I'm the world's worst Typist

My Ugly mug and submitted Photos at -------->
http://www.photosig.com/go/users/userphotos?id=27855

 
I said respectable sharpness for the price and commented that the contrast was weak, I also said OK for up to 8x10s.. no one would dream that it was a 100-400L alternative....

i'm NOT recommending it , Sheesh for not a lot more you can get an old Canon like the 70-210USM

--
Please ignore the Typos, I'm the world's worst Typist

My Ugly mug and submitted Photos at -------->
http://www.photosig.com/go/users/userphotos?id=27855

 
Also Have a look at the used lenses - though avoid the Canon
100-300USM, it's softer than that Cosina - don't pay Jessops prices
either, price match them from Camera world or whatever ..

Cheap old used Telezoom lenses to look out for are the 70-210USM
(Bit soft at the long end but servicable) the 100-300 F5.6 (Not
actually tried one but supposed to be OK for under £100 - the L
version IS superb and goes for about £350 - f5.6 is pretty slow
though and AF is also)

--
Please ignore the Typos, I'm the world's worst Typist

My Ugly mug and submitted Photos at -------->
http://www.photosig.com/go/users/userphotos?id=27855

Thanks for your advise...checked out a couple of sites and forums...i located one bloke in the midlands who wanted £120 for the canon 70-210usm f3.5/4.5.....thought it was dear till i went to have a look...wow still boxed and mint with his purchase receipt etc...he has an 'is' now and no need for it... so i bought it as he wouldn’t drop and and i had just driven 70miles!!....fool and his money?....no chance!!

walshy
 
the canon 70-210usm f3.5/4.5.....thought it was dear till i went to
have a look...wow still boxed and mint with his purchase receipt
etc...
that's not expensive - they fetch more than that om E-Bay you got a great buy for the same price as a cheapo 75-300 Sigma or whatever.. have fun, you'll geta lot of mileage out of that

--
Please ignore the Typos, I'm the world's worst Typist

My Ugly mug and submitted Photos at -------->
http://www.photosig.com/go/users/userphotos?id=27855

 
I just ordered a D100, so I have no business here, but I love your fearlessness when it comes to putting anything on a camera and seeing what the result is.

I can hear the equipment snobs snickering, but you dare to venture where few would ever go, a true explorer. I'm waiting for the Coke bottle comparison with, say, a Canon L lens.

I bet you have quite an array of guilty pleasures when it comes to movies and music.

BTW, if anyone could have persuaded me to buy the 10d it would have been you, man. But I have this irrational belief that the D100 shares some lineage with my beloved classic Nikon manual focus cameras (oh, that smooth ball bearing sound of the wind lever on my FM2) even though my beloved Nikon AI lenses are completely hobbled on my soon to arrive "plastic fantastic" DSLR.

Adam-T wrote:
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top