Thrown out

I, for one, have more sympathy with the mall. When I go to the mall
(frankly, when I'm out in public, but I have little control then),
I do not have any desire to have my picture taken. If I were to
look around and see somebody pointing a camera at me (and you were
a perfect stranger to me), I would be offended.
See above post--I'm not a 'candid' photographer, but point well taken.

Diane--Diane B http://www.pbase.com/picnic/galleriesB/W lover, but color is seducing me
 
I understood that from your post... but of course the mall wouldn't.

Let us know what happens if you ask the management for permission. They may not have a problem with it as long as you ask first. I remember my parents always claimed to be like that... it's ok as long as you ask first... lol

--Patrick
I, for one, have more sympathy with the mall. When I go to the mall
(frankly, when I'm out in public, but I have little control then),
I do not have any desire to have my picture taken. If I were to
look around and see somebody pointing a camera at me (and you were
a perfect stranger to me), I would be offended.
See above post--I'm not a 'candid' photographer, but point well taken.

Diane
--
Diane B
http://www.pbase.com/picnic/galleries
B/W lover, but color is seducing me
--Patrick Martin http://www.patrickmartin.com
 
Thomas, if left unguarded window display espionage just might bring down whole nations. I think we are talking some pretty serious concerns here. I think you really should as you suggest assume a cover name and a good disguise, lest the mall police find you out, and subject you to unknown horrors and tortures. :-) This is just a little fun and not intended to berate the subject at hand which I do feel strongly about.
It seems our freedoms we once enjoyed are slowly slipping away. On
a lighter side Thomas I think that as a result of your photo you
would be a prime suspect as a new student at the photographers
underworld school of mall photography.

Happy shooting, Rick
--
-tom- Canon G1
http://members.tripod.com/tlmarsh1/

 
I understood that from your post... but of course the mall wouldn't.

Let us know what happens if you ask the management for permission.
They may not have a problem with it as long as you ask first. I
remember my parents always claimed to be like that... it's ok as
long as you ask first... lol
Patrick, to be truthful, I doubt that I ever would. I'm not a mall type person, so this has made it not very interesting to me at all. Those who do candids may be more forthcoming about their experiences in similar situations--I'm usually outdoors, on the trail or on the road or on the street. I wish I hadn't started the thread, but I was a bit miffed when I got home---but in rethinking it, it should have occurred to me. I wouldn't ask for permission--I just wouldn't take a camera into such a place.

Diane--Diane B http://www.pbase.com/picnic/galleriesB/W lover, but color is seducing me
 
Just to add my two cents worth to this most interesting thread. I went to Four Season's Mall in Greensboro NC about 10 days ago and spent about 40 minutes walking around taking pictures of plants, people, the workmen setting up the Christmas decorations, the decorations themselves, some of the individuals who work in the mall in their work environment, store fronts etc. Was using a D30 with battery grip handheld. Didn't even think there might be a problem. No one ever said a thing to me, only got one curious look from a shop owner of a shoe repair facility then he struck up a nice pose for me. Guess it all depends on location and general attitude of personel involved.--Rick
 
Just to add my two cents worth to this most interesting thread. I
went to Four Season's Mall in Greensboro NC about 10 days ago and
spent about 40 minutes walking around taking pictures of plants,
people, the workmen setting up the Christmas decorations, the
decorations themselves, some of the individuals who work in the
mall in their work environment, store fronts etc. Was using a D30
with battery grip handheld. Didn't even think there might be a
problem. No one ever said a thing to me, only got one curious look
from a shop owner of a shoe repair facility then he struck up a
nice pose for me. Guess it all depends on location and general
attitude of personel involved.
--
Rick
Rick, coincidence. I'm in Hickory (Valley Hills Mall) and was at Hanes in Winston today---and think they may be owned by same folks. I was round and about doing similar until a guard spotted me/no one else complained or looked even threatened about me shooting 'inanimate' objects--maybe no one saw you--or perhaps Four Seasons is more flexible.

Diane--Diane B http://www.pbase.com/picnic/galleriesB/W lover, but color is seducing me
 
I guess I'm fortunate .. I had a model that wanted part of the shoot done in Abercrombies .. We headed out, and I went in the store first. I talked to the manager, threw her a couple of cards and told her what we were doing and promised to be quick and unobtrusive. She was more than happy to let us use the store. We were gone in 15 min, with no toes stepped on. You'd be amazed at what you get just by first asking, and not assuming or just trying - "daring" someone to tell you that you can't photograph.

Regarding historical areas. I'm in Austin, TX and the state capitol is here. I go there at least twice a week to do bridals and children's portraiture. The Cap Police are MORE than friendly. I've seen them hold people off the main rotunda floor so that I could finish my shots. I even had one officer run to get towels for a bride to dry the stems of her boquet so that it would not drip on her dress !!!! People here just don't even seem to care about cameras... other than recognizing what may be a "professional" rig .. and asking for cards, information, "what kind of camera is that" etc .. Maybe Texas is just a friendly place .. I"ll consider myself lucky and enjoy it. ! .. TNT --Temple http://www.austinphoto.com
 
The moment one gives close attention to anything, even a blade of grass,
it becomes a mysterious, awesome, indescribably magnificent world in
itself.
-Henry Miller, novelist (1891-1980)

:-)

regards
 
This didn't get any responses the first time I posted but I really like this one. I really felt for this guy cause I feel the same way when I am waiting for my girlfriend.



nite
 
Having said that, I'll add that I have twice been asked to stop
taking pictures. Once was in a specialty retailer, presumably for
the reason mentioned above. The second time was in the Laguna
Hills Mall, CA, where I was taking pictures of my family. The
guard told me that it was for security reasons. He said that with
all of the jewelry stores in the mall that there was a concern that
people could use a camera to note things like camera placement or
anything else that might aid in a robbery or burglary. That one
threw me for a loop (was my kindergartener daughter looking
particularly suspicious to him that day???), but I decided not to
make a fuss and put my camera away.

-Jim
I think the guard was suspicious not because you looked suspicious but because he's trained to be suspicious of everyone. I've heard that on the subway, the best pickpockets are not the people who look grungy or young and punky - the pro pickpockets know how to camouflage; they're clean-cut and dress like business executives so you won't have your guard up around them. In a world where the way people look is no sure indication of what they might do, a bit of paranoia becomes integral to security.
 
This business about mall photography not being allowed amazes me. I seldom take pictures in a mall, except for Santa photos of the grandkids. I have found in a few malls that they have those areas set up so it's almost impossible to get a picture of a kid on Santas lap.

I was recently in Washington DC (this Oct.) to be exact, and drove by the Pentagon. I wanted a picture of the damage but was leary of takng photos of the building or gettng to close, until I noticed people all over the place on a hill nearby. I drove down, parked in the Pentagon parking lot, walked up to the fence and proceded to take several photos. There were armed guards around and not one said a word. I think they were there more to keep people out of the construction area than to prevent picture taking. If you can take pictures of that, I don't understand not being allowed to take pictures in a mall.

If I am in a museum I always ask if pictures are allowed. Sometimes they are, sometimes not, and sometimes only without flash, and I try to follow their rules. I have never been kicked out of a place for taking photos.

Paul
 
Being an older person, I can remember the 1950's and the freedoms we enjoyed. Freedoms that were excepted by our peers and law enforcement agencies.

I feel that life in our society (here in the U.S.) is suffering from group neurosis. Paranoia specifically. It's running rampant. People are scared of their own shadow and work to question everything that everyone is doing as though what other people are doing is subversive.

Another aspect of this group mental illness is a need for people to become authoritarian figures whether they have a right to do so or not.

As an example. I have fished a local harbor close to where I live for the last 40 years. Suddenly, security guards are telling me that I can't fish there anymore. I demanded to see the head man. The Port Authority himself. With the guards and the Port Authority in the same room, I pushed the issue. I knew my rights. They had no right to refuse me access to the waterfront. This is a Federal Law. Everything below the maximum high tide mark is Public Domain. These jokers (I call them that because their actions was a joke, a sick one) are not untypical in our present world. People make things up as they go along. And, because too many people accept this type of false authority, it is growning in leaps and bounds.

Question authority. Demand to see the person at the top. Register your complaint with local news agencies. Write your local representitives.
 
This is why I take pictures of only ducks and flowers.
Has anyone else had a similar experience?? (I remember someone
having something like this in San Fran, I think--maybe not on this
forum).
So far, I've been:

1. Invited to stop shooting building construction from a sidewalk,
I told the guy to take a hike.
2. Invited to stop shooting bridge construction from the highway
right of way. I suggested the guy call a cop.
3. Ordered out of a highway construction area. They got me there, I
left.
4. Refused entry into a monument/concrete ornament place because,
"We've got some copy righted items." I left.
5. Ordered out of an office building because I could be taking
pictures to find out where to put a bomb. The guy had a gun, so I
left.
6. Had my ID run through NCIC by a sheriff because I was taking
pictures of graffiti on box cars. She suggest I just move along,
because you never can tell in times like these.

As far as I'm concerned, I will act as though I intend no harm. If
I'm asked to leave a place by someone who has authority over that
place, I'll leave. Otherwise, I'm not doing anything illegal, and
they are welcome to call a cop.

hugh
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- http://www.sesee.com/Photo/Galleries/Galleries.asp
 
Well said Rob. Unfortunately since Sept 11 people seem to be accepting the fact that it is now okay for the government or any official looking entity to push them around at will. Our current administration has just opened the door to legal phone tapping and internet monitoring. Our most basic freedoms and rights are quickly dissappearing. Many innocent people are going to be questioned, harrassed and wrongfully prosecuted because of these law changes. They have just given anyone with any authority the right to pry into and question our private lives. We now have to be careful what we say in public and private for fear of being reported, suspected, detained, questioned and possibly prosecuted for suspision of possibly being involved in anything subversive. Big brother is watching and now no one has complete freedom of speech or is any longer protected by that constitutional right. This may seem a somewhat extreme view, but this is the reality if you take all that has happened since Sept 11 into account. Anyone who would deny this view should stop and think about how their responses to certain issues has changed since then. I for one know that I now am cautious about what I say and to whom I say it to. I have nothing to hide. But now there is that fear in the back of my head that someone may misunderstand or not comprehend the intent of a statement or verbal thought and take that out of context, possibly submitting me to arrest or detainment for questioning just for voicing an opinion or private view. It is a shame that our government instead of accepting responsibility and working on correcting thier inter agency deficiencies have elected to instead oppress its constituents. And unfortunately in light of all this it seems as though most other security and law enforcement agencies have jumped on the band wagon and are using it as an excuse to overly exert their authority on the rest of us. Please don't misunderstand me. I am not a radical or extremist. I am only worried that this whole issue may snowball into an avalanche of unnecesary restraints and controls. Censorship is not good. It violates one of our most basic rights. The freedom of speech!
Being an older person, I can remember the 1950's and the freedoms
we enjoyed. Freedoms that were excepted by our peers and law
enforcement agencies.
I feel that life in our society (here in the U.S.) is suffering
from group neurosis. Paranoia specifically. It's running rampant.
People are scared of their own shadow and work to question
everything that everyone is doing as though what other people are
doing is subversive.
Another aspect of this group mental illness is a need for people to
become authoritarian figures whether they have a right to do so or
not.
As an example. I have fished a local harbor close to where I live
for the last 40 years. Suddenly, security guards are telling me
that I can't fish there anymore. I demanded to see the head man.
The Port Authority himself. With the guards and the Port Authority
in the same room, I pushed the issue. I knew my rights. They had no
right to refuse me access to the waterfront. This is a Federal Law.
Everything below the maximum high tide mark is Public Domain. These
jokers (I call them that because their actions was a joke, a sick
one) are not untypical in our present world. People make things up
as they go along. And, because too many people accept this type of
false authority, it is growning in leaps and bounds.
Question authority. Demand to see the person at the top. Register
your complaint with local news agencies. Write your local
representitives.
 
Unfortunately the lean towards a totalitarian state began well before Sept. 11. Constitutional rights are being blatantly tromped on. ALL law enforcement agencies need probable cause according to the constitution to arrest or detain a suspect.

What is that probable cause? Is it walking down the street in broad daylight. I would think not. However, I've been stopped by local police and frisked without any probable cause whatsoever. Many others have also.

Two older German immigrants I used to fish with before they locked up the park we fished in, both came from Germany in the 1930s. They witnessed the rise of **** Germany. According to them, their former freedoms were taken away gradually. By the time the citizens of that era in Germany were aware of what was happening it was too late! Those two former German citizens tell me that EXACTLY the same thing has been occuring in the U.S. I agree. I've watched it occur. Like you, I'm mildly afraid to walk down the street anymore.

I feel that the gradual elimination of freedoms is about to peak. Most people are too young to remember what a free country is like. As us older citizens die out, the younger citizens taking our place won't have the necessary experience of living in a free country. They've grown up within a restrictive society and as a consequence don't bother to question further elimination of freedoms.

I'm appaled by the views of our representitives regarding the current military tribunals that are to be used against those who may be linked to terrorism. I hope those jokers don't figure me as a possibility. I do have a beard! Shouldn't need to think that way but conditions are making that sort of thinking a necessity. It's time to cover your butt and keep your thoughts primarily to ones self. Sad state of affairs. Glad I'm old and don't have much time left. I shudder at the thought of what conditions will be like 20 years hence! :(
 
Patrick,

Unfortunately, my momma taught me "it's easier to get forgiveness than permission" ;-)
I understood that from your post... but of course the mall wouldn't.

Let us know what happens if you ask the management for permission.
They may not have a problem with it as long as you ask first. I
remember my parents always claimed to be like that... it's ok as
long as you ask first... lol
 
Indeed Rob it is the lack of concern regarding this issue that is scary. And what is even more frightening is allowing our government to practice censorship terrorism on its constituents.
Unfortunately the lean towards a totalitarian state began well
before Sept. 11. Constitutional rights are being blatantly tromped
on. ALL law enforcement agencies need probable cause according to
the constitution to arrest or detain a suspect.
What is that probable cause? Is it walking down the street in broad
daylight. I would think not. However, I've been stopped by local
police and frisked without any probable cause whatsoever. Many
others have also.
Two older German immigrants I used to fish with before they locked
up the park we fished in, both came from Germany in the 1930s. They
witnessed the rise of **** Germany. According to them, their former
freedoms were taken away gradually. By the time the citizens of
that era in Germany were aware of what was happening it was too
late! Those two former German citizens tell me that EXACTLY the
same thing has been occuring in the U.S. I agree. I've watched it
occur. Like you, I'm mildly afraid to walk down the street anymore.
I feel that the gradual elimination of freedoms is about to peak.
Most people are too young to remember what a free country is like.
As us older citizens die out, the younger citizens taking our place
won't have the necessary experience of living in a free country.
They've grown up within a restrictive society and as a consequence
don't bother to question further elimination of freedoms.
I'm appaled by the views of our representitives regarding the
current military tribunals that are to be used against those who
may be linked to terrorism. I hope those jokers don't figure me as
a possibility. I do have a beard! Shouldn't need to think that way
but conditions are making that sort of thinking a necessity. It's
time to cover your butt and keep your thoughts primarily to ones
self. Sad state of affairs. Glad I'm old and don't have much time
left. I shudder at the thought of what conditions will be like 20
years hence! :(
 
.
Rob, my strangest brush with the law came in the late 40's. I was just back home from the service and had been doing 10 and 12 hour shifts in a Navy hospital as a corpsman. I was in a little cafe in Texas having a coke and listening to the jukebox when the town marshal and his deputy walked in. " Hey boy. Come out here on the sidewalk with us, we want to talk to you." I went out and it was, "You've been doing time haven't you son?" "No Sir". "Now boy don't think you can put something over on me, I've seen plenty like you before, you've got what they call prison pallor, pale face, haven't seen the sun for a long while, huh boy?" I was actually kind of amused but dared not express it. I had my Navy discharge wallet card and ID and he kind of apoligized when I showed it to him. If I had been out with no ID I would have been really hassled and detained for awhile. I know they were just out doing their job, was not offended.
...lectraglide
 
I was able to get quite a few shots of this plane and the Joint Strike Fighter, although when I went behind the plane to get a photo of the rear I was told “SIR, DO NOT TAKE THAT PHOTO” It came from a strong sounding serious voice that meant what it was saying. I was then informed that my camera WOULD be taken I would be arrested if I tried to “sneak” a photo. Well when a man with a M-16 tells you something or for that matter 8 men and a 1 woman with M-16s tell you something they might just mean it. This was back when “OUR” P-3 was still in China.

 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top