Bassman2003
Senior Member
I watched all three videos and everything looks as expected except the playback errors on the 60p footage. I kept my mouse over a certain point in the playback marker timeline and kept bringing the video back to that point and playing. The random stutters were falling in similar but different places each time. Weird. It looks like some kind of YouTube playback issue or, issues with the encoded file. Maybe try encoding the 60p file in a few different formats and uploading to YT to test.
So as far as panning, everything looks normal which means you have to learn to work within the parameters of your chosen framerate. As far as shutter speed, I have always used 1/60th for 60p as I think it looks better for motion. (the 180 deg rule is more more 24p & 30p).
As a general approach, try to limit panning anyway unless you have to. If you pan, try moving the camera along a circular arc in the opposite direction of the pan. This is referred to as an orbit move. It is a way to limit judder when filming in 24p.
So bottom line, 24p & 30 will give you judder when you pan from a fixed location. That does not mean they are useless. Pick your framerate at the beginning of your project based upon what you will be filming or if you have a certain requirement (like 24p for cinema etc...) Then you can adjust how you will approach the filming. Use higher framerates for more camera movement and a "live look". Use slower framerates for more storytelling.
So as far as panning, everything looks normal which means you have to learn to work within the parameters of your chosen framerate. As far as shutter speed, I have always used 1/60th for 60p as I think it looks better for motion. (the 180 deg rule is more more 24p & 30p).
As a general approach, try to limit panning anyway unless you have to. If you pan, try moving the camera along a circular arc in the opposite direction of the pan. This is referred to as an orbit move. It is a way to limit judder when filming in 24p.
So bottom line, 24p & 30 will give you judder when you pan from a fixed location. That does not mean they are useless. Pick your framerate at the beginning of your project based upon what you will be filming or if you have a certain requirement (like 24p for cinema etc...) Then you can adjust how you will approach the filming. Use higher framerates for more camera movement and a "live look". Use slower framerates for more storytelling.
I have S5 - a wonderful camera, always (almost always) use 50p/60p to have a smooth playback. The biggest disadvantage is crop :-(
