Getting rid of tiny white dots?

Flycaster

Senior Member
Messages
2,823
Solutions
22
Reaction score
500
Location
Boynton Beach, FL, US
I am using Photoshop Elements 2025, and trialing Photolab 9 on my PC. In the edited photo below, see the many little white dots. How should I eliminate or not even have them? I know I can eliminate them by using PSE's spot healing brush, but that is just too tedious, and Filters>noise>Despeckle doesn't work. Is the appearance of these dots related to over-sharpening, or do they come with the territory? Thanks.



79e7db1e31e3431ca6e54b7a04185a60.jpg
 
How should I eliminate or not even have them?
Don't overprocess photos.
Is the appearance of these dots related to over-sharpening, or do they come with the territory?
They're objects that exist in the original scene, but transformed by your processing, Everything in the image looks like a painting when viewed at full magnification,
 
How should I eliminate or not even have them?
Don't overprocess photos.
This was not a good photo to begin with, and i know that I over-processed...which is something I know I have to control.
Is the appearance of these dots related to over-sharpening, or do they come with the territory?
They're objects that exist in the original scene, but transformed by your processing,
But, even if I didn't over-process, all those dots probably still would have appeared. Here's a jpg of the raw. RAW sent to PSE's ARC (no intentional editing) and then to PSE (no intentional editing,) and then saved. Interested in seeing what you can do (not using blemish tool) to remove spots:



af89f9829bc84cc29e217c9a574f81aa.jpg

Everything in the image looks like a painting when viewed at full magnification,
Yeah, I know it wasn't a great capture to begin with, just wanted to send an example.
 
They're objects that exist in the original scene, but transformed by your processing,
But, even if I didn't over-process, all those dots probably still would have appeared.
Because they exist in the scene.
Here's a jpg of the raw. RAW sent to PSE's ARC (no intentional editing) and then to PSE (no intentional editing,) and then saved. Interested in seeing what you can do (not using blemish tool) to remove spots:

af89f9829bc84cc29e217c9a574f81aa.jpg
I don't want to remove them. They were there. Notice how there are absolutely none in the out-of-focus background, so they were not introduced by the sensor.

Your DOF was very shallow, so only a few parts of the scene are in good focus. You might have to live with that, depending on how large the final result needs to be.

I ran that JPEG through Topaz Photo AI with only some noise reduction (which automatically applies a bit of sharpness as well):

4d4596bcf45e4e71891f76c8571f94b1.jpg

That's as far as I would go. If you want the spots removed without doing any manual work, you could try an AI tool as suggested earlier.
 
Last edited:
I am using Photoshop Elements 2025, and trialing Photolab 9 on my PC. In the edited photo below, see the many little white dots. How should I eliminate or not even have them? I know I can eliminate them by using PSE's spot healing brush, but that is just too tedious, and Filters>noise>Despeckle doesn't work. Is the appearance of these dots related to over-sharpening, or do they come with the territory? Thanks.

79e7db1e31e3431ca6e54b7a04185a60.jpg
Those are things that were really there but you exaggerated them by overprocessing the image. What settings did you use?

--
Tom
 
I don't know if they have a free trial, but the PS plugin SRDx from Lasersoft Imaging sometimes does a surprising job depending on the photo.
 
Last edited:


That's as far as I would go. If you want the spots removed without doing any manual work, you could try an AI tool as suggested earlier.
I did look at some of the free AI's, but they all seemed to use a "blemish tool,' which means doing the removal manually. Could you suggest an AI that one would have to do is request that the white dots be removed?
 
That's as far as I would go. If you want the spots removed without doing any manual work, you could try an AI tool as suggested earlier.
I did look at some of the free AI's, but they all seemed to use a "blemish tool,' which means doing the removal manually.
I'm talking about AIs that accept text prompts as instructions to alter images, like this: 'Remove the white spots in this attached photo.'
Could you suggest an AI that one would have to do is request that the white dots be removed?
I cannot. The ones I know about will only produce tiny images of about 1-2 megapixels, which I'm sure would be useless for your purposes. Others here might have suggestions, though.
 
I don't know if they have a free trial, but the PS plugin SRDx from Lasersoft Imaging sometimes does a surprising job depending on the photo.
Crappy screenshots, but here are

original photo, marked photo, and "optimized" photo using SRDx:



89706f774ab2481c91cf757647d2bb4f.jpg



c9211d36a21f4ebcbe857ea6abe6abe2.jpg



c79aa4730a024c93aba84e2fb3d76063.jpg
 
Those are things that were really there but you exaggerated them by overprocessing the image. What settings did you use?
Don't recall the ued settings, but I obviously did over process a poor image.
 
Those are things that were really there but you exaggerated them by overprocessing the image. What settings did you use?
Don't recall the ued settings, but I obviously did over process a poor image.
I have found that too much micro contrast causes that effect.
 
Those are things that were really there but you exaggerated them by overprocessing the image. What settings did you use?
Don't recall the ued settings, but I obviously did over process a poor image.
I have found that too much micro contrast causes that effect.
I know that I did use "some" micro contrast, but can't recall how much. However, I just dl'd SDRx for a free trial. Really don't know how to efficiently use it, but giving it a rough try, it seems to do a reasonable job in getting rid of most of the white spots. Only thing is that the masking tools seem to be missing in the trial? Now, I have to decide if $49 is worth it? Then again, knowing I tend to over process, it might be good to have?
 
Last edited:
I just tried the SRDx trial and it seems to work real well. My only question is that the trial seems to be missing the masking tools. Maybe they will be there with the paid for version?
 
I just tried the SRDx trial and it seems to work real well. My only question is that the trial seems to be missing the masking tools. Maybe they will be there with the paid for version?
Yes, the masking tools work for me in Windows 10 and 11.
 
If I can control my tendency to over process..fine; but, if not, it looks as though SRDx is going to fit the bill. Just been doing some initial editing with it, and it certainly does a good job. Here's a before and after. BTW, the free trial winds up with a huge water mark, but I still think you should be able to see a remarkable difference.

Before



3a2e42aedf6240e792ecd7504702a4fe.jpg

After



881a80f9d2fc478891bf7598b6125cdf.jpg
 
enjoy!
 
Despeckle is not strong enough to handle these relatively large white spots. Instead, use the Dust and Scratches filter. A radius of around 8 and threshold of around 70 nicely cleans up the white spots without having much of an effect on the rest of the fine detail. Here's your unedited version cleaned up with those settings and nothing else changed:

870005916c9d4c42bd6aa834aaf5a0d2.jpg
 
Despeckle is not strong enough to handle these relatively large white spots. Instead, use the Dust and Scratches filter. A radius of around 8 and threshold of around 70 nicely cleans up the white spots without having much of an effect on the rest of the fine detail. Here's your unedited version cleaned up with those settings and nothing else changed:

870005916c9d4c42bd6aa834aaf5a0d2.jpg
Which program was used?
 
Despeckle is not strong enough to handle these relatively large white spots. Instead, use the Dust and Scratches filter. A radius of around 8 and threshold of around 70 nicely cleans up the white spots without having much of an effect on the rest of the fine detail. Here's your unedited version cleaned up with those settings and nothing else changed:

870005916c9d4c42bd6aa834aaf5a0d2.jpg
Which program was used?
Photoshop, but I'm pretty certain that PSE also has this filter.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top