Filter question

[Tuxster]

I pre-ordered the Sony 28-70 f/2 lens and will most likely need a new filter as i don't have an 86mm.

Was thinking if getting a variable ND filter. I did see this one, B+W 95mm XS-Pro Digital Vario ND with Multi-Resistant Nano Coating.

Any other recommendations?

Mj

 

[LenRivers]

See if a square filter system might be an option.

 

[Bijo S]

VNDs are fine for videography. But if its for photography, get fixed nd filters.

 

[Tuxster]

See if a square filter system might be an option.

I think I would prefer a filter that screws on.

 

[LenRivers]

See if a square filter system might be an option.

I think I would prefer a filter that screws on.

86 mm is a non standard size so in that case it would take some research to see if there is a step up ring 86 mm - 95 mm

So far as variable ND

Polapro is an option for vari ND

For solid ND I like Breakthrough Technology filters I use and like as well.

B&W, Hoya, Heliopan, Tiffen HT line it decent.

https://www.polarpro.com

 

[Planterz]

Variable ND filters, even expensive ones, can get the dreaded dark X at wide angles. Whether one will get you the results you want (or ruin them) depends on what you're shooting and how.

 

[Tuxster]

See if a square filter system might be an option.

I think I would prefer a filter that screws on.

86 mm is a non standard size so in that case it would take some research to see if there is a step up ring 86 mm - 95 mm

So far as variable ND

Polapro is an option for vari ND

For solid ND I like Breakthrough Technology filters I use and like as well.

B&W, Hoya, Heliopan, Tiffen HT line it decent.

https://www.polarpro.com

Wondering if a 95mm on a step up ring would fit under the hood??

 

[Tuxster]

Variable ND filters, even expensive ones, can get the dreaded dark X at wide angles. Whether one will get you the results you want (or ruin them) depends on what you're shooting and how.

Definitely something to watch for. I wonder how many people use a variable on their 24-70 lens and have this issue.

 

[LenRivers]

See if a square filter system might be an option.

I think I would prefer a filter that screws on.

86 mm is a non standard size so in that case it would take some research to see if there is a step up ring 86 mm - 95 mm

So far as variable ND

Polapro is an option for vari ND

For solid ND I like Breakthrough Technology filters I use and like as well.

B&W, Hoya, Heliopan, Tiffen HT line it decent.

https://www.polarpro.com

Wondering if a 95mm on a step up ring would fit under the hood??

Honestly don’t know

 

[Tuxster]

I have researched this a bit more. Ya, 86mm is a non standard so not so easy to find filters so a new plan has been adopted.

Would you prefer to use a 100mm square system or use the Nisi 95mm ND kit with a NiSi SWIFT 86-95mm System Adaptor Ring.

Thoughts ?

 

[Maxmolly7]

I have researched this a bit more. Ya, 86mm is a non standard so not so easy to find filters so a new plan has been adopted.

Would you prefer to use a 100mm square system or use the Nisi 95mm ND kit with a NiSi SWIFT 86-95mm System Adaptor Ring.

Thoughts ?

I was never really happy to use sheet filters, because a lens hood can longer be used which might be critical under certain light condiditions.
I bought a modular hood for my Cokin P system (only up to 82mm), but never really used it due to the added bulk.

For your purpose (86mm) you would need their Z or the even larger X-Pro system holder.

 

[gnPhoto]

Haida Nanopro Magnetic series is pretty good.

I have used them quite a bit over the last one year... magnetic snapping makes it very easy... I think they have 95mm variant also...

The following photos are taken with Haida CPL + ND filters, I have not noticed any degradation of color or sharpness...

1.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

2.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

3.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

4.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

Good luck

https://www.instagram.com/neelagopi/

 

[UncleVanya]

I have researched this a bit more. Ya, 86mm is a non standard so not so easy to find filters so a new plan has been adopted.

Would you prefer to use a 100mm square system or use the Nisi 95mm ND kit with a NiSi SWIFT 86-95mm System Adaptor Ring.

Will you want to use a hood? Would a 95mm screw in hood be ok? How frequently will the nd be used?

Since the original post 86mm filters have started to become more available. This NiSi is a fine filter but pricey. https://nisiopticsusa.com/product/n...cPjc_DTgNfsN2hc-CKsbOqjkrjagXT68QU2LEDjb9ledc