Recommendations on Carbon Fiber Tripods (without center column)

ShutterMama

New member
Messages
8
Reaction score
1
Location
SF Bay Area, CA, US
Hello all-

I am looking to buy a carbon fiber tripod without the center column and with the ball head sold seperately.

Does anyone use the tripod from "The Right Stuff". Do you like it? Pros vs cons?

Any other recommendations and I am only looking to spend 800-900 on the tripod. I know some can go upto 1,000.

Thank you for any suggestions.
 
Hello all-

I am looking to buy a carbon fiber tripod without the center column and with the ball head sold seperately.

Does anyone use the tripod from "The Right Stuff". Do you like it? Pros vs cons?

Any other recommendations and I am only looking to spend 800-900 on the tripod. I know some can go upto 1,000.

Thank you for any suggestions.
It would be helpful to get some additional information upfront to make some reasonable suggestions at all, considering the wide selection of tripod legs in the market:

- how tall are you?

- in what shooting conditions do you want to use the setup?

- what mobility requirements do you have for the setup (hiking, airplane travel, etc.)?

- what (ball) head to you plan to use?

- do you plan the get more demanding photography equipment in the future, means bigger lenses and camera?

Herbert
 
Before you can get very far into the purchase of a CF tripod, first you need to know the weight of your camera+lens. Nearly all tripods have a weight limit. Also, if you add up the weight of the camera+lens and get ten pounds, then you may want to get a tripod with twice that limit, because you never know which other lens you might have next year. My camera+lens is nearly fifteen pounds, and due to the length of the lens and its effect on center of gravity, I opted for a tripod with a weight limit of 25 pounds.

Also, if you shoot birds in flight, you may be using a long lens. In order to balance that on the tripod, the front of the lens may be sticking out in front a lot, and then the camera body will be sticking out in back. Then, as a flying bird approaches, you find the need to elevate the front of the lens more and more. That means that the camera body will be going downward more and more. In order to have your eyeball to the viewfinder, you will need to have the entire camera and lens higher than normal. So, I opted for a tripod that was roughly equal to my own height or slightly higher.
 
Hello all-

I am looking to buy a carbon fiber tripod without the center column and with the ball head sold seperately.

Does anyone use the tripod from "The Right Stuff". Do you like it? Pros vs cons?

Any other recommendations and I am only looking to spend 800-900 on the tripod. I know some can go upto 1,000.

Thank you for any suggestions.
It would be helpful to get some additional information upfront to make some reasonable suggestions at all, considering the wide selection of tripod legs in the market:

- how tall are you? 5ft 11

- in what shooting conditions do you want to use the setup? landscape, city

- what mobility requirements do you have for the setup (hiking, airplane travel, etc.)? I will be using it for mostly hiking and traveling in a car. I am not sure if I would take it with me on extended trips though.

- what (ball) head to you plan to use? Not sure yet but I was looking at

BH-55 Ball Head with Lever-Release Panning Clamp or

BH-40 Ball Head with Screw-Knob Panning Clamp


- do you plan the get more demanding photography equipment in the future, means bigger lenses and camera? Yes, I do plan on buying a bigger lens

Herbert
See my replies above. Thank you for the help.
 
Before you can get very far into the purchase of a CF tripod, first you need to know the weight of your camera+lens. Nearly all tripods have a weight limit. Also, if you add up the weight of the camera+lens and get ten pounds, then you may want to get a tripod with twice that limit, because you never know which other lens you might have next year. My camera+lens is nearly fifteen pounds, and due to the length of the lens and its effect on center of gravity, I opted for a tripod with a weight limit of 25 pounds.

Also, if you shoot birds in flight, you may be using a long lens. In order to balance that on the tripod, the front of the lens may be sticking out in front a lot, and then the camera body will be sticking out in back. Then, as a flying bird approaches, you find the need to elevate the front of the lens more and more. That means that the camera body will be going downward more and more. In order to have your eyeball to the viewfinder, you will need to have the entire camera and lens higher than normal. So, I opted for a tripod that was roughly equal to my own height or slightly higher.
I won't be photographing birds. I will be shooting landscapes, cityscapes and seascapes. Maybe some shots that are avation related.

My camera body is a Canon 6D and my current lens are: 24-105 and the 16-35mm f4. I am going to be purchasing the sigma 150-600 in the near future though.
 
How about investing a small amount of time and going to the bhphotovideo website and doing some research on your own. You can filter for maximum height for "tripod legs" and collapsed length, for carbon fiber, for maximum load, and for the weight of the tripod. You can even filter for price range.

For the tripods you find after doing your filter selections you will find reviews posted by people who have bought and used them.

I do this for each new tripod I buy as it is direct and focused and when I look at a specific tripod brand and model I then can read a dozen or more reviews by owners about what they do or do not like about them.

It is much more effective than posting "what should I buy" on a forum.

--
“A person who thinks about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not a Christian” Pope Francis
 
Last edited:
Hmmm... I'm not afraid to recommend a Benro C3770T... did a review some time ago.
 
My camera body is a Canon 6D and my current lens are: 24-105 and the 16-35mm f4. I am going to be purchasing the sigma 150-600 in the near future though.
The Sigma lens is long enough that you will need to consider the center of gravity issues.
 
How about investing a small amount of time and going to the bhphotovideo website and doing some research on your own. You can filter for maximum height for "tripod legs" and collapsed length, for carbon fiber, for maximum load, and for the weight of the tripod. You can even filter for price range.

For the tripods you find after doing your filter selections you will find reviews posted by people who have bought and used them.

I do this for each new tripod I buy as it is direct and focused and when I look at a specific tripod brand and model I then can read a dozen or more reviews by owners about what they do or do not like about them.

It is much more effective than posting "what should I buy" on a forum.
 
Okay, let me try to give you some first ideas in regards to the selection process of tripod legs...!

1) As you may already have recognized, you will get here a wide range of hints, advices and recommendations. This means at the end of the day that the decision is solely up to you what to go for, as always.

2) You may be well advised to spend some time in the evaluation and selection process. Yes, your stated budget will enable you to get a high quality product that (hopefully) fulfills your requirements, but even with such a budget you still can make mistakes in the selection. From my own experience, just as an example: You can easily go for the most recommended product that promises (and also delivers) highest stability, but if you recognize at the end of the day you would have been better served with a more mobile solution, as your over the top stable tripod is simply too heavy and clumsy and therefore you let it sit in the shelf, you also have potentially wasted your money.

3) Really Right Stuff tripod legs, ball heads and other equipment have quite a good recommendation, no doubt. You will barely read any negative statement about the quality of their product, nevertheless you will find statements saying it's overpriced and depending on the specific requirements you can get products as good as theirs for less money. But if money is not an issue and "made in America" is priority no. 1 feel free to go for their products and you will barely be disappointed.

4) What is the reason that you look for tripod legs without a center column? The often seen argument that a tripod with center column is less stable than one without? While this statement (to be discussed and a topic for fight most likely into eternity) may have some truth included it needs also to be seen in a context. In easy words: Personally, considering my shooting conditions and my gear, I have not faced any situation where a tripod setup without center column would have served me better than my setup with center column. Other people, other equipment, other conditions... maybe there it is different. Keep in mind that really good tripod legs have the opportunity to remove the center column, a center column can be the last resort for additional height whenever needed and the center column also allows shorter folded length by utilizing the reverse folded length concept. Finally, there is quite some difference, mostly seen in the cost of the setup, how the center column and its locking mechanism is designed and that way supports stability or not.

5) Considering your height you will be a little more limited to find tripod legs that support your height than somebody somebody for example 1.70 m tall. Looking for tripod legs that enable you an ergonomic height and not having a center column will at least increase the folded length of the setup and that way make it less mobile.

6) Considering your actual gear the stated ball heads, while definitely good heads, at least for me are something like an overkill. Have you ever seen in reality for example RRS series 3 tripod legs with a mounted BH-55 ball head? No doubt, a great product and definitely stable, but maybe more so for some bigger gear considering camera and lens.

7) Finally, at least for the moment, there is also a fact that not everybody is aware of. There is not the one tripod setup that serves all purposes and requirements. You always will face a compromise at least between stability and mobility and that is a reason why a lot of people owe more than one setup.

So, as my personal "recommendation": Budget not an issue, as it sounds in your case, is a great thing. Therefore you can look into different solutions and brands that have a good reputation and are recommended. Brands to be named in here, even it's just my personal opinion: RRS, Gitzo and FLM (the brand I use). Other brands to be considered, they normally are always named also: Manfrotto, Sirui, Benro, Feisol, etc.

Most solutions that will give you sufficient stability and mobility for your existing equipment will also support a longer lens as stated from you as long as you know how to handle the setup. Just aiming for max. stability only makes sense as long as you will have the setup also with you, but reality shows that people finally get annoyed regarding weight and size and then either leave the gear at home or go for an additional setup. With some thinking upfront you can easily avoid such issues...!

Any questions left just let me know.

Herbert
 
Last edited:
Hello all-

I am looking to buy a carbon fiber tripod without the center column and with the ball head sold seperately.

Does anyone use the tripod from "The Right Stuff". Do you like it? Pros vs cons?

Any other recommendations and I am only looking to spend 800-900 on the tripod. I know some can go upto 1,000.

Thank you for any suggestions.
I'm also 5'11". I have the Gitzo GT3532LS, and with a ballhead, it brings the viewfinder of my D810 exactly to eye-level when I'm wearing shoes. The RRS TVC-3xx is equivalent to mine and you won't find anything negative about them. FLM is a brand I've recently been introduced to since picking up their travel tripod. It is very well made so I've got the German company on my radar.

If you travel by car mostly, then there's no reason to consider thing shorter. Whether you choose 3 or 4 legs is up to you. When I fly, I check the 27" collapsed Gitzo into my full-sized hard-case luggage.

At this level, it's hard to go wrong. Just commit to biggest size you can see yourself needing now and the near future. And buy a smaller one later if you find yourself needing to carry it onto a plane.

--
You can't own just one tripod
 
Last edited:
Hello all-

I am looking to buy a carbon fiber tripod without the center column and with the ball head sold seperately.

Does anyone use the tripod from "The Right Stuff". Do you like it? Pros vs cons?

Any other recommendations and I am only looking to spend 800-900 on the tripod. I know some can go upto 1,000.

Thank you for any suggestions.
I have had the Sirui N-3204X for a few weeks now, and it really is fantastic. Great tripod for the money, and top quality. I am 6'1" and with the short center column the view finder is ever so slightly below eye level. And then you also have the flexibility of having a center column if you ever need it by attaching the longer piece. It is made from thick carbon fibre and seems really stable so I will have no second thoughts about extending it if I need to. A tripod that costs twice as much really has to be made from compressed fairy dust to be worth that much when you can get a tripod as good as the N-3204X for half the money.
 
I've been doing a lot of research on tripods looking for something smaller and lighter than my gitzo gt2531 mountaineer for a trip to the Pacific Northwest this summer. From what I've found the Sirui tripods look to be really nice and priced reasonably. In my case I'm probably going to go with the n1204x.
 
B&H has Induro tripods on sale that are CF and no column
 
Hello all-

I am looking to buy a carbon fiber tripod without the center column and with the ball head sold seperately.

Does anyone use the tripod from "The Right Stuff". Do you like it? Pros vs cons?

Any other recommendations and I am only looking to spend 800-900 on the tripod. I know some can go upto 1,000.

Thank you for any suggestions.
You're in luck. Gitzo is having a sale on some of their Systematic tripods. They have a wide range of leg types and accessories so that your tripod will work exactly the way you want. B&H has great prices on Gitzo and they have a great selection. Generally speaking, the Gitzo tripods are the most rigid. You will have to decide what series you want and how tall you want the tripod to extend.
 
Jobu Designs Algonquin Tripod. The best I have ever used. Every bit the quality of RRS and Gitzo, but at about 70% of the price. Jobu has great customer service as well. I use mine with a RRS Bh-55 and Acratech GV-2 ballheads.


See the link

Anthony
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top