Nissin Di866 and Nikon CLS

michaeladawson

Forum Pro
Messages
21,353
Solutions
16
Reaction score
22,962
Location
West Bath, ME, US
Was hoping to get some input from this forum on my experience of the wireless capabilities of the Di866.

I recently received my 866 with the intent of using it with 2 Nikon SB-800 flashes in Nikon's AWL mode (CLS). I mainly use a D3 so one of these three flashes will be connected to the camera as the commander with the other two as remote.

With the 866 on camera as the commander everything worked perfectly. I would say 100%, no failures, in the limited testing I did over the weekend. I was shooting mostly manual flash with the 866 commander set to OFF (---) and the 2 SB-800 remote units dialed in appropriately on the 866, something like 1/4 to 1/8 power. All flashes fired every time.

Things did not work so well with the Nissin 866 set up as one of the remotes with an SB-800 serving as commander on-camera. The 866 would not reliably fire. The other SB-800 remote ALWAYS fired.

Sometimes the 866 would fire 10 times in a row. Sometimes I could go away for half an hour, pick up the D3 and fire a shot and the 866 would fire as well. Sometimes the 866 would not fire at all until I aimed the camera (and commander flash) directly at the 866 and snapped a shot. Then the 866 would fire normally again for a few more shots until it would decide to quite again.

The 866 was very sensitive to where I stood with the camera. Whereas the SB-800 remote would fire even if I went into the next room with no direct line of site, just an open door for the pre-flash light to shine through.

Next I pulled out my D200 and put the pop-up flash in commander mode. With the commander set to OFF (---), but the pre-flashes still on, I got somewhat better results, but still not great. So I turned the D200 commander flash on manual at 1/128 power. NOW, the Nissin fired every time. I could even walk the D200 slightly into the next room, fire, and the 866 would fire. I couldn't get as far away into the next room and have the 866 fire as compared with the SB-800. But not bad.

So I went back to the D3 and set the SB-800 on-camera in commander mode with a manual setting of 1/128 power. The other SB-800 and the 866 were set up as remotes in manual mode. It still didn't work reliably. I think it worked better than it did with the commander flash set to OFF (----), but still was extremely unreliable.

One other thing... even when the Nissin flash fails to fire you can watch the two red lights on the front of the unit flash quickly when you trip the shutter. Every time. I take that as a sign that the Nissin is receiving the pre-flash signals, but is failing to fire for some reason.

This is a lengthy post, but can anyone offer any suggestions? All is not lost as the 866 works perfectly as a commander flash on-camera. But I would like to know if others have experienced what I have. And if so, is a firmware update forthcoming?
--
Mike Dawson
 
Thanks for the details on how you tested. I just bought the 866 a few weeks back and did notice it seemed much more dependent on the direction or view of the commander. To a point where I started to turn the 866's body toward the camera to get consistent flashes. I wrote it off to the position of its sensor.

I have not heard of a firmware upgrage for it at this point.
 
I guess I am not gaining anything using this flash on a pole for remote shooting weddings. I need good consistent results.
 
Thanks for the replies thus far.

Just to repeat, the Di866 has worked perfectly as a commander. So if your setup includes multiple flashes the Nissin seems a good alternative to fill the commander role. Nearly the same price as an SU-800 but with the addition of flash capability.
I guess I am not gaining anything using this flash on a pole for remote shooting weddings. I need good consistent results.
--
Mike Dawson
 
Like most things in life - you get what you pay for.

The Nissin flashes seem fine for casual shooting - but for anyone doing photography for a living IMHO would be best served by using Nikon flashes.

The great interface on the SB900 makes it well worth the cost - not to even mention that it works all the time - both as a remote unit and as a commander.

--
http://www.almariphoto.net

http://www.twincitiesphotoworks.com
 
If I earned a living at this you are absolutely correct. I would buy Nikon. Heck, I already have two.

But I don't, so...
Like most things in life - you get what you pay for.

The Nissin flashes seem fine for casual shooting - but for anyone doing photography for a living IMHO would be best served by using Nikon flashes.

The great interface on the SB900 makes it well worth the cost - not to even mention that it works all the time - both as a remote unit and as a commander.

--
http://www.almariphoto.net

http://www.twincitiesphotoworks.com
--
Mike Dawson
 
Owner of TWO nissin di866 units. Master from D90 body, commander mode. Not working in this mode, be aware! Group A in M mode, group B in M mode, after firt shoot group B never flash. You must go to the units and set group A to be B and B to A. Another shoot, working, next shoot dead. This CLS mode from nissin is BAD BAD BAD. Need help, mayne is something wrong with me?
If someone wants to put me on other testing please be my guest.
 
NOTE: A and B in TTL mode is working but I don't want TTL mode, only MANUAL.
 
My problem tested by my dealer - bad news. :(
Two Nissin Di866 in commander mode not working in Manual mode.

Testing condition:

Nikon D90 master from buil-in flash.
Channel 1 (or 2, 3, 4, no matter)
Nissin Di866 Group A, Manual mode, any value
Nissin Di866 Group A, Manual mode, any value

REZULT:
Group B not working (no flash).

So if you want to put two Nissin di866 units in CLS manual mode you must stay away from Nissin.
 
Hi I have 2 of these and a D90 too. and have the same random problems It seem to work pretty well using the D90's commander with one flash but goes struggles when using two. I have contacted the UK supplier (Kenro) and got this message:

"The answer that I have got form Nissin is that the design of Nissin Di866 is so that is uses the external flash as the commander, like SB600, 900, Not using built-in flash on the camera. This is because the commander code is different from each camera, so sometimes the following situation can happen when using a D90.

Unfortunately so far, Nissin have only have only had this problem raised with the D90, but no other DSLR"

Then this from Nissin:

"We will release firmware around the end of this year to solve the problem.

Thank you for your kind understanding.
Nissin
http://www.nissindigital.com "

This has now been amended to "Sometime in February" 2011. So...hopefully Nissin will fix this ASAP. As I believe these flashes are fantastic value for money.
 
February is at end and NO fix from Nissin. This is so bad! Never buy Nissin, so sad.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top