Benefits of Manual exposure vs Aperture priority exposure

Rendrat

Leading Member
Messages
751
Reaction score
0
Location
SG
Hi ... I often read in photography books, the photographer will take photo in Manual exposure. I want to know what are the benefits of Manual (M) exposure as compared to Aperture priority (Av) exposure.

In what situation using M will be an advantage ?

--
Rendrat
 
Nightshots, HDR, panoramas, using the flash...

Many advantages. AV is sort of an auto mode, the camera decides which shutter speed to use, and many times the camera can get it wrong.
 
Shooting manual allows you to override the cameras light metering giving you more creative license with the shot. Using Aperture (or shutter) Priority is only like Auto in that the exposure is adjusted to the cameras metering. With exposure compensation and other non automatic adjustments available aperture and shutter priority are far more advanced than Auto.

I have seen a lot of manual shooters adjust the aperture to what they want, then adjust the shutter speed until the cameras meter says it's ok which is no different that aperture or shutter priority...
--
Dennis
 
In P A S, the camera controls either shutter speed, aperture or both, responding to the light level. If you find that the camera sets the exposure too dark or too light, you can set an offset - the offset is called Exposure Value Compensation or shortened to EV.

You can typically EV as much as 2 stops + or -

One issue is that some people don't "think" in EV. They prefer to know what the Light Value is and simply adjust the shutter speed and aperture directly.

Two ways to the same result.

Another, bigger issue is that as you wave the camera around, the camera's recommendation may and does change based on how much sky it sees as you change the view. Some people prefer to already know what shutter speed and aperture they want at this time and refuse to let the waving of the camera flutter the camera's recommendation. With "M", you set the shutter speed and aperture and the camera does not try to change anything.
Hi ... I often read in photography books, the photographer will take photo in Manual exposure. I want to know what are the benefits of Manual (M) exposure as compared to Aperture priority (Av) exposure.

In what situation using M will be an advantage ?

--
Rendrat
--



Ananda
http://anandasim.mp
 
I've had two main uses for manual exposure. The first most often occurs when I'm shooting people indoors, perhaps speakers at a podium or snapshots of guests at a reception or convention of some sort. In both cases, the light falling on the subjects is usually quite consistent, but the exposure set by the camera's meter will vary depending on the lightness or darkness of a person's clothing or if he is standing in front of a dark tapestry or a white wall. Under these conditions, I typically meter off the palm of my hand and increase exposure by one stop. Skin tones will remain consistent and dark and light items will be rendered appropriately dark or light without the meter trying to average everything to a neutral tone.

Another use I've had for manual exposure is dependent on the operation of the camera. I like to set focus and exposure apart from the shutter button. Some cameras allow me to set focus by pressing and releasing the OK button and to set exposure by pressing and releasing the AEL button; when I press the shutter button, nothing happens except for actuating the shutter, and that's how I like it. Other cameras require that a button be pushed and held to lock a setting, or have no provision other than the shutter button to access auto focus and/or auto exposure. On cameras like that, I prefer to just operate manually.
 
Personally, I find aperture priority the least use for me. Sometimes, but not that often.

All methods can be manual. To me, as long as you know what the camera is doing and you're in control, it's manual.

Shutter priority, is just what it says. The priority is that the shutter remain at some shutter speed you wish, generally stopping action. If you don't want the shutter under 1000 of a second to stop a bird in flight, that's shutter priority, or the same goes for freezing kids or anything else where you don't want subject blur.

Aperture priority is for when the aperture setting is the most important thing to consider and freezing action is second choice or not important. That might be for portraits or where depth of field might come into play.

Program mode is for when you just let the camera choose. Freezing action or depth of field is not that important. You can shift it if you wish to empasize one of these things. You still have control.

I use program mode to tell me the exposure. I usually change to manual mode to lock in my choice based on what I found out. I then have control over freezing action or not and depth of field. This way, bright sunny backgrounds don't fool the camera. I also sometimes take a picture just to see the histogram. Once I do this, I don't need to change the exposure from frame to frame. Unless I move to different light, I leave that manual exposure alone, or adjust it a stop or so in some direction depending on need. I look at histograms fairly often to keep it honest.

If program mode tells me 125th of a second at f/8 and I want to stop action at 500th of a second. I know I can just move two stops. I'll change to 500th which is stopping down two, then open the aperture two to make up for it, or f/4.

You have to be careful and set ISO either manually or auto with a limit or your test exposure might be off.
--
Cheers, Craig
 
In the studio, using studio strobes, you must use manual as the strobes are also manual. You set the required power levels on the strobes (multiple units typically), then use a flash meter to determine exposure, which you then transfer manually to the camera.

--

The greatest of mankind's criminals are those who delude themselves into thinking they have done 'the right thing.'
  • Rayna Butler
 
Hi ... thank you for all answers. Those answer are really help.
--
Rendrat
 
I want to know what are the benefits of Manual (M) exposure as compared to Aperture priority (Av) exposure.
Just like S, and P modes in A the camera is deciding exposure settings for you, and by doing that you'll end up with an average photo, and who wants that?

If you look at the following image it was shot at 2.5 seconds wide open (settings I chose):

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0803/Mikefellh/My_Creative_Variety/streetfest.jpg

If I let the camera decide for me I wouldn't have gotten that shot...the camera's meter would have been fooled by difference in the hot spots vs. the night sky.

I used a camera for 20 years that only had M mode (it was fully manual)...I'd take that camera over a camera that forced me to only work in A mode!
 
you named your shot streetfest ..isnt that mainstreet disney ..

i could be wrong
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top