erase or format each time

rollerbones

Member
Messages
13
Reaction score
0
Location
OH, US
--

Easy question...

Do most people format the card in camera after you download pics or do you just delete them from the card?

Thanks
 
--
Shoot.
 
I always format a card in the camera after downloading and saving my photos. Formatting automatically erases anything on the card.
--
Paul O'D, Chicago, IL
 
If I transfer an image from the computer to a SD card and then put the card into my Canon A-550 the camera does not see it and will not delete it. It does not give me a choice to format, only delete.

When the card is put into my Lumix LX3 it does Format and remove it. The Lumix takes forever to format, so I have kept the A-550 handy just to delete.

I guess the Prime choice is to format in the computer. It also is fast with the card in a USB2 adapter. Gene
 
I guess the Prime choice is to format in the computer. It also is
fast with the card in a USB2 adapter. Gene
To avoid formatting issues its best to do it in-camera if you can. Formatting with my cameras takes 5-10 seconds, on my D200 I don't even have to go into any buried menu selections either.
--

 
I always format, not sure why it'd be preferably over erasing. I do it in the camera though, to prevent filesystem-conflicts (though i don't consider it a very big risk if you format on the computer).
 
One reason to prefer formatting over erasing is that flash memory is used by many different devices.

A card inserted into the camera might show half a dozen photos are present, and allow you to delete them. But it most likely won't show any other types of files such as MP3 or WAV and so on, which could mean the card capacity is reduced by these 'invisible' files. Formatting will clear out all the existing stuff, regardless of where or how it originated.

Regards,
Peter
 
Panasonic invented the SD/SDHC card and this is what they have to say:

"This software [Panasonic SD card formatting utility] formats SD Memory Card and SDHC Memory Card(SD/SDHC Memory Card) using a formatting program that complies with the SD Memory Card specification SD formatting provides quick and easy access to the SD Memory Card.

Generally, SD/SDHC Memory Card file systems formatted with generic operating system formatting software do not comply with the SD Memory Card specification."

http://panasonic.jp/support/global/cs/sd/download/sd_formatter.html

(The download button is at the very bottom of the page)

--
Currently shooting:
Casio EX-Z400
Sanyo HD2000 HD camcorder/8 and 12 megapixel stills.
Panasonic LX3.
Olympus SP-570UZ.
Canon HG10 High Definition camcorder.
Canon Rebel Xs DSLR with kit lens, 50mm F1.8 II lens, and 55-250mm IS telephoto.
Samsung G810 Cell Phone With 5 Megapixel Camera.
 
When the card is put into my Lumix LX3 it does Format and remove it.
The Lumix takes forever to format, so I have kept the A-550 handy
just to delete.
While you shouldn't have an issue between the Canon and the Lumix, you shouldn't really share cards between cameras (especially the same brand) as it can corrupt the file numbering as the camera checks the card to see what the last number was (if there are images on the card).
I guess the Prime choice is to format in the computer. It also is
fast with the card in a USB2 adapter. Gene
No, because the camera can change the formatting of the card to a format that's not compatible with the camera.

Also it's not recommended to Move the files, always use the Copy command instead.

Since it takes long to format on your camera, what I suggest is if it's a few images erase them, and if it's hundreds of images format the card, or format the card once out of every 10 transfers.
 
the reason to format the card in the camera you use it in is not to erase the images. WHEN YOU FORMAT THE CARD IN THE CAMERA YOU USE IT IN, IT MAKES A NEW ALLOCATION TABLE. that table is why you could have the images on the card but be unable to get to or download the images.

this is why formating the card in the computer will not work. the computer does make the same allocation table that the camera does. also, you should not format the card in one camera then use it in another, the allocation tables will not be the same.

yes, you can get away with deletion only or doing what the opposite of what was mentioned above. but, the day you go on your once in a lifetime trip to hawaii is when you find out that it did not work. the only way then to fix the problem is to go back to hawaii and spend the first $10000 again taking another set of the same pictures.

it is simply safer and easier to do the formatting in the camera that you are going to use it in, and do it every time.

for the safety of the images on a hawaii trip and the $10000 that goes with, are you going to taken the chance? how many $10000 do you have and can afford to spend? having been to a great many national parks, there is no way that i will take the chance. not to mention about shooting a wedding for a fee, are you going to tell the b&g that they have no images the next day because you did not format and took a shortcut?
 
The Panasonic formatting software Mr. Palmer mentions is for use on a PC, not in the individual camera. I agree that it's better to use it if formatting an SD card attached to the PC via a card reader.

However, I think you're safer to format the card in the camera itself. That's what the camera manufacturers recommend.

--
Tom
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top