I have found the 85mm 1.4 lens not as forgiving as the 70-200 f/2.8 VR. Certainly not a fault of the lens, but of me learning how to use it effectively. Here are a couple of shots.
Maybe you should have sharpen only the eyes and the hair but not the skin... tho it looks amazing its doesnt quite give a natural look tho it doesnt sream photshop either...
The second image is horrendously oversharpened. Most here are doing you no favor with their great shot posts. If it looks this bad onscreen, imagine what a print would look like.