Canon 10-22 vs Tamron 11-18 vs Sigma 10-20?

[alekas]

Is there any comparison between these 3 lenses? I mean an image quality?

I understand Sigma may not be available yet, but how about Tamron vs Canon?

I would appreciate if someone post a link

Thanks,
Alex

--
http://www.pbase.com/alekas

 

[Omprakash Das]

Could you please answer the Thread

Which to select Canon 70-200mm f/4 L or Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8
--
Omprakash Das

 

[alekas]

--
http://www.pbase.com/alekas

 

[anthony kohn]

Yet to see much on the Tamron or the Sigma, but is there a reason you aren't looking at the Tokina?
--
http://planeguy.mine.nu/pictures

 

[Marvin Doering]

I agree. The Tokina rocks! By comparison the build of the Tamron looks cheap. The Sigma was not recommended by my local Camera Shop. Let us know what you decide on.
--
MRD

 

[alekas]

I want 10 (or 11mm max) at wide end.

Also I did not see any comparison between Tokina and Canon EFS lets say at 12mm. Do you have a link?

And after using for a while EF 85/1.8 USM I like USM a lot - hope Sigma's HSM is the same - that's why although I have 2 Tamrons (17-35 and 28-75) and love them - this time I want Sigma HSM or Canon USM - but from the samples of Canon lens I saw - I don't really like CA and the softness on the corners IMHO... And the price... I'm not an idiot to pay $800 for that lens... IMHO again. And I don't play these Dell games.

It would be nice if someone can compare all these lenses (or some of them) at the wide end. For now I saw a few basic reviews (or... how great is that lens, how not bad it is for the money etc) - I want the comparison in optical quality (center sharpness, corner sharpness, CA, AF quality in low light).

Alex

Yet to see much on the Tamron or the Sigma, but is there a reason
you aren't looking at the Tokina?
--
http://planeguy.mine.nu/pictures

--
http://www.pbase.com/alekas

 

[alekas]

If you follow "local camera shop" recommendations - you will have to buy only what they have in stock

Tamron build quality is exactly the same as Tamron 17-35 and Tamron 28-75 - I have them both... What can I say - if only they have USM or HSM - everything else is good enough. Did you try Tamron yourself?

Alex

--
http://www.pbase.com/alekas

 

[alekas]

or Tamron 11-18?

Alex
--
http://www.pbase.com/alekas