D-100 discovery

KenEis

Senior Member
Messages
4,055
Reaction score
32
Location
Ft Collins USA, US
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images, and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about 45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2 minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--

Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300, 80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
 
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images,
and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that
the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that
said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the
uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked
at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the
factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not
the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and
shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per
image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--
Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300,
80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
--
Tim Bessell
 
right at the time Phil wrote it in the D100 review =)
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikond100/page10.asp
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images,
and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that
the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that
said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the
uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked
at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the
factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not
the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and
shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per
image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--
Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300,
80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
--
Everything looks better when you turn your head and squint.
 
The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.
Thanks for the tip Ken. As a new D100 owner, I will follow your example.

Gordon
 
I must admit I thought that the NEF compression time penalty on the D100 was well known - that's why I, and most people, don't use it!!!

What surprises me is your observation that turning off the camera before the buffer has emptied results in loss of the image(s). I thought you could turn off the camera anytime and it would finish what it had to do before gracefully powering down. I'm pretty sure I have done this, but not with compressed NEFs, without problems.

-JohnK
The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.
Thanks for the tip Ken. As a new D100 owner, I will follow your
example.

Gordon
 
Got a question for you was tha a WiFi compact flash card that you were reffering to if so can you direct the files to place on a server or a workstation in the area.
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images,
and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that
the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that
said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the
uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked
at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the
factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not
the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and
shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per
image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--
Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300,
80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
 
Sorry about your loss of images when turning off the camera. In the manuel, the one that came with the camera, it states that you can't turn off the camera when the green light is on.

dave
What surprises me is your observation that turning off the camera
before the buffer has emptied results in loss of the image(s). I
thought you could turn off the camera anytime and it would finish
what it had to do before gracefully powering down. I'm pretty sure
I have done this, but not with compressed NEFs, without problems.

-JohnK
The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.
Thanks for the tip Ken. As a new D100 owner, I will follow your
example.

Gordon
 
Sorry about you not knowing that bit of info. It has been discussed here several times. But if you don't catch it, sometimes it is difficult to find information. A person doesnt' know if there is a problem until he comes upon it

I find that when shooting NEF that if I pace myself a bit that the camera can keep up with my shooting if I turn compression OFF.

Yes with compression on it can be unbelievablly slow.

dave
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images,
and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that
the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that
said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the
uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked
at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the
factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not
the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and
shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per
image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--
Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300,
80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
 
This has been previously reported at least a few times. I had this same experience myself, which was discussed approx 1 year ago. Yes, it's really stupid that Nikon set the standard default to compressed NEFs, which takes a huuuuuge amount of time for writing.

-CC
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images,
and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that
the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that
said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the
uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked
at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the
factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not
the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and
shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per
image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--
Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300,
80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
 
As a new-ish owner, I missed this when it was discussed, but it is in Thom Hogan's book - which I recommend to any new D100 owners out there! CHanging to uncompressed stopped me throwing the D100 through the window!
 
If you value your time at minimum wage you still come out way, WAY ahead shooting RAW uncompressed, buying a fast CF card that is 1GB or larger, and using a digital wallet if you have to.

This is the same logic that someone who spends $65.00 of my time in the supermarket checkout line haggling over a 25 cent coupon uses.
 
What surprises me is your observation that turning off the camera
before the buffer has emptied results in loss of the image(s). I
thought you could turn off the camera anytime and it would finish
what it had to do before gracefully powering down. I'm pretty sure
I have done this, but not with compressed NEFs, without problems.
Hi John.

According to "Thom Hogans Guide to the D100" is only the current buffer image transferred to the card. All other images left in the buffer will be lost...
 
This has been previously reported at least a few times. I had this
same experience myself, which was discussed approx 1 year ago.
Yes, it's really stupid that Nikon set the standard default to
I think that was one of the changes with the current firmware version.
compressed NEFs, which takes a huuuuuge amount of time for writing.

-CC
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images,
and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that
the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that
said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the
uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked
at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the
factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not
the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and
shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per
image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--
Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300,
80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
--
Tim Bessell
 
Well... you learn something new every day!!!!

I wasn't aware of this - I must have been lucky up to now. I suppose shooting in uncompressed RAW must have been emptying the buffer quickly enough for me not to get caught. I'll check the green light in future just to be safe

Thanks.

-JohnK
What surprises me is your observation that turning off the camera
before the buffer has emptied results in loss of the image(s). I
thought you could turn off the camera anytime and it would finish
what it had to do before gracefully powering down. I'm pretty sure
I have done this, but not with compressed NEFs, without problems.
Hi John.

According to "Thom Hogans Guide to the D100" is only the current
buffer image transferred to the card. All other images left in the
buffer will be lost...
 
I wasn't finding fault with Nikon, the camera, or the manual. Lose of NEFs (you dont lose the one being processed at the time, just those in the buffer not being worked on) The fault is/was all mine. I have a habit of turning off the camera without thinking after I take a shot. Bad habit of a jpeg shooter.
dave
What surprises me is your observation that turning off the camera
before the buffer has emptied results in loss of the image(s). I
thought you could turn off the camera anytime and it would finish
what it had to do before gracefully powering down. I'm pretty sure
I have done this, but not with compressed NEFs, without problems.

-JohnK
The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.
Thanks for the tip Ken. As a new D100 owner, I will follow your
example.

Gordon
--

Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300, 80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
 
Sorry about this WA misunderstanding. I was refering to a Write Accelorated CF card, not a WiFi wireless communications device.
I'm ashamed to admit this after taking 10s of thousands of images,
and owning my D-100 for 2 years but I've just made a discovery that
the rest of you probably already knew. I followed a discussion that
said that compressed NEF was only 10-bit compared to the
uncompressed NEF being the extected 12-bit. I've never even looked
at NEF in the cameras menue system. Well I changed over (the
factory setting is compressed) this last weekend. Well that's not
the discovery.

Taking uncompressed NEFs did show some improvement in color and
shadow detail and doubled the size of the files aprox 9 MB per
image. Well that was expected and not my discovery.

The discovery was the change in shoot to CF download time. It was
incredible. My WF enabled card using V 2.0 software took about
45-50 sec to put an image to the CF card and the green light to
turn off. I've lived with this for a long time. I've lost many
photo opportunities when the buffer was full and I had to wait 2
minutes for the D-100 to wake up from the buffer death. I've also
lost pictures when I inadvertently turned the camera off while
writting to the card. (Only happens when NEFs are being written.)

So switching to uncompressed NEFs changed all that. It takes 4 sec
for an uncompressed NEF to clear the buffer. That's 1/10 the time
of the compressed. Clearly the compression algorithm is what takes
time and not the transfer from buffer to card.

WHy didn't you guys tell me this a year ago? Maybe I wasn't listening.
--
Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300,
80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
--

Ken Eis - D100 and S45 Nikon 18-35, 28-105, 24-120VR, 70-300, 80-400VR, 500mm and 60mm macro
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top