New laser printer recommendation?

NAwlins Contrarian

Forum Pro
Messages
11,575
Solutions
44
Reaction score
8,667
Location
New Orleans, LA, US
My small home color laser printer seems to be on its last legs*, and I'm looking for a replacement, either an all-in-one or a printer-only; what do you recommend?

My needs and priorities, roughly in order of importance to me:

* it must be a color laser printer (period--I'm familiar with, and not interested in rehashing the pros and cons of, e.g. tank inkjets);

* it must not be expensive to buy or exorbitantly expensive to run--I'm thinking I'd go up to $375 on a printer-only or $450 on an all-in-one, but that's the maximum, and I'd prefer to spend less;

* it should be reliable;

* it should be compact, especially in height;

* auto-duplex / two-sided printing would be nice but not necessary;

* a scanner / all-in-one functionality would be nice but not necessary; and

* if it has a scanner, then an automatic document feeder would be nice but not necessary.

Also: they all seem to be wireless, but wireless operation is a requirement. It must be readily available new; I'm not interested in a used printer, or hunting for a new copy of a discontinued model. Photo printing quality is not important because I have an inkjet for that.

My candidates identified so far:

89f51cdded8242a293eb8f9bc38456c1.jpg

Either from among my identified candidates or not, what do you recommend? Are there any you think I should avoid? Do you have any comments about the brands and/or models listed above? Any details and reasons would be helpful. Thanks!

*It's a Samsung CLP-325W, it has bad feeding problems, toners are getting harder to find and less likely to be accepted happily by the printer, and the fuser seems past its best-performance life. It got it almost thirteen years ago.
 
Last edited:
Will be interesting to see if you can get a good "value" recommendation.

My guess is some of the brands use the same engine. In the past, it seemed like Canon and HP are quite similar. Is that your impression.
 
I have a Brother HL-L3820CDW. It's not an all-in-one. It does duplex printing, though.

I haven't had it long, but I have been pleased with it so far.

I like Brother's drive support for old printers. Maybe the rest of the industry has caught up. (Lookin' at you, HP!)
 
Can you refill the Brother toner cartridges?
I don't know.

I've never looked into it. My use of the printer isn't heavy enough to make it attractive. I have a B&W MFD that I use more.
 
My small home color laser printer seems to be on its last legs*, and I'm looking for a replacement, either an all-in-one or a printer-only; what do you recommend?
FWIW, I ordered a Canon MF653Cdw color laser all-in-one (AIO), cost $300. My thinking:

* My sense is that Canon builds reliable printers. The IT guy at work independently expressed the opinion that Canon builds the most reliable home-type printing devices.

* It was the least expensive of the AIO models I seriously considered, and only $50 more than the least expensive of the printer-only models I seriously considered.

* I think that occasionally a scanner will be nice to have, but it would be very rare for an ADF to matter much for me, and I like the flatter top that the non-ADF models have.

* It's appreciably shorter than three of the five other AIOs I seriously considered, and only slightly taller than the other two. Unfortunately, there's nothing that seems remotely suitable that's anywhere near as compact as my old Samsung.

* Of the ten devices I seriously considered, it had the highest customer rating at B&H (4.9 out of 5.0).

* It has double-sided (duplex) printing, which a few of the other models did not.

* The range of toner costs per page printed, even using OEM toners, is not that large. I analyzed a bunch of models, that the least expensive, using high-capacity toner cartridges, was about $0.022 per page printed, and the most expensive, using standard-capacity toner cartridges, was about $0.051 per page printed. That's inconsequential at my current printing volume (I'm estimating 1000 pages/year, so $51 per year maximum total cost, $29 per year range).

Thanks all for the comments and suggestions!
 
Did you look at power draw? Looks like max is 900W.

Enjoy the printer. Although it irritates me that nearly every review on B&H is based on printer being given away for a review in return. I often see the same thing on Amazon.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.]
 
Last edited:
I have a Brother HL-L3820CDW. It's not an all-in-one. It does duplex printing, though.

I haven't had it long, but I have been pleased with it so far.

I like Brother's drive support for old printers. Maybe the rest of the industry has caught up. (Lookin' at you, HP!)
Sorry. HL-3280CDW. Not that it matters now.
 
Last edited:
Did you look at power draw?
B&H reports 900 W maximum, 10.5 W standby, and 0.8 W sleep, but I don't really care about the power draw--for us, this will be such a nothing, a rounding error in the scheme of our electric use. Usually we keep printers turned off unless and until somebody wants to print (averaging maybe once every two or three days), although that's for other reasons (with the old Samsung, there was some heat buildup, which I suspect is not good for it, and some noise). As comparisons, our microwave draws 1460 W and will spend far more time running than the printer will; and I cannot recall having measured what our air conditioner and/or our water heater use, but those almost have to be far more.
 
Did you look at power draw? Looks like max is 900W.

Enjoy the printer. Although it irritates me that nearly every review on B&H is based on printer being given away for a review in return. I often see the same thing on Amazon.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.]
Reminds me of a stupid error I've made.

Plugged a couple of laser printers into a UPS (1500VA/900W).

When the printers came up in a cold start, the UPS was very unhappy.

I believe that the power draw during printing is less.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top