...
That said, my own experiences with free software have not been all that encouraging over the years. I've used LR for years, and given its capabilities, I really don't have an issue with funding its further development by paying for it. ...Free does not equate to bad.
darktable is really a capable piece of software.
I have used it since I entered the Fujifilm ecosystem and re-discovered photography as a hobby for me. That was in 2018.
darktable is very logical in its workflow, you have more degrees of freedom as compared to Lightroom.
However, darktable cannot compete with paid state of the art solutions that provide "AI supported features", the most important one for me being denoising of high ISO images. I wanted to have this feature, hence, end of 2023, I licensed Lightroom. darktable does not offer convenient auto masking in a way LR does. But on the other hand, masks in darktable offer more options and are more fun to use than those in LR. darktable does not offer generative fill like Photoshop does or no AI sharpening like Topaz does. GIMP also does not have generative fill. At least today, if you want the latest "AI features", you need to pay.
Although I have LR now, I sometimes still prefer darktable. Hats off to its developers.
KR,
Martin