X-S20 vs X-T50

X-S20 vs X-T50


  • Total voters
    0
I've heard, that in X-T50 You can't save Your jpg recipes LOL

I'm that case no, thanks. X-S20 all day long. Jpg recipes are one of very few big reasons I'm still in Fuji X system.
Is this true?

I know you can't assign a recipe to the 'film' dial (which I guess makes sense since 'recipes' are part of the more general custom settings these days) but surely Fuji aren't removing the ability to save your custom jpg settings?
XT50 has FS 1,2,3 and C slots on the Film Sim dial. I guess we can save the custom film sim recipes on XT50?

--
https://www.flickr.com/photos/183079213@N06/
 
Last edited:
I've heard, that in X-T50 You can't save Your jpg recipes LOL

I'm that case no, thanks. X-S20 all day long. Jpg recipes are one of very few big reasons I'm still in Fuji X system.
Is this true?

I know you can't assign a recipe to the 'film' dial (which I guess makes sense since 'recipes' are part of the more general custom settings these days) but surely Fuji aren't removing the ability to save your custom jpg settings?
XT50 has FS 1,2,3 and C slots on the Film Sim dial. I guess we can save the custom film sim recipes on XT50?
 
I've heard, that in X-T50 You can't save Your jpg recipes LOL

I'm that case no, thanks. X-S20 all day long. Jpg recipes are one of very few big reasons I'm still in Fuji X system.
Is this true?

I know you can't assign a recipe to the 'film' dial (which I guess makes sense since 'recipes' are part of the more general custom settings these days) but surely Fuji aren't removing the ability to save your custom jpg settings?
XT50 has FS 1,2,3 and C slots on the Film Sim dial. I guess we can save the custom film sim recipes on XT50?
Recipies can only be saved as custom settings. You than have to turn the new dial to C and than you can choose them. FS1 - FS3 is only for saving Filmsimulations not explicitly written on the dial
 
I've heard, that in X-T50 You can't save Your jpg recipes LOL

I'm that case no, thanks. X-S20 all day long. Jpg recipes are one of very few big reasons I'm still in Fuji X system.
Is this true?

I know you can't assign a recipe to the 'film' dial (which I guess makes sense since 'recipes' are part of the more general custom settings these days) but surely Fuji aren't removing the ability to save your custom jpg settings?
XT50 has FS 1,2,3 and C slots on the Film Sim dial. I guess we can save the custom film sim recipes on XT50?
Recipies can only be saved as custom settings. You than have to turn the new dial to C and than you can choose them. FS1 - FS3 is only for saving Filmsimulations not explicitly written on the dial
Which is a bummer imo. But maybe Fujifilm have determined through marketing research that very few users actually tweak the built in film sims. And that 3 FS are enough for those who do.

--
DJF
 
Last edited:
I've heard, that in X-T50 You can't save Your jpg recipes LOL

I'm that case no, thanks. X-S20 all day long. Jpg recipes are one of very few big reasons I'm still in Fuji X system.
Is this true?

I know you can't assign a recipe to the 'film' dial (which I guess makes sense since 'recipes' are part of the more general custom settings these days) but surely Fuji aren't removing the ability to save your custom jpg settings?
XT50 has FS 1,2,3 and C slots on the Film Sim dial. I guess we can save the custom film sim recipes on XT50?
Recipies can only be saved as custom settings. You than have to turn the new dial to C and than you can choose them. FS1 - FS3 is only for saving Filmsimulations not explicitly written on the dial
I thought the "C" position is just a command position to allow you to cycle film sims with one of the command dials, just like there is a "C" position on ISO dials and exposure comp dials.

So still no recipes on there, to me all of that is only in the custom user profiles you have access to in the Q menu, like any other Fujifilm camera. Or at least that's my understanding of it.
 
And that 3 FS are enough for those who do.
My understanding is that those three positions on the wheel are for saving one of the factory film simulations; you cannot save anything you have customised yourself.
 
I've heard, that in X-T50 You can't save Your jpg recipes LOL

I'm that case no, thanks. X-S20 all day long. Jpg recipes are one of very few big reasons I'm still in Fuji X system.
Is this true?

I know you can't assign a recipe to the 'film' dial (which I guess makes sense since 'recipes' are part of the more general custom settings these days) but surely Fuji aren't removing the ability to save your custom jpg settings?
Omar Gonzalez said so in his first impressions review of X-T50 (in 3:47 min)



So I do assume, it is true after all.
 
Omar Gonzalez said so in his first impressions review of X-T50 (in 3:47 min)
It is contradicted here: https://fujixweekly.com/2024/05/16/...ttings-14-new-film-simulation-recipes-yes-14/
Indeed, You are right!
X-T50 has the ability to save SOOC .jpg settings as recipes, and Omar Gonzalez misled everyone!

From fujixweekly:

"Just to be completely clear, the way this works is that you program the Recipe (that’s found below) into either a C1-C7 slot, or (as I did it) into the IQ Menu set. Then, when this Recipe is selected, simply rotate the Film Dial to choose the film simulation that you want to use. There are eight built-into-the-knob film sims, plus three custom, plus “C” (which is whatever you have programmed into the Recipe)."

Ehhh... YouTubers... Thx Omar, GJ with spreading disinformation that I later repeat myself for others :-(

Sorry for misleading everyone - my bad.
although this was not my intention.
 
Last edited:
Omar Gonzalez said so in his first impressions review of X-T50 (in 3:47 min)
It is contradicted here: https://fujixweekly.com/2024/05/16/...ttings-14-new-film-simulation-recipes-yes-14/
Indeed, You are right!
X-T50 has the ability to save SOOC .jpg settings as recipes, and Omar Gonzalez misled everyone!

From fujixweekly:

"Just to be completely clear, the way this works is that you program the Recipe (that’s found below) into either a C1-C7 slot, or (as I did it) into the IQ Menu set. Then, when this Recipe is selected, simply rotate the Film Dial to choose the film simulation that you want to use. There are eight built-into-the-knob film sims, plus three custom, plus “C” (which is whatever you have programmed into the Recipe)."

Ehhh... YouTubers... Thx Omar, GJ with spreading disinformation that I later repeat myself for others :-(

Sorry for misleading everyone - my bad.
although this was not my intention.
To be fair to Omar I think he says 'You can't save recipes on here' and points to the film simulation dial, so I think he's just saying that you can't use the film sim dial to recall custom recipes.

I agree it's ambiguous, though, and could be interpreted as meaning 'you can't save recipes on the camera'...

Anyway, all cleared up now!
 
In my normal shop the XT5 is 1800 EUR today. Of course it can be bought cheaper online, or used. But give it some time, and the XT50 will go down as well. The XT50 is a much better camera compared to the previous XT30II, so I was expecting a price raise. Same for XS20, which is dearer at launch compared to the XS10. If I were interested in the XT50, I would 6 months or 1 year, and buy it cheaper.
It's 1760€ right now in France, with regular sales under 1700. Launch price in France was 1999€. I agree with the "buy later" part but the X-T5 price will also continue to drop as time goes on. My issue is not with the price itself, but with the lack of separation with the X-T5. and a lightly used X-T5 off MPB is already cheaper than the X-T50's launch price.
Lack of price separation? Sure, but again you are comparing launch price for a new camera versus price of a camera that has been around for 3 years. In 3 years time how much the XT50 will cost?
Even comparing launch price in the US : 1400 vs 1700. That's only a $300 difference, while it used to be 700 to 800. The X-T5 didn't increase in price compared to the X-T4 while the X-T50 is $500 more than the X-T30.

Sure, we can check the prices in 3 years, but the price of the X-T5 will continue to drop also.

European pricing is pretty funny when this is what Google gets you :



516271dcdf694c2b8854836c173fd5ce.jpg.png

In that line of thought, those who want to upgrade from X100 series to ILC in the Fuji ecosystem, will see the XT50 as a natural progression. They even share the sensor and batteries.
Yes, that's my point exactly. They're really putting down the film sim argument harder and harder.

Also, I wouldn't consider the X-T50 a step-up to the X100VI. More like an ILC side grade for people that couldn't get one. An upgrade would men not leaving anything that the X100 has, becised the OVF. EVF is worse, no weather sealing, cheaper build are enough things to make me consider an X-T50 not as a X100VI upgrade.
I can see people that have X100 series camera to be hooked on Fuji, and then wanting a Fuji ILC. The XT50 can be such a camera. The X100VI is also not weather sealed. How do you know the XT50 has cheaper build?
X-Tx0 cameras always had cheaper builds than the X-T series, as well as the X100 series. Generally, thinner metal panels, a bit more plastic used. It seems to still be the case according to reviews I've seen. Also, much lower end EVF, and lower res back panel play a part imho.

Also, both the X100V and X100VI are weather sealed on the body. The front of the lens isn't but you can seal the camera by putting a filter on the lens to seal it. According to Fujifilm the weather sealing on the X100VI's body is about as weather resistant as the X-T5.
It will probably find its public with the people that wanted to buy an X100VI but couldn't due to the long wait times.
The increase in size between XT3 and XT4 is minimal, they were able to accommodate the new battery.
It was not "minimal". The X-T4 was the largest X-T body to date (even compared to the X-T5)
I have used XT3 and XT4, no real difference in use. As your comparison below illustrates, hardly noticeable.
I noticed it quite a bit when I used them


--
(G.A.S. and collectionnite will get my skin one day)
 
Omar Gonzalez said so in his first impressions review of X-T50 (in 3:47 min)
It is contradicted here: https://fujixweekly.com/2024/05/16/...ttings-14-new-film-simulation-recipes-yes-14/
Indeed, You are right!
X-T50 has the ability to save SOOC .jpg settings as recipes, and Omar Gonzalez misled everyone!

From fujixweekly:

"Just to be completely clear, the way this works is that you program the Recipe (that’s found below) into either a C1-C7 slot, or (as I did it) into the IQ Menu set. Then, when this Recipe is selected, simply rotate the Film Dial to choose the film simulation that you want to use. There are eight built-into-the-knob film sims, plus three custom, plus “C” (which is whatever you have programmed into the Recipe)."

Ehhh... YouTubers... Thx Omar, GJ with spreading disinformation that I later repeat myself for others :-(

Sorry for misleading everyone - my bad.
although this was not my intention.
You can not save Custom recipies directly on the dial!

You can save them just as you alwys could in the custom settings.

When you turn the dial to C, than you can toogle with the other control wheels through the custom settings. For this you will not touch the filmsim wheel again.

What Richie descripes is that he created a base setting which he stores in either one of the C banks which works with all simulations and than toggles the simualtion by using the wheel

So people which use a lot of reciies don't need the dial or keep it always on C
 
Last edited:
I just cannot live without a second card slot, weather sealing, classic controls and the d-pad. So no X-S20 or X-T50 but the X-T5 will be my next camera.
 
And that 3 FS are enough for those who do.
My understanding is that those three positions on the wheel are for saving one of the factory film simulations; you cannot save anything you have customised yourself.
If so, all the more useless for those who really want tp exploit the camera's jpeg capabilities.
 
Omar Gonzalez said so in his first impressions review of X-T50 (in 3:47 min)
It is contradicted here: https://fujixweekly.com/2024/05/16/...ttings-14-new-film-simulation-recipes-yes-14/
Indeed, You are right!
X-T50 has the ability to save SOOC .jpg settings as recipes, and Omar Gonzalez misled everyone!

From fujixweekly:

"Just to be completely clear, the way this works is that you program the Recipe (that’s found below) into either a C1-C7 slot, or (as I did it) into the IQ Menu set. Then, when this Recipe is selected, simply rotate the Film Dial to choose the film simulation that you want to use. There are eight built-into-the-knob film sims, plus three custom, plus “C” (which is whatever you have programmed into the Recipe)."

Ehhh... YouTubers... Thx Omar, GJ with spreading disinformation that I later repeat myself for others :-(

Sorry for misleading everyone - my bad.
although this was not my intention.
To be fair to Omar I think he says 'You can't save recipes on here' and points to the film simulation dial, so I think he's just saying that you can't use the film sim dial to recall custom recipes.

I agree it's ambiguous, though, and could be interpreted as meaning 'you can't save recipes on the camera'...

Anyway, all cleared up now!
Still a more than sub par way to set up and use "on the fly" recipes: to see them, first you have to set the film sim on the dial, and then select the recipe from C1-C7 that is programmed with that film sim? Or in C on the film dial, you use the dial to set and view recipes C1-C7. In either case, one has used the C1 -C7 settings for film sims/ recipes only. So that leaves the Q settings for other variable settings. Hmmm.

I hope that those bying this camera for extensive use of film sims / recipes are soon rewarded with a software update allowing at least to save recipes to the 3 free slots on the dial.

--
DJF
 
Last edited:
In my normal shop the XT5 is 1800 EUR today. Of course it can be bought cheaper online, or used. But give it some time, and the XT50 will go down as well. The XT50 is a much better camera compared to the previous XT30II, so I was expecting a price raise. Same for XS20, which is dearer at launch compared to the XS10. If I were interested in the XT50, I would 6 months or 1 year, and buy it cheaper.
It's 1760€ right now in France, with regular sales under 1700. Launch price in France was 1999€. I agree with the "buy later" part but the X-T5 price will also continue to drop as time goes on. My issue is not with the price itself, but with the lack of separation with the X-T5. and a lightly used X-T5 off MPB is already cheaper than the X-T50's launch price.
Lack of price separation? Sure, but again you are comparing launch price for a new camera versus price of a camera that has been around for 3 years. In 3 years time how much the XT50 will cost?
Even comparing launch price in the US : 1400 vs 1700. That's only a $300 difference, while it used to be 700 to 800. The X-T5 didn't increase in price compared to the X-T4 while the X-T50 is $500 more than the X-T30.

Sure, we can check the prices in 3 years, but the price of the X-T5 will continue to drop also.

European pricing is pretty funny when this is what Google gets you :

516271dcdf694c2b8854836c173fd5ce.jpg.png
In that line of thought, those who want to upgrade from X100 series to ILC in the Fuji ecosystem, will see the XT50 as a natural progression. They even share the sensor and batteries.
Yes, that's my point exactly. They're really putting down the film sim argument harder and harder.

Also, I wouldn't consider the X-T50 a step-up to the X100VI. More like an ILC side grade for people that couldn't get one. An upgrade would men not leaving anything that the X100 has, becised the OVF. EVF is worse, no weather sealing, cheaper build are enough things to make me consider an X-T50 not as a X100VI upgrade.
I can see people that have X100 series camera to be hooked on Fuji, and then wanting a Fuji ILC. The XT50 can be such a camera. The X100VI is also not weather sealed. How do you know the XT50 has cheaper build?
X-Tx0 cameras always had cheaper builds than the X-T series, as well as the X100 series. Generally, thinner metal panels, a bit more plastic used. It seems to still be the case according to reviews I've seen. Also, much lower end EVF, and lower res back panel play a part imho.

Also, both the X100V and X100VI are weather sealed on the body. The front of the lens isn't but you can seal the camera by putting a filter on the lens to seal it. According to Fujifilm the weather sealing on the X100VI's body is about as weather resistant as the X-T5.
It will probably find its public with the people that wanted to buy an X100VI but couldn't due to the long wait times.
The increase in size between XT3 and XT4 is minimal, they were able to accommodate the new battery.
It was not "minimal". The X-T4 was the largest X-T body to date (even compared to the X-T5)
I have used XT3 and XT4, no real difference in use. As your comparison below illustrates, hardly noticeable.
I noticed it quite a bit when I used them
MPB is for used. Again, you are comparing different things. The XTxx series has been maturing in a way to bring it closer to the XTx. Hence, the price differential has been narrowed. Rightly or wrongly, we shall see how it sells.

--
www.paulobizarro.com
 
I would also guess that from a features point of view the continued use of the smaller battery life also allows Fuji to further differentiate the X-Txx from the X-Tx line.
Sure, while the X-T50 is rated as having a battery life of 305 (down from 380 for my X-T30), the X-S20 has a whopping 750! Another argument for the X-S20.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top