S23 Ultra: Bird Photography

  • Thread starter Thread starter jackwelch
  • Start date Start date
J

jackwelch

Guest
All images using the 10x lens with a TC, straight out of camera and roughly 30x zoom (that's roughly 690mm equiv on a smartphone!!)

3f0efa1b02b3465d883ede5787076973.jpg

8346dd5ea0e24918b0fa25996b1a414c.jpg

bbf3b141715241a693024dbc6853c5e2.jpg

4125357047c84c06b213cc5ebfa34593.jpg

adfe6acb353c4301adf034c0faab9be1.jpg

f2eee1b8a20c4581801ba40578234904.jpg

fbde42e347b14acdaacd4dcb30cbc31a.jpg

1de09b65d68249e9b310ca4e213c2abf.jpg

ea0e901303ff44979ff3e656ac430d9e.jpg

972a72e740234c29b086d4e45dbb8850.jpg

Last is a bonus, was trying my luck at bird in flight, autofocus couldn't nail it unfortunately:

d9580b086af64ead98794816e885b246.jpg
 
Last edited:
I see this kind of zoom ideal for amateurs and travellers who wants to capture a moment.

However, it's very far to be good quality to post it as "photography" of a bird.
 
I see this kind of zoom ideal for amateurs and travellers who wants to capture a moment.

However, it's very far to be good quality to post it as "photography" of a bird.
Firstly it's a small smartphone sensor and secondly it's only 12MP.

These are just OOC images, I'm sure in the hands of a real pro who knows how to take a photo and also edit it, you'll get something much much better.
 
Last edited:
I see this kind of zoom ideal for amateurs and travellers who wants to capture a moment.

However, it's very far to be good quality to post it as "photography" of a bird.
Firstly it's a small smartphone sensor and secondly it's only 12MP.

These are just OOC images, I'm sure in the hands of a real pro who knows how to take a photo and also edit it, you'll get something much much better.
 
I see this kind of zoom ideal for amateurs and travellers who wants to capture a moment.

However, it's very far to be good quality to post it as "photography" of a bird.
Firstly it's a small smartphone sensor and secondly it's only 12MP.

These are just OOC images, I'm sure in the hands of a real pro who knows how to take a photo and also edit it, you'll get something much much better.
I was getting very excited with the video quality of the s23U, but when he put up the pictures of the birds about 1/2 way through, the background was horrendous. it was a pixelated blur, not smooth blur like a real camera would give. I am not sure if this can be fixed via software updates etc...but it was terrible.
 
This (bird photography) is one of a handful of areas where I don’t see smartphones replacing dSLRs for the “prosumer” photographer over time. MANY other genres now can be or will be “soon”.

BUT…. Let’s forget about “prosumer photographers” for a minute and let’s talk about “birders”, specifically “newbies” who are trying to learn to ID birds. Little cameras like this are WONDERFUL for helping those newbies (me included) learn to ID various species. These images are already perfect for that. No need for a budding birder to carry 10 pounds of kit plus their binoculars. Now, it’s the binoculars and a smartphone…..
 
This (bird photography) is one of a handful of areas where I don’t see smartphones replacing dSLRs for the “prosumer” photographer over time. MANY other genres now can be or will be “soon”.

BUT…. Let’s forget about “prosumer photographers” for a minute and let’s talk about “birders”, specifically “newbies” who are trying to learn to ID birds. Little cameras like this are WONDERFUL for helping those newbies (me included) learn to ID various species. These images are already perfect for that. No need for a budding birder to carry 10 pounds of kit plus their binoculars. Now, it’s the binoculars and a smartphone…..
A big +1
 
This (bird photography) is one of a handful of areas where I don’t see smartphones replacing dSLRs for the “prosumer” photographer over time. MANY other genres now can be or will be “soon”.

BUT…. Let’s forget about “prosumer photographers” for a minute and let’s talk about “birders”, specifically “newbies” who are trying to learn to ID birds. Little cameras like this are WONDERFUL for helping those newbies (me included) learn to ID various species. These images are already perfect for that. No need for a budding birder to carry 10 pounds of kit plus their binoculars. Now, it’s the binoculars and a smartphone…..
I visit my local nature preserve 2-3 x a week, especially during the migration of waterfowl and have never seen anyone use a smartphone. Why? For me it's simple: no evf, screen washout, shutter lag, little to no zoom (vs a 65-90X optical zoom on p&s bridge cameras). Those clip on lenses are poor. Save the smartphone for selfies.
 
...I was walking in a local park and saw a spot of red near the bottom of a tree. My eyes are terrible these days and the 200mm that I had wasn't really enough to get a great shot.

It did however do well enough to allow me to identify the bird that I saw for less than 2 minutes once I got the shot home and processed.

The shot wasn't great due to missed focus but I was able to add a bird to my life list.
 
I see this kind of zoom ideal for amateurs and travellers who wants to capture a moment.

However, it's very far to be good quality to post it as "photography" of a bird.
Firstly it's a small smartphone sensor and secondly it's only 12MP.

These are just OOC images, I'm sure in the hands of a real pro who knows how to take a photo and also edit it, you'll get something much much better.
 
I was getting very excited with the video quality of the s23U, but when he put up the pictures of the birds about 1/2 way through, the background was horrendous. it was a pixelated blur, not smooth blur like a real camera would give. I am not sure if this can be fixed via software updates etc...but it was terrible.
May not look good for those how had seem what a big camera can do, but for anyone with just a phone this is excellent. It's just a phone 9mm thick, what more can you ask?
 
What you could and probably should do it to set up the phone nearby a birdfeeder, shoot using the 10x optical lens and trigger it via the S-pen. Although there will be some lag you should be able to catch some nice shots. Or simply set the phone to record 8K 30fps video for a while and simply pull some nice shots from the video. :)

/ Magnus
 
I was getting very excited with the video quality of the s23U, but when he put up the pictures of the birds about 1/2 way through, the background was horrendous. it was a pixelated blur, not smooth blur like a real camera would give. I am not sure if this can be fixed via software updates etc...but it was terrible.
May not look good for those how had seem what a big camera can do, but for anyone with just a phone this is excellent. It's just a phone 9mm thick, what more can you ask?
To have my fake blurred background to be done correctly. My iPhone has the same feature but it does it better. Nothing beats real bokeh, but if you are going to fake it, fake it good.
 
I was getting very excited with the video quality of the s23U, but when he put up the pictures of the birds about 1/2 way through, the background was horrendous. it was a pixelated blur, not smooth blur like a real camera would give. I am not sure if this can be fixed via software updates etc...but it was terrible.
May not look good for those how had seem what a big camera can do, but for anyone with just a phone this is excellent. It's just a phone 9mm thick, what more can you ask?
To have my fake blurred background to be done correctly. My iPhone has the same feature but it does it better. Nothing beats real bokeh, but if you are going to fake it, fake it good.
Your iphone is 10 years behind that photos, but lets focus on a bit more fake looking then the already fake looking blur on the iphone, that btw can be adjusted by preference, now let us see your iphone details/textures/denoise/sharpening/artifacts and lets compare with that or other 10x samples?

Or even this 3x one,

AGC-20221009-180609079.jpg
 
Last edited:
Sorry to hijack your thread OP but just to further the discussion on bird photography with the S23 Ultra. Using Gcam, this person on XDA has achieved some excellent results with the 10x on the S22 Ultra (which uses the same sensor as the S23 Ultra).
All comments are welcomed!
 
I was getting very excited with the video quality of the s23U, but when he put up the pictures of the birds about 1/2 way through, the background was horrendous. it was a pixelated blur, not smooth blur like a real camera would give. I am not sure if this can be fixed via software updates etc...but it was terrible.
May not look good for those how had seem what a big camera can do, but for anyone with just a phone this is excellent. It's just a phone 9mm thick, what more can you ask?
To have my fake blurred background to be done correctly. My iPhone has the same feature but it does it better. Nothing beats real bokeh, but if you are going to fake it, fake it good.
Your iphone is 10 years behind that photos, but lets focus on a bit more fake looking then the already fake looking blur on the iphone, that btw can be adjusted by preference, now let us see your iphone details/textures/denoise/sharpening/artifacts and lets compare with that or other 10x samples?

Or even this 3x one,

AGC-20221009-180609079.jpg
Sure, look at the background on this photo...smooth, not pixelated. There is even pixelation in your budgiebird photo. The blur from the S23 Ultra is very pixelated and square blocks are forming the background in those pictures. Seriously..if you cannot see that, take up another hobby. The video footage from the phone is very good however.



From my old iPhone 11 btw...
From my old iPhone 11 btw...



--
Fronterra Photography Tours
One Lens, No Problem
The Point and Shoot Pro
The People of the Red and White stand with the people of the yellow and blue!
 
I was getting very excited with the video quality of the s23U, but when he put up the pictures of the birds about 1/2 way through, the background was horrendous. it was a pixelated blur, not smooth blur like a real camera would give. I am not sure if this can be fixed via software updates etc...but it was terrible.
May not look good for those how had seem what a big camera can do, but for anyone with just a phone this is excellent. It's just a phone 9mm thick, what more can you ask?
To have my fake blurred background to be done correctly. My iPhone has the same feature but it does it better. Nothing beats real bokeh, but if you are going to fake it, fake it good.
Your iphone is 10 years behind that photos, but lets focus on a bit more fake looking then the already fake looking blur on the iphone, that btw can be adjusted by preference, now let us see your iphone details/textures/denoise/sharpening/artifacts and lets compare with that or other 10x samples?

Or even this 3x one,

AGC-20221009-180609079.jpg
Sure, look at the background on this photo...smooth, not pixelated. There is even pixelation in your budgiebird photo. The blur from the S23 Ultra is very pixelated and square blocks are forming the background in those pictures. Seriously..if you cannot see that, take up another hobby. The video footage from the phone is very good however.

From my old iPhone 11 btw...
From my old iPhone 11 btw...


You compare this with the parrot or 10x zoom shots? btw the fake blur is by user choice, you can turn that off completely.
 
To have my fake blurred background to be done correctly. My iPhone has the same feature but it does it better. Nothing beats real bokeh, but if you are going to fake it, fake it good.
Not totally sure about the level of background blur simulation on the iPhones, if you can change the intensity or not, but this is a very common feature. You apply to your taste, so if you don't like the level other person chose for his photos that's your problem.

But that is not the issue, I'm seeing people complaining about how ugly the background blur and bokeh looks on the Galaxies 10x camera. That's inevitable, it's sorta like that on all periscope cameras because of the retangular shape of the lens. IMO this is a non-issue, the principal objective is to give the user more reach and currently it seems impossible to offer such a long reach without resorting to periscope modules, so criticism of it sounds like tantrums because the one your buddy have is bigger than yours.
 
Last edited:

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top