Are the phone mfg's pulling our leg again?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bob A L

Forum Pro
Messages
12,843
Solutions
6
Reaction score
11,494
Did you see the release article in dpr news about the new Xiaomi phone with the huge sensor 12.8% wider on the diagonal than M43 sensors? First it was 10x optical zoom using 3 fixed focal length lenses, now huge sensors bigger than M43. Here's the size shown in the article if you didn't see it.

b99e2f11407441998f911dff23e7ce09.jpg

Wonder how pocketable it will be? Lens would be pretty long wouldn't it?
 
Solution
?? not sure what you are referring to. Yep, I learned that the mfg's will deceive the public with reckless abandon in attempts to glorify their product. And learned that some did not seem to recognize that 1" was an error for the diagonal dimension of the sensor, or maybe thought it was correct? I had just figured that most in this forum knew that the 1" designation for a sensor size was not the diagonal dimension just like the 1/2.3" is not the diagonal dimension of that size sensor. Maybe only us folks that own a 1" sensor camera are aware that 1" is not the diagonal dimension of the sensor.
Is your first post intended to be sarcastic? It does not come across.

using the 1" notation has been standard in advertising material...
They use really wide lenses as these can have a very short profile and sit half a mm from the sensor. The lenses look like corrugated glass one on top of each other, all completely aspherical. This is why they can keep the size small. Put a 50mm equiv. and you need to ideally make the sensor smaller or start becoming very creative how to house it.
 
Not the way it's shown with diagonal lines corner to corner. Maybe this version more clearly indicates what they are telling consumers.



f1b50cf6868a43bc82489274a0dc0145.jpg

Pretty clear here with the arrows clear at the ends of the lines.
 
he made it here too but made it more clear what they meant. Only slightly larger than M43.



4c975a53ad5d4827a1cb6bf863d8b3a0.jpg
 
Not the way it's shown with diagonal lines corner to corner. Maybe this version more clearly indicates what they are telling consumers.

f1b50cf6868a43bc82489274a0dc0145.jpg

Pretty clear here with the arrows clear at the ends of the lines.
Again you fail to understand the point. That line does not tell you it is 1" corner to corner, it's there to tell you that it is a 1" sensor.
 
?? not sure what you are referring to. Yep, I learned that the mfg's will deceive the public with reckless abandon in attempts to glorify their product. And learned that some did not seem to recognize that 1" was an error for the diagonal dimension of the sensor, or maybe thought it was correct? I had just figured that most in this forum knew that the 1" designation for a sensor size was not the diagonal dimension just like the 1/2.3" is not the diagonal dimension of that size sensor. Maybe only us folks that own a 1" sensor camera are aware that 1" is not the diagonal dimension of the sensor.
I know it but don’t care. It’s the results that matter not the specs.
 
Did you see the release article in dpr news about the new Xiaomi phone with the huge sensor 12.8% wider on the diagonal than M43 sensors? First it was 10x optical zoom using 3 fixed focal length lenses,
No, it's optical zoom using zoom lenses. Here's an incomplete list of actual optical zoom cameras.
  • Sony Xperia 1V: 3 fixed lens cameras, 1 1.5x optical zoom.
  • Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra 5G: 2 fixed lens cameras, 1 3x zoom, 1 10x zoom. Other S22 family members only have the 1 zoom camera, the 3x. Samsung has been making zoom cameras since the infamous "S4 zoom" some 13 years ago.
  • Samsung Z-Fold 3: 2 fixed, 1 2x zoom camera.
  • iPhone 13 Pro Max: 2 fixed lens cameras, 1 3x optical zoom camera.
  • iQ00 9 pro: 2 fixed lens cameras, 1 2.5x optical zoom camera.
  • Vivo X70: 3 fixed lens cameras, 1 5x optical zoom camera.
now huge sensors bigger than M43. Here's the size shown in the article if you didn't see it.

Wonder how pocketable it will be? Lens would be pretty long wouldn't it?
There are only four phones that have launched in the last few years with a lens capable of offering multiple FLs on the same sensor, and they all use the same lens - the xperia 1 iii and iv, and xperia 5 iii and iv.
No. What Sony says is that they have the only camera with a particular optical zoom ratio, not that they are the only ones with any sort of optical zoom.
The rest have several prime lenses and use the crop relative to the main sensor to describe their field of view.
And yet the phone makers describe the lenses as "optical zooms", specify different ratios of optical zoom and digital zoom, and enumerate which sensors have zoom lenses and which ones are primes.
The sony cameras have a maximum and minimum FL given for their zoom lens, all the rest give one value - a lens with one FL is not a zoom.
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
I believe that most of the listed phones, by "optical zoom" they mean whatever x compared to the main wide angle lens and don't actually have a lens that can change focal lengths.

I think there was a prior phone, but may be wrong (maybe it was aperture not focal length) that had a camera that could switch between 2 focal lengths.

I believe sony's claim is that the their new phone camera is the first one with movable elements that can change focal lengths in a continuous fashion.
 
Did you see the release article in dpr news about the new Xiaomi phone with the huge sensor 12.8% wider on the diagonal than M43 sensors? First it was 10x optical zoom using 3 fixed focal length lenses,
No, it's optical zoom using zoom lenses. Here's an incomplete list of actual optical zoom cameras.
  • Sony Xperia 1V: 3 fixed lens cameras, 1 1.5x optical zoom.
  • Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra 5G: 2 fixed lens cameras, 1 3x zoom, 1 10x zoom. Other S22 family members only have the 1 zoom camera, the 3x. Samsung has been making zoom cameras since the infamous "S4 zoom" some 13 years ago.
  • Samsung Z-Fold 3: 2 fixed, 1 2x zoom camera.
  • iPhone 13 Pro Max: 2 fixed lens cameras, 1 3x optical zoom camera.
  • iQ00 9 pro: 2 fixed lens cameras, 1 2.5x optical zoom camera.
  • Vivo X70: 3 fixed lens cameras, 1 5x optical zoom camera.
now huge sensors bigger than M43. Here's the size shown in the article if you didn't see it.

Wonder how pocketable it will be? Lens would be pretty long wouldn't it?
There are only four phones that have launched in the last few years with a lens capable of offering multiple FLs on the same sensor, and they all use the same lens - the xperia 1 iii and iv, and xperia 5 iii and iv.
No. What Sony says is that they have the only camera with a particular optical zoom ratio, not that they are the only ones with any sort of optical zoom.
The rest have several prime lenses and use the crop relative to the main sensor to describe their field of view.
And yet the phone makers describe the lenses as "optical zooms", specify different ratios of optical zoom and digital zoom, and enumerate which sensors have zoom lenses and which ones are primes.
The sony cameras have a maximum and minimum FL given for their zoom lens, all the rest give one value - a lens with one FL is not a zoom.
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
They use the phrase "optical zoom" to refer to the cropped FoV relative to the main camera, not a zoom lens. This is standard practice in the smartphone world, and often causes confusion among photographers. It started as a way to differentiate from advertisements claiming "2x digital zoom" or similar, and as you know digital zoom does not make a zoom lens either.

If they had actual zoom lenses:
  1. People wouldn't be describing the sony phones as the only phones with true zoom lenses
  2. They would publish minimum and maximum FL equivalents. If the latest Samsung phones have a zoom, what is the maximum and minimum eq. FL? Is it mentioned in any marketing materials? There is only one focal length given for each sensor on all the phones you listed (bar sony and that old samsung camera with a phone stuck to it); and one focal length means it's a prime.
 
The problem is simply the way people and marketing differentiate between the word "zoom".

Most consumers (and the point you're making) take it as a continuous, variable FL lens, like whats used in DSLR/Mirrorless/bridge cameras.

Phone makers mean it as "telephoto".

S22 Ultra example: The phones have a true optical 10x telephoto compared to the "standard" 1x mode. It doesn't do anything digitally to get the 10x FL, all optics. However, it's a fixed lens. Anything between the 1x, 3x, and 10x are stitched from those 3 lenses. The problem is they call them 10x "zoom" lenses, when it's not what they mean.
 
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
The list of phones with cameras offering true "optical zoom" capabilities by the movement the elements of a lens in front of a sensor is extremely short.
What they call "optical zoom" is actually the shifting between cameras with lenses of different fixed focal lengths.

A smartphone with a true optical zoom at last! Why Sony Xperia 1 IV is the real deal

"So why do so many camera phones apparently have optical zooms according to the internet? Because, they have multiple prime lenses around the back, and they digital zoom between focal lengths. The common setup is an ultra-wide camera of around 16mm, that digital zooms until it reaches a primary camera’s focal length, which is usually around 25mm, and sometimes, there’s a third or fourth lens, from anything between 50mm to 200mm or greater. The reason for this multiple-prime-lens solution is space – optical zooms take a lot of space, and smartphones pride themselves on being pocket-friendly."
 
Last edited:
I believe that most of the listed phones, by "optical zoom" they mean whatever x compared to the main wide angle lens and don't actually have a lens that can change focal lengths.

I think there was a prior phone, but may be wrong (maybe it was aperture not focal length) that had a camera that could switch between 2 focal lengths.

I believe sony's claim is that the their new phone camera is the first one with movable elements that can change focal lengths in a continuous fashion.
As a matter of fact, my Asus Zenfone zoom (ZX551ML), an early 3G phone released in 2015, already used a 3x Hoya optical zoom lens in periscopic design:

13bea868d5524649b5382ab897da330e.jpg.png

Optical zoom is nothing new. Just this design had increased the thickness of the phone slightly making it not very welcome to everyone at that time.

--
Albert
** Please forgive my typo error.
** Please feel free to download my image and edit it as you like :-) **
 
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
The list of phones with cameras offering true "optical zoom" capabilities by the movement the elements of a lens in front of a sensor is extremely short.

A smartphone with a true optical zoom at last! Why Sony Xperia 1 IV is the real deal

"So why do so many camera phones apparently have optical zooms according to the internet? Because, they have multiple prime lenses around the back, and they digital zoom between focal lengths. The common setup is an ultra-wide camera of around 16mm, that digital zooms until it reaches a primary camera’s focal length, which is usually around 25mm, and sometimes, there’s a third or fourth lens, from anything between 50mm to 200mm or greater. The reason for this multiple-prime-lens solution is space – optical zooms take a lot of space, and smartphones pride themselves on being pocket-friendly."
I don't think that article is true (the first one to have an optical zoom lens). My 8 years old Asus Zenfone zoom already had a 3x optical zoom lens (in periscopic design) from Hoya. Just it is not a very popular brand in the world making and Asus itself has never marketing its phone product well as its computer product therefore not many people aware of it.

 
"Bob A L • Veteran Member • Posts: 4,687"

Please do yourself a favor: "Yes guys. I was wrong. I didn't know about 1''-type sensor". The definition next to your name asks for it.
 
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
The list of phones with cameras offering true "optical zoom" capabilities by the movement the elements of a lens in front of a sensor is extremely short.

A smartphone with a true optical zoom at last! Why Sony Xperia 1 IV is the real deal

"So why do so many camera phones apparently have optical zooms according to the internet? Because, they have multiple prime lenses around the back, and they digital zoom between focal lengths. The common setup is an ultra-wide camera of around 16mm, that digital zooms until it reaches a primary camera’s focal length, which is usually around 25mm, and sometimes, there’s a third or fourth lens, from anything between 50mm to 200mm or greater. The reason for this multiple-prime-lens solution is space – optical zooms take a lot of space, and smartphones pride themselves on being pocket-friendly."
I don't think that article is true (the first one to have an optical zoom lens). My 8 years old Asus Zenfone zoom already had a 3x optical zoom lens (in periscopic design) from Hoya. Just it is not a very popular brand in the world making and Asus itself has never marketing its phone product well as its computer product therefore not many people aware of it.

https://www.gsmarena.com/asus_zenfone_zoom_zx550-6918.php
The article doesn't say it was "the first one to have an optical zoom lens", it says it was “the world’s first optical zoom* 85mm-125mm on a smartphone”.
 
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
The list of phones with cameras offering true "optical zoom" capabilities by the movement the elements of a lens in front of a sensor is extremely short.

A smartphone with a true optical zoom at last! Why Sony Xperia 1 IV is the real deal

"So why do so many camera phones apparently have optical zooms according to the internet? Because, they have multiple prime lenses around the back, and they digital zoom between focal lengths. The common setup is an ultra-wide camera of around 16mm, that digital zooms until it reaches a primary camera’s focal length, which is usually around 25mm, and sometimes, there’s a third or fourth lens, from anything between 50mm to 200mm or greater. The reason for this multiple-prime-lens solution is space – optical zooms take a lot of space, and smartphones pride themselves on being pocket-friendly."
I don't think that article is true (the first one to have an optical zoom lens). My 8 years old Asus Zenfone zoom already had a 3x optical zoom lens (in periscopic design) from Hoya. Just it is not a very popular brand in the world making and Asus itself has never marketing its phone product well as its computer product therefore not many people aware of it.

https://www.gsmarena.com/asus_zenfone_zoom_zx550-6918.php
The article doesn't say it was "the first one to have an optical zoom lens", it says it was “the world’s first optical zoom* 85mm-125mm on a smartphone”.
Oop then it makes sense.

We can expect many more World's first optical zoom for smartphone, says 24-70, 35-105 or 100-300.... :-)
 
"Bob A L • Veteran Member • Posts: 4,687"

Please do yourself a favor: "Yes guys. I was wrong. I didn't know about 1''-type sensor". The definition next to your name asks for it.
I'm pretty sure he, like the rest of us, knows that a 1" sensor is about only 0.62" corner to corner diagonally.

I'm also pretty sure the marketing material that implies a measurement of 1" corner to corner can be considered as misleading.

d511f4f11a254c70aa8ce0c639a51da6.jpg
 
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
The list of phones with cameras offering true "optical zoom" capabilities by the movement the elements of a lens in front of a sensor is extremely short.

A smartphone with a true optical zoom at last! Why Sony Xperia 1 IV is the real deal

"So why do so many camera phones apparently have optical zooms according to the internet? Because, they have multiple prime lenses around the back, and they digital zoom between focal lengths. The common setup is an ultra-wide camera of around 16mm, that digital zooms until it reaches a primary camera’s focal length, which is usually around 25mm, and sometimes, there’s a third or fourth lens, from anything between 50mm to 200mm or greater. The reason for this multiple-prime-lens solution is space – optical zooms take a lot of space, and smartphones pride themselves on being pocket-friendly."
I don't think that article is true (the first one to have an optical zoom lens). My 8 years old Asus Zenfone zoom already had a 3x optical zoom lens (in periscopic design) from Hoya. Just it is not a very popular brand in the world making and Asus itself has never marketing its phone product well as its computer product therefore not many people aware of it.

https://www.gsmarena.com/asus_zenfone_zoom_zx550-6918.php
The article doesn't say it was "the first one to have an optical zoom lens", it says it was “the world’s first optical zoom* 85mm-125mm on a smartphone”.
Oop then it makes sense.

We can expect many more World's first optical zoom for smartphone, says 24-70, 35-105 or 100-300.... :-)
You bet... that's how the marketing people justify their jobs. 😉
 
"Bob A L • Veteran Member • Posts: 4,687"

Please do yourself a favor: "Yes guys. I was wrong. I didn't know about 1''-type sensor". The definition next to your name asks for it.
I'm pretty sure he, like the rest of us, knows that a 1" sensor is about only 0.62" corner to corner diagonally.

I'm also pretty sure the marketing material that implies a measurement of 1" corner to corner can be considered as misleading.
I'm pretty sure that the marketing material in question implies nothing more than some marketing exec or artist not knowing how old vidcon tube sizes related to modern imaging, combined with working in a country that uses metric measurements.

Are you familiar with the principle of "Hanlon's Razor"? Back in the late 1970s, Robert J. Hanlon famously said:
Misunderstandings and lethargy perhaps produce more wrong in the world than deceit and malice do.
So, the pictures are definitely in error, but will that error help sell more cameras? Nope! The average user isn't going to care that their sensor is x mm. They're only going to care that "it's so much bigger than the Apple iPhone 13 pro!".

Now, it's pretty obvious that Bob A L is also in error, and is stubbornly doubling down on it at every step instead of admitting he might have made a mistake. Do you think he's genuinely misleading and malicious, or do you think he's just an example of the same Hanlon's razor that Xiaomi fell victim to?
 
There are only four phones that have launched in the last few years with a lens capable of offering multiple FLs on the same sensor, and they all use the same lens - the xperia 1 iii and iv, and xperia 5 iii and iv.
No. What Sony says is that they have the only camera with a particular optical zoom ratio, not that they are the only ones with any sort of optical zoom.
The rest have several prime lenses and use the crop relative to the main sensor to describe their field of view.
And yet the phone makers describe the lenses as "optical zooms", specify different ratios of optical zoom and digital zoom, and enumerate which sensors have zoom lenses and which ones are primes.
The sony cameras have a maximum and minimum FL given for their zoom lens, all the rest give one value - a lens with one FL is not a zoom.
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
I believe that most of the listed phones, by "optical zoom" they mean whatever x compared to the main wide angle lens and don't actually have a lens that can change focal lengths.
What you "believe" the phone companies "mean" is irrelevant. What will hold up in court when the things get to false advertising charges is what matters, and that is based entirely on "standards of the community", in short "how does a photographer define an 'optical zoom'?" Not an advertiser, a photographer.
I think there was a prior phone, but may be wrong
I'm almost certain you are. Your arguments are literally not making any sense to me.
(maybe it was aperture not focal length) that had a camera that could switch between 2 focal lengths.

I believe sony's claim is that the their new phone camera is the first one with movable elements that can change focal lengths in a continuous fashion.
You can "believe" whatever you wish to believe, or you can look at the images of the print ads that state exactly what I said they do.

--
Christine Fleischer 1947-2014.
My soulmate. There are no other words.
-----
Rahon Klavanian 1912-2008.
Armenian genocide survivor, amazing cook, scrabble master, and loving grandmother. You will be missed.
----
Ciao! Joseph
www.swissarmyfork.com
 
Last edited:
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
They use the phrase "optical zoom" to refer to the cropped FoV relative to the main camera, not a zoom lens.
Nope.
This is standard practice in the smartphone world, and often causes confusion among photographers.
Again, no. Did you notice elsewhere where someone posted the mechanism of a smart phone from over a decade ago with an optical zoom lens.
It started as a way to differentiate from advertisements claiming "2x digital zoom" or similar,
How do you "differentiate" by claiming that the same thing is different.
and as you know digital zoom does not make a zoom lens either.
Yep. Which only means your claims won't hold in court.
If they had actual zoom lenses:
  1. People wouldn't be describing the sony phones as the only phones with true zoom lenses
Bingo. People aren't describing "the sony phones as the only phones with true zoom lenses", so by your logic, your points are groundless. It's a classic "If A then B" fallacy, because A is not true, therefore you can't say anything about B.
  1. They would publish minimum and maximum FL equivalents.
Why?

You've basically made an argument that requires the rest of us to accept an arbitrary condition you declare as a condition for something totally unrelated.

Now, I know you want Sony to be right and holy and all, but no. Just no.
 
Do you seriously believe that phone maker after phone maker would be using the term "optical zoom" in their spec sheets and advertisements if they didn't have it? Complaints would pour in (mostly from their competitors, masquerading as customers) about it, and various advertising standards agencies would shut that down so fast it would make your head spin.
The list of phones with cameras offering true "optical zoom" capabilities by the movement the elements of a lens in front of a sensor is extremely short.
What they call "optical zoom" is actually the shifting between cameras with lenses of different fixed focal lengths.
In that case, every phone in the world that shifted between two cameras would be advertising "optical zoom".
They don't, so the logic of the article you quoted is fatally flawed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top