Metallic papers

nickbatz

Senior Member
Messages
1,904
Solutions
1
Reaction score
367
Do they look like they're printed on silver-colored metal?

Put another way, are these prints what commercial printers sell as metallic? (I've seen those, just not sure whether they're the same thing.)

If so, is this stuff any good? I'm going to use a Canon Pro-100.


TIA
 
The metallic papers I've looked at do not look like they are on metal.

The effect is caused by what look like fine mica (or similar) crystals in the coating of the paper.

here's one that looks good for some images on the PRO-200


also mentioned in


There is a lustre version as well, which seems to be slightly rougher and with bigger crystals
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:


It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:


as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
 
Last edited:
I've printed with Epson and Red River Metallic papers. They look glossy and have a pearlescent metallic shine, but definitely do not look like they are printed on metal at all. Also, it only looks good when there is bright light so that you can see how the light reflects off of the print.

It does make for a cool effect, but color profiles are also harder to nail down.
 
Thanks.

I've seen pictures printed on metal, and some of mine would work really well on it.

They're modern art rather than pictures of things, though, so exact color calibration is less important than density.
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.

BayPhoto uses a Kodak Endura Metalic paper (their metalic option). I was interested in trying. Does your comment above of very poor quality apply here, or are there different metallic papers from Kodak?
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
BayPhoto uses a Kodak Endura Metalic paper (their metalic option). I was interested in trying. Does your comment above of very poor quality apply here, or are there different metallic papers from Kodak?
Endura is a RA-4 paper not an inkjet one so my comments do not apply to it. I've never seen it but I've heard that it looks good.
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
BayPhoto uses a Kodak Endura Metalic paper (their metalic option). I was interested in trying. Does your comment above of very poor quality apply here, or are there different metallic papers from Kodak?
Endura is a RA-4 paper not an inkjet one so my comments do not apply to it. I've never seen it but I've heard that it looks good.
Thanks for that distinction. I can’t believe the rabbit whole I went down with this thread. No wonder so many just get their own photo printer! Damn the costs! 😂

At least I’m learning quite a bit. More than I wanted to.
 
Hahnemühle photo rag metallic has a distinctly silvery coating.
I love it and am still learning how and what to print with it. It's very very different from regular metallic paper and the only one that's OBA free. Definitely worth experimenting with.
 
I use both Red River metallic papers (gloss and satin). For my HDR stuff, the gloss is terrific. I get a lot of compliments on color rendition. But, this is NOT for wildlife or people pictures.

I use the satin version on a lot of my B&W shots, especially architecture. It's a bit more subtle, but it still give the shots a bit of 'oomph' for lack of a better term. I don't use this for wildlife or people, either.

To answer your question, it is not the equivalent of aluminum prints.

David
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
I just tried the Breathing Color Vibrance Metallic paper and it indeed gives an appearance quite similar to metal prints. The manufacturer specifications say the base is mixed, but do not disclose the OBA's. Do you have any information on that?
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
I just tried the Breathing Color Vibrance Metallic paper and it indeed gives an appearance quite similar to metal prints. The manufacturer specifications say the base is mixed, but do not disclose the OBA's. Do you have any information on that?
All metallic papers contain OBAs except for Hahnemuhle's Metallic Rag which has a very different (but also very beautiful) look from regular metallic paper.
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
I just tried the Breathing Color Vibrance Metallic paper and it indeed gives an appearance quite similar to metal prints. The manufacturer specifications say the base is mixed, but do not disclose the OBA's. Do you have any information on that?
All metallic papers contain OBAs except for Hahnemuhle's Metallic Rag which has a very different (but also very beautiful) look from regular metallic paper.
Yes, but minimal OBA's or loaded. I suppose there is no way to know. I've used the Hahnemuhle from the sample pack. It's nice but, as you point out, not the same look. The Breathing Color product was just the look I was seeking. I've not seen noticeable yellowing from OBA papers over the last decade, but archival it's not.
 
Last edited:
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
I just tried the Breathing Color Vibrance Metallic paper and it indeed gives an appearance quite similar to metal prints. The manufacturer specifications say the base is mixed, but do not disclose the OBA's. Do you have any information on that?
All metallic papers contain OBAs except for Hahnemuhle's Metallic Rag which has a very different (but also very beautiful) look from regular metallic paper.
Yes, but minimal OBA's or loaded. I suppose there is no way to know.
I have a UV light (purchased from Amazon for around $15) and you can tell by the intensity of the reflection. Bright white means a lot whereas a light purple means a lesser amount. Just use a non OBA paper as a reference point.



But I would bet on a lot. Just remember that OBAs only fade if they are exposed to UV light, and with most people today using LED lighting, which has no UV, OBAs aren't problem they used to be.
 
At one time a few companies were selling metallic papers that actually had a silver coating, but most images looked pretty bad on them so I think they've been discontinued.

I've tested four of them and my favorite is from Breathing Color:

https://www.breathingcolor.com/coll...ucts/vibrance-metallic?variant=31561252896864

It looks more metallic than the others which are more pearlescent, but it's a matter of taste.

Red River is also popular:

https://www.redrivercatalog.com/browse/metallic-paper.html

as is Moab and Epson. Kodak also has one but it is to be avoided as it's of very poor quality.
I just tried the Breathing Color Vibrance Metallic paper and it indeed gives an appearance quite similar to metal prints. The manufacturer specifications say the base is mixed, but do not disclose the OBA's. Do you have any information on that?
All metallic papers contain OBAs except for Hahnemuhle's Metallic Rag which has a very different (but also very beautiful) look from regular metallic paper.
Yes, but minimal OBA's or loaded. I suppose there is no way to know.
I have a UV light (purchased from Amazon for around $15) and you can tell by the intensity of the reflection. Bright white means a lot whereas a light purple means a lesser amount. Just use a non OBA paper as a reference point.

But I would bet on a lot. Just remember that OBAs only fade if they are exposed to UV light, and with most people today using LED lighting, which has no UV, OBAs aren't problem they used to be.
All good information. Thanks.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top