I'm torn. Those of you who made the decision, which did you pick? I know, I know. I'm going to get the standard "it depends on your needs, budget, etc".
If you could tell me *your* reasons for picking one over the other, I'd really appreciate it.
I didn't pick one over the other (in my case XT2 versus XT4). I like having both.
After reading through your responses if becomes evident that you already are in possession of both cameras, which puts you in a better position to decide for yourself versus investing your hard earned money based on the well intended experience of others.
As others have suggested keep both and force yourself to work with the constraints or flexibilities of them. You'll lose money selling either if you purchased them new. But if you're just kicking tires and are still in the return period then don't complain later when you buy something else as new and find the product has already been tried by someone else.
Even if you were out with your XT4, there's no guarantee you will have the proper lens mounted at the moment you need it. Of course chances are better with a zoom but still a possibility.
But for me, if only one camera body, it would have to be the one that gives me the most flexibility. My X100V is strictly an option, albeit the one that is with me more than the others.
Hope you are satisfied and can rest easily with whatever decision you make.