IF you edit HDR video on Mac/PC which monitor do you use?

BlueCosmo5050

Senior Member
Messages
1,772
Solutions
4
Reaction score
1,178
So, I have HDR camera and I really like the look of it. But I want to edit it on a large monitor. I have a newer MacBook Pro which says it supports HDR-10 output.

You'd think this would be easy... search for a 27 to 32 inch monitor with true HDR (not software HDR) and be done with it. However I searched Bestbuy, Amazon, B&H Photo, and I'm totally confused. There doesn't seem to be many true ones.

What are you using? With PC or MAC. I really don't care if it's 4k or 5k. I obviously can't afford Apples XDR monitor, it's around 5 or 6 grand and I'm only doing this as a hobby as of now.

I do care about HDR though. Since I've been able to record in 10 bit HDR it's become more important to me than 4k. I was always a fan of HDR photography and now to have videos where I can see the sky, the foreground, etc in a high contrast situation is amazing. And I don't even have to shoot log and go through a million processes to get it to look that way.

Right now I'm still on the Thunderbolt monitor. Although I've bought new MacBooks over the years, I've stayed with the same old Thunderbolt Monitor, the original one (Or it might be the second one if there was a second one) I've had it since like 2011 I believe.

I don't want to downgrade. Although this Thunderbolt monitor is not 4k, it is 2560x1440 IPS, it actually still looks better than most monitors I see, including 4k ones. In fact, if you put this monitor next to a 27 inch 5k iMac, it really doesn't look all that different. The 5k iMac is basically this monitor running in retina mode. Or that's one way to think of it if this monitor had more pixels.

On Apple's website they recommend the LG 5k monitor for 1299 but it doesn't even have HDR.

I may have to go to a gaming website and ask some gamers what they use because I know a lot of them have true HDR.
 
So, I have HDR camera and I really like the look of it.
What variant of HDR does your camera shoot in, HLG?
But I want to edit it on a large monitor. I have a newer MacBook Pro which says it supports HDR-10 output.
I'd say that the majority of monitors are falsely advertised as HDR, because they don't have deep enough black levels or a high enough cd/m2 brightness rating to meet an HDR standard. OLED or full-array-local-dimming LCD displays will have deep blacks, but you also need to check the cd/m2 rating and confirm it meets the HDR standard. It's also advisable to calibrate the display to ensure proper color, saturation, & contrast.

My TV was advertised as HDR, but it can't display true HDR, so I tone map S-Log2 to SDR.

P.S. Some monitors that are advertised as 10-bit are actually 8-Bit+FRC.
 
I have (soon to be "had") a Razer gaming laptop with an OLED display. But after trying the new MacBook with the M1 chip, I am switching.

My current setup is a USB 3.2 USB-C hub with an HDMI port, two ports for keyboard and mouse, and a fast USB SSD drive. Almost forgot it has a USB-C power input too to charge the MacBook. I just plug in the one cable and I get everything.

But I've lost HDR. The hub supports 4K 60p, but I don't know if it supports HDR too. And like you I don't know of any good HDR monitors,

And if you haven't seen yet, the little MacBooks with only 8GB of RAM are blazing fast when editing 4K video. I edit 8K video on mine too.
 
So, I have HDR camera and I really like the look of it. But I want to edit it on a large monitor. I have a newer MacBook Pro which says it supports HDR-10 output.

You'd think this would be easy... search for a 27 to 32 inch monitor with true HDR (not software HDR) and be done with it. However I searched Bestbuy, Amazon, B&H Photo, and I'm totally confused. There doesn't seem to be many true ones.

What are you using? With PC or MAC. I really don't care if it's 4k or 5k. I obviously can't afford Apples XDR monitor, it's around 5 or 6 grand and I'm only doing this as a hobby as of now.

I do care about HDR though. Since I've been able to record in 10 bit HDR it's become more important to me than 4k. I was always a fan of HDR photography and now to have videos where I can see the sky, the foreground, etc in a high contrast situation is amazing. And I don't even have to shoot log and go through a million processes to get it to look that way.

Right now I'm still on the Thunderbolt monitor. Although I've bought new MacBooks over the years, I've stayed with the same old Thunderbolt Monitor, the original one (Or it might be the second one if there was a second one) I've had it since like 2011 I believe.

I don't want to downgrade. Although this Thunderbolt monitor is not 4k, it is 2560x1440 IPS, it actually still looks better than most monitors I see, including 4k ones. In fact, if you put this monitor next to a 27 inch 5k iMac, it really doesn't look all that different. The 5k iMac is basically this monitor running in retina mode. Or that's one way to think of it if this monitor had more pixels.

On Apple's website they recommend the LG 5k monitor for 1299 but it doesn't even have HDR.

I may have to go to a gaming website and ask some gamers what they use because I know a lot of them have true HDR.
Benq is HDR-10 compatible and it shows in system preferences

no computer display is HLG compatible

after long evaluation I have switched off HDR and I only switch it on if I am doing a PQ project because the effect on standard content is ugly

it also disables adobe rgb and other schemes you may want to use
 
So, I have HDR camera and I really like the look of it. But I want to edit it on a large monitor. I have a newer MacBook Pro which says it supports HDR-10 output.

You'd think this would be easy... search for a 27 to 32 inch monitor with true HDR (not software HDR) and be done with it. However I searched Bestbuy, Amazon, B&H Photo, and I'm totally confused. There doesn't seem to be many true ones.

What are you using? With PC or MAC. I really don't care if it's 4k or 5k. I obviously can't afford Apples XDR monitor, it's around 5 or 6 grand and I'm only doing this as a hobby as of now.

I do care about HDR though. Since I've been able to record in 10 bit HDR it's become more important to me than 4k. I was always a fan of HDR photography and now to have videos where I can see the sky, the foreground, etc in a high contrast situation is amazing. And I don't even have to shoot log and go through a million processes to get it to look that way.

Right now I'm still on the Thunderbolt monitor. Although I've bought new MacBooks over the years, I've stayed with the same old Thunderbolt Monitor, the original one (Or it might be the second one if there was a second one) I've had it since like 2011 I believe.

I don't want to downgrade. Although this Thunderbolt monitor is not 4k, it is 2560x1440 IPS, it actually still looks better than most monitors I see, including 4k ones. In fact, if you put this monitor next to a 27 inch 5k iMac, it really doesn't look all that different. The 5k iMac is basically this monitor running in retina mode. Or that's one way to think of it if this monitor had more pixels.

On Apple's website they recommend the LG 5k monitor for 1299 but it doesn't even have HDR.

I may have to go to a gaming website and ask some gamers what they use because I know a lot of them have true HDR.
I didn't realize at first, but my new M1 MacBook display supports HDR video. Is it really HDR? It doesn't look like it. It looks better, but not like my OLED TV.
 
So, I have HDR camera and I really like the look of it. But I want to edit it on a large monitor. I have a newer MacBook Pro which says it supports HDR-10 output.

You'd think this would be easy... search for a 27 to 32 inch monitor with true HDR (not software HDR) and be done with it. However I searched Bestbuy, Amazon, B&H Photo, and I'm totally confused. There doesn't seem to be many true ones.

What are you using? With PC or MAC. I really don't care if it's 4k or 5k. I obviously can't afford Apples XDR monitor, it's around 5 or 6 grand and I'm only doing this as a hobby as of now.

I do care about HDR though. Since I've been able to record in 10 bit HDR it's become more important to me than 4k. I was always a fan of HDR photography and now to have videos where I can see the sky, the foreground, etc in a high contrast situation is amazing. And I don't even have to shoot log and go through a million processes to get it to look that way.

Right now I'm still on the Thunderbolt monitor. Although I've bought new MacBooks over the years, I've stayed with the same old Thunderbolt Monitor, the original one (Or it might be the second one if there was a second one) I've had it since like 2011 I believe.

I don't want to downgrade. Although this Thunderbolt monitor is not 4k, it is 2560x1440 IPS, it actually still looks better than most monitors I see, including 4k ones. In fact, if you put this monitor next to a 27 inch 5k iMac, it really doesn't look all that different. The 5k iMac is basically this monitor running in retina mode. Or that's one way to think of it if this monitor had more pixels.

On Apple's website they recommend the LG 5k monitor for 1299 but it doesn't even have HDR.

I may have to go to a gaming website and ask some gamers what they use because I know a lot of them have true HDR.
I didn't realize at first, but my new M1 MacBook display supports HDR video. Is it really HDR? It doesn't look like it. It looks better, but not like my OLED TV.
You need to play HDR content to see the benefit. Rent something from the Apple TV application otherwise you won't see anything thats correct
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top