Which software is best for making luminosity masks to combine images with different exposures?

Theovv

Active member
Messages
91
Reaction score
11
Hi guys,

I have been looking for a technique for landscape photography to blend multiple photo's with different exposures (at least 1 underexposed for the sky, 1 normal exposed and 1 overexposed for the foreground) into 1 photo, by using luminosity masks.

Until now, I have been doing this with 32bit HDR from lightroom to photoshop and back, to avoid the real HDR-look, that I don't like. But it gives me not enough contral to adjust the photos locally. So that's why I became enthousiastic about Luminosity masks, but I've havent started using them.

I want to try to achieve the best quality as possible and start learning on a specific panel or software. I found many types of software, like TK7, Raya Pro/Instamask, Lumi32, Lumenzia.
Without having tested those, I am leaning towards Lumenzia, which seems to be a favourite choice, or Lumi32, because it seems to offer the highest quality, with a special software and an algorithm designed to do just that: create the best luminosity masks.
What are your opinions about the best (in highest quality) luminosity masking software or panel, especially about Lumenzia and Lumi 32? A tool with good free tutorials would also be a pro.

(I also kinda wonder why Jimmy McIntyre now offers Raya Pro, Instamask and Lumi 32 which can all be used for luminosity masks in another way. I know Raya Pro offers other tools as well, but which one of those 3 is the best for luminosity masking and what is the difference?)

Thanks in advance!
 
Sometimes locally toning down some highlights on the 'over-exposed' frame or doing the opposite, working on bringing up some shadows locally on the 'under-exposed' frame before combining making a difference in the combined HDR final image LR gives you.
You can do that, but I don't want the highlights from the overexposured frame or shadows of the under exposed frame, I want to combine to well exposed parts of each frame, and with luminosity masks, I can select and combine those parts.
Ah, so you make a mask for the highlights for example, then turn it into a selection. That way nothing but the highlights will be blended from that layer into the mids and darks layers, right? Thanks for this.
 
I haven't started working with them, but I think that is the function of exposure blending by luminosity masks.
 
Last edited:
For those interested Greg Benz has had his Lumenzia software on sale at $39.99 recently and today Jimmy McIntyre announced a $22.50 half price sale on Raya Pro.

Greg Benz - Lumenzia: Luminosity Masking Panel for Photoshop

Jimmy McIntyre - Shutter…Evolve – Luminosity Masks, Digital Blending, HDR Tutorials for Landscape & Cityscape Photographers
Interested to hear if anyone has any experience with either of these panels (Lumenzia vs Raya Pro) and the courses/tutorials offered.

I've only really done post processing in LR and am a PS novice (having only done some YouTube tutorials). Would be great to support these photographers while also being able to learn about exposure blending and luminosity masks. Currently considering these two but open to to other suggestions.

Thanks!
 
For those interested Greg Benz has had his Lumenzia software on sale at $39.99 recently and today Jimmy McIntyre announced a $22.50 half price sale on Raya Pro.

Greg Benz - Lumenzia: Luminosity Masking Panel for Photoshop

Jimmy McIntyre - Shutter…Evolve – Luminosity Masks, Digital Blending, HDR Tutorials for Landscape & Cityscape Photographers
Interested to hear if anyone has any experience with either of these panels (Lumenzia vs Raya Pro) and the courses/tutorials offered.

I've only really done post processing in LR and am a PS novice (having only done some YouTube tutorials). Would be great to support these photographers while also being able to learn about exposure blending and luminosity masks. Currently considering these two but open to to other suggestions.
Not a tutorial but interesting:


 
Just adding some information about a third option. Jimmy McIntyre's Lumi32 came out a few months ago, and a week or two back he made a Lumi32 course available. I'm using Lumi32 with his course and I'm quite satisfied. Unlike Raya Pro, which is like a Swiss Army knife for Photoshop, Lumi32 is very focused on doing just one thing: luminosity masks; but it's really simple to use and quite powerful at the same time.

Because luminosity masking requires an understanding of Photoshop's layers and masks, McIntyre has made a three video beginners' Photoshop course available as a separate download when you buy the Lumi32 course. I find McInTyre's Lumi32 course to be very thorough. The course consists of 11 videos covering everything from a simple blend using two exposures up to blending panoramas. He also supplies the image files required for each lesson.

Hope this is useful.
Peter
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top