Regulated vs. Unregulated AC Power Adaptors

  • Thread starter Thread starter Paul
  • Start date Start date
P

Paul

Guest
There was a thread started some time ago that was revived again (by me) asking about the possible damage that could be done to a camera using the DigiPower AC Adapters that is sold on Thomas-Distributing's web site (that so many seem to use).

That thread (if anyone likes to read "history") is http://www.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1008&message=610854

I have since posed the question to Thomas-Distributing but have not yet gotten a reply from them.

Today, by coincidence, I stumbled on useful information on Cliff Shade's site. It appears that the DigiPower Direct AC Adapter is regulated.

The URL is http://www.cliffshade.com/dpfwiw/c-2000z/power/index.htm#need

The text is, as follows:

Oly AC Adapters

Oly-brand AC adapters are expensive, but you're paying in part for the security of a regulated adapter that won't fry your camera, which cost 15 times more.

The Oly C-6AU Adapter (discontinued)
I own one of these, but I'm no longer sure why. I seldom carry it.

The now discontinued regulated C-6AU outputs 6.5VDC and 2A via a 4.8 mm OD center-positive plug. AC input is listed at 110-120V at 50/60 Hz and rated for 20W.

I originally purchased my C-6AU for my Oly D-340L, but it works with the C-20x0Z as well. This adapter's fairly large and heavy, and its plug doesn't fold down for packing.

The Oly C-7AU Universal Adapter

The C-7AU's DC output is 2A, like that of the C-6AU. From pictures, its wall plug doesn't look foldable. The C-7AU's AC input is dual voltage (110-120V, 220V). Per Olympus, the C-7AU is designed to work with its entire current line of digital cameras, so its camera plug is presumably the same as that of the C-6AU, which the C-7AU replaced.

Currently, the C-7AU goes for $40-50 mail order. Oly specifies the C-7AU for its newer C-30x0Z and C-2100UZ cameras as well.

A Viable Alternative to Pricey Oly AC Adapters

Many RPD posts have discussed alternatives to the reliable but pricey Oly-brand adapters. Most of these posts have been of the "I've gotten away with it so far" genre.

It's clear enough that 6VDC is adequate to power Oly digicams via their DC power connectors. How much amperage is required is not so clear, but the answer lies somewhere in the 800-2000mA range.

Honey, I Fried the Camera

Whether one should trust an expensive digital camera to a cheap unregulated power supply is another question entirely. Connecting your Camedia to any old 6V, 1A adapter amounts to a potentially costly leap of faith, since most inexpensive, off-the-shelf AC adapters are unregulated, as are many of the adapters supplied with other electronic devices—even expensive ones!

The DigiPower Direct AC Adapter

Thanks to digital photographer/engineer dpFWIW contributor Dave Totosian, however, I can now confidently recommend a safe and affordable regulated alternative to the Oly adapters in the $20-30 price range. Dave thoroughly tested the DigiPower Solutions Direct AC digital camera power adapter and found it suitable for his C-2020Z:

Not wanting to jeopardize a $700 camera to a $20 adapter, I used my lab-quality digital volt meter along with my trusty Tektronics 'scope to do some careful analysis before using it with my camera.
Open circuit voltage = 6.73vdc, 120mv ripple @105khz (switcher frequency)
With a 1.0amp resistive load = 6.59vdc, 80mv ripple @105khz
With a 1.5amp resistive load = 6.51vdc, 100mv ripple @105khz
After 20 minutes driving 1.5A, the unit was barely warm to the touch.

Very impressive performance characteristics. They got this one right. All measurements were taken using 110vac/60hz input, but this unit will also work on 240vac/50hz.

In follow-up, Dave notes that he's powered his C-2020Z with this adapter with batteries loaded many times over several months now without incident.

The DigiPower adapter is suitable for the C-30x0Z as well. A good source is Thomas Distributing.
 
I posed the question to Thomas-Distributing about whether the Digipower AC Adaptors being sold are regulated because there have been many past discussions in which many have said it was not regulated and that we could fry our cameras.

Jim, who works at customer service at Thomas-Distributing, wrote back to me saying that the Digipower AC Adaptors are regulated so that as it pulls varying amounts of current the voltage will remain the same.

In addition to this statement from T-D, I also provided related information I found on another site, written by Cliff Shade (see below ... the text may read funny because all I did was a simple cut and paste of the page on his site ... and it's written in the narrative).

It is odd that this fact is not on Digipower's package, and it is odd that I can't seem to find Digipower's web site (everything I found relates to sales and distribiution, not to supporting factual content).

Oh, well ...

I'm keeping the adaptor I bought and I will use it. Hope this helps others.

Paul
There was a thread started some time ago that was revived again (by
me) asking about the possible damage that could be done to a camera
using the DigiPower AC Adapters that is sold on
Thomas-Distributing's web site (that so many seem to use).

That thread (if anyone likes to read "history") is
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1008&message=610854

I have since posed the question to Thomas-Distributing but have not
yet gotten a reply from them.

Today, by coincidence, I stumbled on useful information on Cliff
Shade's site. It appears that the DigiPower Direct AC Adapter is
regulated.

The URL is
http://www.cliffshade.com/dpfwiw/c-2000z/power/index.htm#need

The text is, as follows:

Oly AC Adapters
Oly-brand AC adapters are expensive, but you're paying in part for
the security of a regulated adapter that won't fry your camera,
which cost 15 times more.

The Oly C-6AU Adapter (discontinued)
I own one of these, but I'm no longer sure why. I seldom carry it.
The now discontinued regulated C-6AU outputs 6.5VDC and 2A via a
4.8 mm OD center-positive plug. AC input is listed at 110-120V at
50/60 Hz and rated for 20W.
I originally purchased my C-6AU for my Oly D-340L, but it works
with the C-20x0Z as well. This adapter's fairly large and heavy,
and its plug doesn't fold down for packing.

The Oly C-7AU Universal Adapter
The C-7AU's DC output is 2A, like that of the C-6AU. From pictures,
its wall plug doesn't look foldable. The C-7AU's AC input is dual
voltage (110-120V, 220V). Per Olympus, the C-7AU is designed to
work with its entire current line of digital cameras, so its camera
plug is presumably the same as that of the C-6AU, which the C-7AU
replaced.
Currently, the C-7AU goes for $40-50 mail order. Oly specifies the
C-7AU for its newer C-30x0Z and C-2100UZ cameras as well.

A Viable Alternative to Pricey Oly AC Adapters
Many RPD posts have discussed alternatives to the reliable but
pricey Oly-brand adapters. Most of these posts have been of the
"I've gotten away with it so far" genre.
It's clear enough that 6VDC is adequate to power Oly digicams via
their DC power connectors. How much amperage is required is not so
clear, but the answer lies somewhere in the 800-2000mA range.

Honey, I Fried the Camera
Whether one should trust an expensive digital camera to a cheap
unregulated power supply is another question entirely. Connecting
your Camedia to any old 6V, 1A adapter amounts to a potentially
costly leap of faith, since most inexpensive, off-the-shelf AC
adapters are unregulated, as are many of the adapters supplied with
other electronic devices—even expensive ones!

The DigiPower Direct AC Adapter
Thanks to digital photographer/engineer dpFWIW contributor Dave
Totosian, however, I can now confidently recommend a safe and
affordable regulated alternative to the Oly adapters in the $20-30
price range. Dave thoroughly tested the DigiPower Solutions Direct
AC digital camera power adapter and found it suitable for his
C-2020Z:
Not wanting to jeopardize a $700 camera to a $20 adapter, I used my
lab-quality digital volt meter along with my trusty Tektronics
'scope to do some careful analysis before using it with my camera.
Open circuit voltage = 6.73vdc, 120mv ripple @105khz (switcher
frequency)
With a 1.0amp resistive load = 6.59vdc, 80mv ripple @105khz
With a 1.5amp resistive load = 6.51vdc, 100mv ripple @105khz
After 20 minutes driving 1.5A, the unit was barely warm to the touch.
Very impressive performance characteristics. They got this one
right. All measurements were taken using 110vac/60hz input, but
this unit will also work on 240vac/50hz.
In follow-up, Dave notes that he's powered his C-2020Z with this
adapter with batteries loaded many times over several months now
without incident.
The DigiPower adapter is suitable for the C-30x0Z as well. A good
source is Thomas Distributing.
 
I use the C-7AU supply for both my C2000 and C3030. I think you are carrying this concern to the extreme. You have already put more than $20 worth of analysis time into figuring out what is what! So rather than anti-up, you waste further time justifying your decison; which would have more than paid for the Olympus AC by now. Now you want to live with your decision (but still not be able to sleep nights, wondering if your camera is damaged, and knowing that Olympus will not honor any warranty of damage resulting from use of a 3rd party AC adapter), so further analysis and waste of time continues. Methinks thou protest too much :-))

Sleep tight...Barry
Jim, who works at customer service at Thomas-Distributing, wrote
back to me saying that the Digipower AC Adaptors are regulated so
that as it pulls varying amounts of current the voltage will remain
the same.

In addition to this statement from T-D, I also provided related
information I found on another site, written by Cliff Shade (see
below ... the text may read funny because all I did was a simple
cut and paste of the page on his site ... and it's written in the
narrative).

It is odd that this fact is not on Digipower's package, and it is
odd that I can't seem to find Digipower's web site (everything I
found relates to sales and distribiution, not to supporting factual
content).

Oh, well ...

I'm keeping the adaptor I bought and I will use it. Hope this helps
others.

Paul
There was a thread started some time ago that was revived again (by
me) asking about the possible damage that could be done to a camera
using the DigiPower AC Adapters that is sold on
Thomas-Distributing's web site (that so many seem to use).

That thread (if anyone likes to read "history") is
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1008&message=610854

I have since posed the question to Thomas-Distributing but have not
yet gotten a reply from them.

Today, by coincidence, I stumbled on useful information on Cliff
Shade's site. It appears that the DigiPower Direct AC Adapter is
regulated.

The URL is
http://www.cliffshade.com/dpfwiw/c-2000z/power/index.htm#need

The text is, as follows:

Oly AC Adapters
Oly-brand AC adapters are expensive, but you're paying in part for
the security of a regulated adapter that won't fry your camera,
which cost 15 times more.

The Oly C-6AU Adapter (discontinued)
I own one of these, but I'm no longer sure why. I seldom carry it.
The now discontinued regulated C-6AU outputs 6.5VDC and 2A via a
4.8 mm OD center-positive plug. AC input is listed at 110-120V at
50/60 Hz and rated for 20W.
I originally purchased my C-6AU for my Oly D-340L, but it works
with the C-20x0Z as well. This adapter's fairly large and heavy,
and its plug doesn't fold down for packing.

The Oly C-7AU Universal Adapter
The C-7AU's DC output is 2A, like that of the C-6AU. From pictures,
its wall plug doesn't look foldable. The C-7AU's AC input is dual
voltage (110-120V, 220V). Per Olympus, the C-7AU is designed to
work with its entire current line of digital cameras, so its camera
plug is presumably the same as that of the C-6AU, which the C-7AU
replaced.
Currently, the C-7AU goes for $40-50 mail order. Oly specifies the
C-7AU for its newer C-30x0Z and C-2100UZ cameras as well.

A Viable Alternative to Pricey Oly AC Adapters
Many RPD posts have discussed alternatives to the reliable but
pricey Oly-brand adapters. Most of these posts have been of the
"I've gotten away with it so far" genre.
It's clear enough that 6VDC is adequate to power Oly digicams via
their DC power connectors. How much amperage is required is not so
clear, but the answer lies somewhere in the 800-2000mA range.

Honey, I Fried the Camera
Whether one should trust an expensive digital camera to a cheap
unregulated power supply is another question entirely. Connecting
your Camedia to any old 6V, 1A adapter amounts to a potentially
costly leap of faith, since most inexpensive, off-the-shelf AC
adapters are unregulated, as are many of the adapters supplied with
other electronic devices—even expensive ones!

The DigiPower Direct AC Adapter
Thanks to digital photographer/engineer dpFWIW contributor Dave
Totosian, however, I can now confidently recommend a safe and
affordable regulated alternative to the Oly adapters in the $20-30
price range. Dave thoroughly tested the DigiPower Solutions Direct
AC digital camera power adapter and found it suitable for his
C-2020Z:
Not wanting to jeopardize a $700 camera to a $20 adapter, I used my
lab-quality digital volt meter along with my trusty Tektronics
'scope to do some careful analysis before using it with my camera.
Open circuit voltage = 6.73vdc, 120mv ripple @105khz (switcher
frequency)
With a 1.0amp resistive load = 6.59vdc, 80mv ripple @105khz
With a 1.5amp resistive load = 6.51vdc, 100mv ripple @105khz
After 20 minutes driving 1.5A, the unit was barely warm to the touch.
Very impressive performance characteristics. They got this one
right. All measurements were taken using 110vac/60hz input, but
this unit will also work on 240vac/50hz.
In follow-up, Dave notes that he's powered his C-2020Z with this
adapter with batteries loaded many times over several months now
without incident.
The DigiPower adapter is suitable for the C-30x0Z as well. A good
source is Thomas Distributing.
 
I had bought the thing ... it showed up ... then I stumbled on the posts and decided to get the question answered. So, I wrote some e mails and looked at Cliff's site.

The time sink would have been either the work to return it ... continuing to talk about it and goig no where with it ... or buying another (yours) and junking this one.

I use these boards and learn a lot from them. No reason not to give back the information since I now corrected incorrect information posted and used by other people. And, why spend so much more for something as simple as this?

I do appreciate your concern ... but no need to worry about me ... I'm doing just fine. It does feel good to be able to contribute something here, no matter how small it is.

Paul
Sleep tight...Barry
Jim, who works at customer service at Thomas-Distributing, wrote
back to me saying that the Digipower AC Adaptors are regulated so
that as it pulls varying amounts of current the voltage will remain
the same.

In addition to this statement from T-D, I also provided related
information I found on another site, written by Cliff Shade (see
below ... the text may read funny because all I did was a simple
cut and paste of the page on his site ... and it's written in the
narrative).

It is odd that this fact is not on Digipower's package, and it is
odd that I can't seem to find Digipower's web site (everything I
found relates to sales and distribiution, not to supporting factual
content).

Oh, well ...

I'm keeping the adaptor I bought and I will use it. Hope this helps
others.

Paul
There was a thread started some time ago that was revived again (by
me) asking about the possible damage that could be done to a camera
using the DigiPower AC Adapters that is sold on
Thomas-Distributing's web site (that so many seem to use).

That thread (if anyone likes to read "history") is
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1008&message=610854

I have since posed the question to Thomas-Distributing but have not
yet gotten a reply from them.

Today, by coincidence, I stumbled on useful information on Cliff
Shade's site. It appears that the DigiPower Direct AC Adapter is
regulated.

The URL is
http://www.cliffshade.com/dpfwiw/c-2000z/power/index.htm#need

The text is, as follows:

Oly AC Adapters
Oly-brand AC adapters are expensive, but you're paying in part for
the security of a regulated adapter that won't fry your camera,
which cost 15 times more.

The Oly C-6AU Adapter (discontinued)
I own one of these, but I'm no longer sure why. I seldom carry it.
The now discontinued regulated C-6AU outputs 6.5VDC and 2A via a
4.8 mm OD center-positive plug. AC input is listed at 110-120V at
50/60 Hz and rated for 20W.
I originally purchased my C-6AU for my Oly D-340L, but it works
with the C-20x0Z as well. This adapter's fairly large and heavy,
and its plug doesn't fold down for packing.

The Oly C-7AU Universal Adapter
The C-7AU's DC output is 2A, like that of the C-6AU. From pictures,
its wall plug doesn't look foldable. The C-7AU's AC input is dual
voltage (110-120V, 220V). Per Olympus, the C-7AU is designed to
work with its entire current line of digital cameras, so its camera
plug is presumably the same as that of the C-6AU, which the C-7AU
replaced.
Currently, the C-7AU goes for $40-50 mail order. Oly specifies the
C-7AU for its newer C-30x0Z and C-2100UZ cameras as well.

A Viable Alternative to Pricey Oly AC Adapters
Many RPD posts have discussed alternatives to the reliable but
pricey Oly-brand adapters. Most of these posts have been of the
"I've gotten away with it so far" genre.
It's clear enough that 6VDC is adequate to power Oly digicams via
their DC power connectors. How much amperage is required is not so
clear, but the answer lies somewhere in the 800-2000mA range.

Honey, I Fried the Camera
Whether one should trust an expensive digital camera to a cheap
unregulated power supply is another question entirely. Connecting
your Camedia to any old 6V, 1A adapter amounts to a potentially
costly leap of faith, since most inexpensive, off-the-shelf AC
adapters are unregulated, as are many of the adapters supplied with
other electronic devices—even expensive ones!

The DigiPower Direct AC Adapter
Thanks to digital photographer/engineer dpFWIW contributor Dave
Totosian, however, I can now confidently recommend a safe and
affordable regulated alternative to the Oly adapters in the $20-30
price range. Dave thoroughly tested the DigiPower Solutions Direct
AC digital camera power adapter and found it suitable for his
C-2020Z:
Not wanting to jeopardize a $700 camera to a $20 adapter, I used my
lab-quality digital volt meter along with my trusty Tektronics
'scope to do some careful analysis before using it with my camera.
Open circuit voltage = 6.73vdc, 120mv ripple @105khz (switcher
frequency)
With a 1.0amp resistive load = 6.59vdc, 80mv ripple @105khz
With a 1.5amp resistive load = 6.51vdc, 100mv ripple @105khz
After 20 minutes driving 1.5A, the unit was barely warm to the touch.
Very impressive performance characteristics. They got this one
right. All measurements were taken using 110vac/60hz input, but
this unit will also work on 240vac/50hz.
In follow-up, Dave notes that he's powered his C-2020Z with this
adapter with batteries loaded many times over several months now
without incident.
The DigiPower adapter is suitable for the C-30x0Z as well. A good
source is Thomas Distributing.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top