15-45mm or 22mm For Landscape Photography

Kris Chua

New member
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Due to my phone destroyed by water, I decided to purchase my first camera, EOS M100 with it's default lens 15-45mm. I also include 22mm in the purchase. I am very interested to try CPL, FLD and ND8 filter to enhance the color of my photograph but still confused to decide whether to get the 49mm or 43mm set.

Just like what the majority said, the 15-45mm is quite disappointing with all the soft edges but does it make 22mm better for landscape photograph?

Any help will be appreciated.
 
Solution
Due to my phone destroyed by water, I decided to purchase my first camera, EOS M100 with it's default lens 15-45mm. I also include 22mm in the purchase. I am very interested to try CPL, FLD and ND8 filter to enhance the color of my photograph but still confused to decide whether to get the 49mm or 43mm set.
Just like what the majority said, the 15-45mm is quite disappointing with all the soft edges but does it make 22mm better for landscape photograph?
Any help will be appreciated.
Don't buy any filters until you have a problem that requires a filter.

You certainly don't need an FLD filter that was used in the days of film for shooting in fluorescent light. On a digital camera you handle that by changing the white balance...
Due to my phone destroyed by water, I decided to purchase my first camera, EOS M100 with it's default lens 15-45mm. I also include 22mm in the purchase. I am very interested to try CPL, FLD and ND8 filter to enhance the color of my photograph but still confused to decide whether to get the 49mm or 43mm set.
Just like what the majority said, the 15-45mm is quite disappointing with all the soft edges but does it make 22mm better for landscape photograph?
Any help will be appreciated.
Don't buy any filters until you have a problem that requires a filter.

You certainly don't need an FLD filter that was used in the days of film for shooting in fluorescent light. On a digital camera you handle that by changing the white balance. CPL filters remove light polarised in a particular direction and are primarily used for reducing reflections although they are sometimes used for darkening skies. ND filters reduce the amount of light entering the lens and allow a longer shutter speed to be used. These filters come in different optical densities for different uses. An ND08 3stop filter would be useful for portrait photography with fill flash on very bright days.

If you are interested in landscape photography then a tripod would be a better investment than filters.

I don't know a lot about EOS-M lenses but I imagine that a 22mm prime lens would have significantly better image quality than a zoom.
 
Solution
Due to my phone destroyed by water, I decided to purchase my first camera, EOS M100 with it's default lens 15-45mm. I also include 22mm in the purchase.
Congrats! This combo will definitely extend your photo possibilities. :-)
Just like what the majority said, the 15-45mm is quite disappointing with all the soft edges
The 15-45 has soft corners at the widest angle and largest aperture (spherical aberration). There is also some moustache (geometric) distortion at these settings. Enable Canon's excellent DLO (Digital Lens Optimization) for this lens to help correct.

If you're noticing soft edges, then you should do the "brick wall" test to check if your lens is decentered (one side will be blurrier than the other). If it's noticeable, then you might want to exchange the lens. My 15-45 is slightly decentered, but doesn't impact my images enough to bother me...

Another photog shooting riders. 15mm wide open. Click on "original size"

Another photog shooting riders. 15mm wide open. Click on "original size"

Sample from the shoot...

The 15-45 exhibited excellent AF. Click on "original size"

The 15-45 exhibited excellent AF. Click on "original size"
but does it make 22mm better for landscape photograph?
If you like the 22mm focal length (35mm equiv), then by all means shoot away!

However the most popular landscape lens is the 11-22. Head over to the Canon M-Series Forum to check samples from each of these lenses.
I am very interested to try CPL, FLD and ND8 filter to enhance the color of my photograph but still confused to decide whether to get the 49mm or 43mm set.
Purchase filters that fit your largest (dia) lens, then use step-up rings for the other lenses. I'd buy the best you can afford (but like Chris R says skip the FLD).

Happy Shooting!

R2

--
Good judgment comes from experience.
Experience comes from bad judgment.
http://www.pbase.com/jekyll_and_hyde/galleries
 
Last edited:
Due to my phone destroyed by water, I decided to purchase my first camera, EOS M100 with it's default lens 15-45mm. I also include 22mm in the purchase. I am very interested to try CPL, FLD and ND8 filter to enhance the color of my photograph but still confused to decide whether to get the 49mm or 43mm set.
Just like what the majority said, the 15-45mm is quite disappointing with all the soft edges but does it make 22mm better for landscape photograph?
Any help will be appreciated.
Don't buy any filters until you have a problem that requires a filter.

You certainly don't need an FLD filter that was used in the days of film for shooting in fluorescent light. On a digital camera you handle that by changing the white balance. CPL filters remove light polarised in a particular direction and are primarily used for reducing reflections although they are sometimes used for darkening skies. ND filters reduce the amount of light entering the lens and allow a longer shutter speed to be used. These filters come in different optical densities for different uses. An ND08 3stop filter would be useful for portrait photography with fill flash on very bright days.

If you are interested in landscape photography then a tripod would be a better investment than filters.

I don't know a lot about EOS-M lenses but I imagine that a 22mm prime lens would have significantly better image quality than a zoom.
+ 1

For some exotic situations a filter is a must, but for most landscapes you are better off with no filter at all. Mastering post processing with a RAW developer will improve your landscape colors far more than any filter.

Kelly Cook
 
Don't trash the EF-M 15-45 kit lens yet. I know some are having trouble with decentering. However, I have a good copy that I am enjoying. The prime lenses are supposed to be sharper, but limit your 'in camera' cropping. Ask some people that have the EF-M 15-45 lens before you make your choice definite. I don't have a prime therefore I can't make a quality test. I do know that I rather not have to change lenses every time a different scene is to be photographed. You also open your camera to dust every time you change lenses. But, it was made for making changes.
Dan



676aa74a5bca4c20a203e8887f1c8ec1.jpg

Canon M50 with EF-M 15-45 lens.

--
Christian Amateur Photographer
Choose life's involvements carefully with an eye toward eternity.
 
Last edited:

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top