Reactions, Late on a Saturday Night

Chato

Veteran Member
Messages
47,071
Reaction score
7,958
Location
NYC
Late at night at an outdoor bar, she suddenly noticed me shooting
Late at night at an outdoor bar, she suddenly noticed me shooting

A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night

Young Ladies reaction to being photographed... Priceless... :-)
Young Ladies reaction to being photographed... Priceless... :-)

Another person reacts to being photographed
Another person reacts to being photographed

Two women react to being photographd
Two women react to being photographd
 
Last edited:
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night

Magnificent the way you photographed six separate interactions, with no one in the picture noticing you. I can appreciate how difficult it is to take this sort of image; one needs a fast camera technique in order not to be caught.

Do you find your short hairs standing on end when you take a picture like this? (I know I do.)

Well done!

--
 
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night

Magnificent the way you photographed six separate interactions, with no one in the picture noticing you. I can appreciate how difficult it is to take this sort of image; one needs a fast camera technique in order not to be caught.

Do you find your short hairs standing on end when you take a picture like this? (I know I do.)

Well done!
Much thanks.

I never try to hide my shooting, but I also don't "advertise it... :-)

What I find strange about my own attitude is that when in shooting mode I see the world in terms of a picture frame.
 
Being yourself, and understanding that you have every right to photograph others in public, is Joel Meyerowitz's formula for being invisible on the street. I figured from your photographs that you at least acknowledge intuitively his wisdom in that regard.
 
Being yourself, and understanding that you have every right to photograph others in public, is Joel Meyerowitz's formula for being invisible on the street. I figured from your photographs that you at least acknowledge intuitively his wisdom in that regard.
My two rules, are

1. Never hide that your photographing people

2. Never physically interfere in some ones activities. I am simply capturing with a camera what is also being captured by my eyes.
 
Being yourself, and understanding that you have every right to photograph others in public, is Joel Meyerowitz's formula for being invisible on the street. I figured from your photographs that you at least acknowledge intuitively his wisdom in that regard.
While one has the right to photograph in public in the US, I regularly delete the photos where the subjects realize they are being photographed without their permission and react by clearly showing their suspiciousness. annoyance, disdain, and outright anger at the street photographer. IMO, it changes the tenor of the photo into being a confrontation, rather than being a candid or a convivial exchange. These photos make me uncomfortable and emphasize the potential danger, although slight, that a street photographer risks. In the big city, my experience is that one must be careful, quick, and when necessary diplomatic.

FYI, I live and photograph in the same neighborhood as Chato.


Steve Schulman
Steve Schulman Photography
 
Being yourself, and understanding that you have every right to photograph others in public, is Joel Meyerowitz's formula for being invisible on the street. I figured from your photographs that you at least acknowledge intuitively his wisdom in that regard.
While one has the right to photograph in public in the US, I regularly delete the photos where the subjects realize they are being photographed without their permission and react by clearly showing their suspiciousness. annoyance, disdain, and outright anger at the street photographer. IMO, it changes the tenor of the photo into being a confrontation, rather than being a candid or a convivial exchange. These photos make me uncomfortable and emphasize the potential danger, although slight, that a street photographer risks. In the big city, my experience is that one must be careful, quick, and when necessary diplomatic.

FYI, I live and photograph in the same neighborhood as Chato.

Steve Schulman
Steve Schulman Photography
While I never delete photo's, if someone sees me shooting them, and (With some exceptions) their body language tells me that don't want to be photographed, I'll stop shooting them. The exceptions are Cops, Security Guards, people in, or making movies.
 
Late at night at an outdoor bar, she suddenly noticed me shooting
Late at night at an outdoor bar, she suddenly noticed me shooting

A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night

Young Ladies reaction to being photographed... Priceless... :-)
Young Ladies reaction to being photographed... Priceless... :-)

Another person reacts to being photographed
Another person reacts to being photographed

Two women react to being photographd
Two women react to being photographd
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.

--
Sam K., NYC
“I’m halfway between tightrope walker and pickpocket.” — HCB

Native New Yorker:
http://www.blurb.com/b/7943076
__
Street Gallery:
http://skanter.smugmug.com/NYC-Street-Photography
__
Recent Photos:
https://skanter.smugmug.com/Recent-Photos
 
Last edited:
I've thought about brandishing a rifle, but this is frowned on. :-(

On the other hand, I enjoy the reactions I get.
 
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.
I know your comments applied to all of Chato's posted photos but on this image, your words are untrue. Chato has made an image that contains very good composition, offers the viewer a narrative and emotional response, and has a decent dollop of drama. With some license, there is even an element of mystery.

These are factors I look for in a good street photo. How many of those considerations are present and how strongly they present themselves, go to how the image elevates itself in the viewer's aesthetic judgement.

--
 
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.
I know your comments applied to all of Chato's posted photos but on this image, your words are untrue. Chato has made an image that contains very good composition, offers the viewer a narrative and emotional response, and has a decent dollop of drama. With some license, there is even an element of mystery.

These are factors I look for in a good street photo. How many of those considerations are present and how strongly they present themselves, go to how the image elevates itself in the viewer's aesthetic judgement.
Perhaps you are right Jeff, but on the other hand, Chato has said that he enjoys seeing people's reactions to his camera. This lady may have anticipated the coming shot and quickly averted her head to avoid him. I've seen this happen many times so perhaps I am overly sensitive to this possibility. I do like all the reflections surrounding the couple, and perhaps my thoughts are irrelevant if other people see this from a different perspective. If my photo, I would have color corrected the casts, but that is of course to taste.

Steve

--
Steve Schulman
Steve Schulman Photography
 
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.
I know your comments applied to all of Chato's posted photos but on this image, your words are untrue. Chato has made an image that contains very good composition, offers the viewer a narrative and emotional response, and has a decent dollop of drama. With some license, there is even an element of mystery.

These are factors I look for in a good street photo. How many of those considerations are present and how strongly they present themselves, go to how the image elevates itself in the viewer's aesthetic judgement.
This might have been decent had he done some PP work on it so tht we could see the female subject’s face, worked with some highlights and shadows levels and corrected the red color cast. I’m not sure it could have been salvaged. When the best of a series is mediocre, that’s not saying much.

It seems the OP’s intent was not achieving compelling photos, but in enjoying a “reaction”. This in itself is not to be encouraged as you have done, and has not resulted in anything worth looking at.

--
Sam K., NYC
“I’m halfway between tightrope walker and pickpocket.” — HCB

Native New Yorker:
http://www.blurb.com/b/7943076
__
Street Gallery:
http://skanter.smugmug.com/NYC-Street-Photography
__
Recent Photos:
https://skanter.smugmug.com/Recent-Photos
 
Last edited:
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.
I know your comments applied to all of Chato's posted photos but on this image, your words are untrue. Chato has made an image that contains very good composition, offers the viewer a narrative and emotional response, and has a decent dollop of drama. With some license, there is even an element of mystery.

These are factors I look for in a good street photo. How many of those considerations are present and how strongly they present themselves, go to how the image elevates itself in the viewer's aesthetic judgement.
This might have been decent had he done some PP work on it so tht we could see the female subject’s face, worked with some highlights and shadows levels and corrected the red color cast.
The red color cast is the way the scene actually looked. These are "bars" and these are garish scenes.
I’m not sure it could have been salvaged. When the best of a series is mediocre, that’s not saying much.

It seems the OP’s intent was not achieving compelling photos, but in enjoying a “reaction”. This in itself is not to be encouraged as you have done, and has not resulted in anything worth looking at.
Sorry, you didn't like them. I often shoot other kinds of Street Scenes. But my "intent" in a Saturday night is to show the scene as it actually looked.
 
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.
I know your comments applied to all of Chato's posted photos but on this image, your words are untrue. Chato has made an image that contains very good composition, offers the viewer a narrative and emotional response, and has a decent dollop of drama. With some license, there is even an element of mystery.

These are factors I look for in a good street photo. How many of those considerations are present and how strongly they present themselves, go to how the image elevates itself in the viewer's aesthetic judgement.
This might have been decent had he done some PP work on it so tht we could see the female subject’s face, worked with some highlights and shadows levels and corrected the red color cast.
The red color cast is the way the scene actually looked. These are "bars" and these are garish scenes.
I’m not sure it could have been salvaged. When the best of a series is mediocre, that’s not saying much.

It seems the OP’s intent was not achieving compelling photos, but in enjoying a “reaction”. This in itself is not to be encouraged as you have done, and has not resulted in anything worth looking at.
Sorry, you didn't like them. I often shoot other kinds of Street Scenes. But my "intent" in a Saturday night is to show the scene as it actually looked.
The red cast is the least of it. You need to learn about post-processing, and, more important, what street photography is about.

--
Sam K., NYC
“I’m halfway between tightrope walker and pickpocket.” — HCB

Native New Yorker:
http://www.blurb.com/b/7943076
__
Street Gallery:
http://skanter.smugmug.com/NYC-Street-Photography
__
Recent Photos:
https://skanter.smugmug.com/Recent-Photos
 
Last edited:
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.
I know your comments applied to all of Chato's posted photos but on this image, your words are untrue. Chato has made an image that contains very good composition, offers the viewer a narrative and emotional response, and has a decent dollop of drama. With some license, there is even an element of mystery.

These are factors I look for in a good street photo. How many of those considerations are present and how strongly they present themselves, go to how the image elevates itself in the viewer's aesthetic judgement.
This might have been decent had he done some PP work on it so tht we could see the female subject’s face, worked with some highlights and shadows levels and corrected the red color cast.
The red color cast is the way the scene actually looked. These are "bars" and these are garish scenes.
I’m not sure it could have been salvaged. When the best of a series is mediocre, that’s not saying much.

It seems the OP’s intent was not achieving compelling photos, but in enjoying a “reaction”. This in itself is not to be encouraged as you have done, and has not resulted in anything worth looking at.
Sorry, you didn't like them. I often shoot other kinds of Street Scenes. But my "intent" in a Saturday night is to show the scene as it actually looked.
The red cast is the least of it. You need to learn about post-processing, and, more important, what street photography is about.
I am amazed at people having the gall to tell me what Street Photography is all about. :-)

I like most your posts, but here you are describing "your Images" as Street, and mine are not.

Post processing? You really mean distorting the scene to match the normal eyes view."

In this case, This IS what the eye actually sees.
 
Last edited:
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
A couple at the Wine Bar late on a Saturday Night
Well, you’ve gotten some “reactions”, but, frankly, you have not achieved very interesting photos.

I see no sense of composition, light, gesture, or emotion. Anyone pointing a camera at anyone will get a “reaction” - hopefully we try for more.
I know your comments applied to all of Chato's posted photos but on this image, your words are untrue. Chato has made an image that contains very good composition, offers the viewer a narrative and emotional response, and has a decent dollop of drama. With some license, there is even an element of mystery.

These are factors I look for in a good street photo. How many of those considerations are present and how strongly they present themselves, go to how the image elevates itself in the viewer's aesthetic judgement.
This might have been decent had he done some PP work on it so tht we could see the female subject’s face, worked with some highlights and shadows levels and corrected the red color cast.
The red color cast is the way the scene actually looked. These are "bars" and these are garish scenes.
I’m not sure it could have been salvaged. When the best of a series is mediocre, that’s not saying much.

It seems the OP’s intent was not achieving compelling photos, but in enjoying a “reaction”. This in itself is not to be encouraged as you have done, and has not resulted in anything worth looking at.
Sorry, you didn't like them. I often shoot other kinds of Street Scenes. But my "intent" in a Saturday night is to show the scene as it actually looked.
The red cast is the least of it. You need to learn about post-processing, and, more important, what street photography is about.
I am amazed at people having the gall to tell me what Street Photography is all about. :-)
I didn’t tell you what it is about, but that you have to learn what it is about. I wouldnt begin to try. You will have to figure it out.
I like most your posts, but here you are describing "your Images" as Street, and mine are not.
Never said that. But I will say that it is not just “photos taken out on the street”.
Post processing? You really mean distorting the scene to match the normal eyes view."

No, it’s the opposite. You PP to achieve what the eye saw, what the camera could not.


In this case, This IS what the eye actually sees.
Your eyes, unfortunately, are not seeing much at this point.

--
Sam K., NYC
“I’m halfway between tightrope walker and pickpocket.” — HCB

Native New Yorker:
http://www.blurb.com/b/7943076
__
Street Gallery:
http://skanter.smugmug.com/NYC-Street-Photography
__
Recent Photos:
https://skanter.smugmug.com/Recent-Photos
 
Last edited:
Your eyes, unfortunately, are not seeing much at this point.
Your ignorance is appalling. But I am always ready to help. The Human brain, much like a camera which always tries to make every scene look like day, tries to eliminate the garish colors of night time.

Now Go out, with an open mind on one of these bar filled streets, and SEE the actual colors. The unconscious brain can be taught the truth.
 
Last edited:
If my photo, I would have color corrected the casts, but that is of course to taste.
Next time you are out at night alongside garish bars, "consciously" look at the colors of the light. The brain automatically does it's best to "correct" colors, but that doesn't mean that the correction is accurate.

While irrelevant to this thread, here's another visual experiment. People know that a camera has depth of field and objects too close or too far are blurred. But most people are not aware that the human eye functions in the same manner.

So go out to about eight feet from a lamp post, focus on the post, and then "notice" the background... :-)

The brain is a wonderful gadget for navigating the world... :-)
 
Last edited:
Your eyes, unfortunately, are not seeing much at this point.
Your ignorance is appalling. But I am always ready to help. The Human brain, much like a camera which always tries to make every scene look like day, tries to eliminate the garish colors of night time.

Now Go out, with an open mind on one of these bar filled streets, and SEE the actual colors. The unconscious brain can be taught the truth.
So you trust more what your camera sees than your eyes/brain?

The results are apparent in your photos, genius. :-)
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top