Sunk cost.So the D5, D4s and D4 were free then?
Jim
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Sunk cost.So the D5, D4s and D4 were free then?
A question , do the generic grips have a Fn button near the shutter button ?
No. 5 grips - but they are for sale on Kijiji - and I'll keep two that give 9 fps for my two D850s.
And I only bought the real Nikon grip because I was tired of waiting for the others to arrive.
One grip arrive the day after I bought my Nikon grip - and another arrived a day after that. Some of the generics took a LONG time to ship from China. One arrived 2 weeks after the LONGEST estimate of how long it would take.
And when I ordered the grips - my local camera guy couldn't tell me how long it would take for the Nikon grip to be in stock.
AND - I wanted to know which generics provide 9 fps. Now I know. And I've got one that has a built in remote control. That's a feature I was hoping to have anyways.
And I don't mind the investment of $. Using the D850 without a grip was NOT all that pleasant - especially after you get used to a D5 or D4 or D2x - and if you have grips on all your other cameras.
But if you tried putting a 200-400 f4 or 300mm 2.8 or 200mm f2 on the D850 without a grip - and tried hand holding them - you would understand.
Oh - and by the way - you can buy 4 generic grips for less than the price of one overpriced Nikon grip - and the generics have the added advantage of being lighter - which is nice when you are handholding.
Ditto and the BL-5 is the same as the one for the D810. Personally If I was going generic I would probably risk a well reviewed charger given the saving, but go original for battery. Generally the batteries are reported to not last as long. I did the calculations and if one goes bang its the equivalent to 200 max strength firecrackers. I have been on trips where batteries are checked and they need to be stored and charged in "Battery bags" so it is a risk.For completeness, I'll point out that if, like me, you already have a D5, D4, or D4s, the only things you need are the grip and the cap, so the entry bar is a bit lower.***GRIPS***
Nikon grip - 9 fps -
DTSE grip - 9 fps
Vello grip -9 fps
MCoplus - 9 fps (and includes a remote control)
Travor grip - 7 fps
Pixel grip - 7 fps
***Batteries***
Still working on this one, with less data
Nikon EL-18a or EL-18b - 9 fps
AA batteries - 7 fps
Watson el-18 equivalent - 9fps - $70
Wasabi - $46 - probably 9 fps (unknown)
Others... perhaps it is accurate to say that the batteries with built-in endplates typically do NOT give 9 fps, while the batteries that require the BL-5 endcap do give the added speed. Probably would help to put together a list of model numbers for the batteries that work.
***Battery Chamber Cover ***
Nikon BL-5 - $25-30
generic Chinese BL-5 - $6
I have both, but the Chinese one took so long to get here that I ended up with the Nikon one when I found it in stock with the grip. I have not used the knockoff, but it looks fine, Just pointing out that these are available.
***Chargers***
Nikon dual-bay charger - $370
all the rest below, much cheaper
Wasabi dual-bay charger -works fine - $60
DTSE dual-bay charger - unknown, but looks like the exact unit as the Wasabi - about $60
RAVPower dual-bay charger - unknown, but looks like the exact unit at the Wasabi - $50
Myself, I have the Nikon grip, the Watson battery and the Wasabi charger. I meant to buy the Wasabi battery when I bought the charge, but clicked on the wrong link. No problem, the Watson battery works fine, gives 9 fps, fits well in the grip and charger, shows a charge indication in-camera.
There is certainly no problem getting a grip, battery and charger for WAY cheaper than Nikon and still achieve all functions. Plus a remote release in the case of MCoplus (clever).
I've used non-Nikon batteries since the D800e. I was upset that Nikon couldn't have provided some way to use my expensive D700 big battery charger and Nikon batteries in the D800 series. I bought the NIkon grips for D800e and D810, but I bought $70 batteries with the built-in endplates and included charges. Still working fine now, but these batteries don't give the in-camera charge level indication. (I'm thinking you may not be able to do a firmware update with one of these batteries as the camera doesn't know how much charge is in the battery).
Perhaps those with 3rd-party gear could edit this list to add prices, frame rate and an indication of whether there is any problem or not.
Jim
--
http://blog.kasson.com
Some really interesting info in this thread so thanks to all who have contributed.
Hardest thing to find (at least in the UK) seems to be the 3rd party battery chargers.
You must suck at search engines...Thanks for the detailed review. Any opinion on which generic charger for the En EL 18b is best...I don't see many options on Amazon, and none on B&H. many thanks
Try putting this in a Google search: "generic MH-26". LOTS of hits come up for me, First one is from Amazon. Second one, Amazon.
This one is Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/Replacement-Channel-Battery-EN-EL18a-Batteries/dp/B00LLI9HTK
Ebay:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/MH-26A-3in...ikon-EN-EL4-EN-EL18-Canon-LP-E4-/142306617785
This is the one I bought, from Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/Wasabi-Power-Battery-MH-26aAK-EN-EL18a/dp/B0131NS2XO
This last one seems to be something made in China and sold under many brand names. All around $60-75.
Thanks, not used eBay for years (few bad experiences) but maybe I'll take a punt. Normally prefer to use Amazon if poss as returns are easy but nothing on there at present.
Some really interesting info in this thread so thanks to all who have contributed.
Hardest thing to find (at least in the UK) seems to be the 3rd party battery chargers.
Thanks. This is very good to know!I can confirm that with the 1.01 firmware upgrade you can get 9fps with third party battery and third party grip. I have the DSTE battery grip and a Power2000 brand en-el18 and I get 9fps. FYI.
***GRIPS***
Nikon grip - 9 fps -
DTSE grip - 9 fps
Vello grip -9 fps
MCoplus - 9 fps (and includes a remote control)
Travor grip - 7 fps
Pixel grip - 7 fps
***Batteries***
Still working on this one, with less data
Nikon EL-18a or EL-18b - 9 fps
AA batteries - 7 fps
Watson el-18 equivalent - 9fps - $70
Wasabi - $46 - probably 9 fps (unknown)
Others... perhaps it is accurate to say that the batteries with built-in endplates typically do NOT give 9 fps, while the batteries that require the BL-5 endcap do give the added speed. Probably would help to put together a list of model numbers for the batteries that work.
***Battery Chamber Cover ***
Nikon BL-5 - $25-30
generic Chinese BL-5 - $6
I have both, but the Chinese one took so long to get here that I ended up with the Nikon one when I found it in stock with the grip. I have not used the knockoff, but it looks fine, Just pointing out that these are available.
***Chargers***
Nikon dual-bay charger - $370
all the rest below, much cheaper
Wasabi dual-bay charger -works fine - $60
DTSE dual-bay charger - unknown, but looks like the exact unit as the Wasabi - about $60
RAVPower dual-bay charger - unknown, but looks like the exact unit at the Wasabi - $50
Myself, I have the Nikon grip, the Watson battery and the Wasabi charger. I meant to buy the Wasabi battery when I bought the charge, but clicked on the wrong link. No problem, the Watson battery works fine, gives 9 fps, fits well in the grip and charger, shows a charge indication in-camera.
There is certainly no problem getting a grip, battery and charger for WAY cheaper than Nikon and still achieve all functions. Plus a remote release in the case of MCoplus (clever).
I've used non-Nikon batteries since the D800e. I was upset that Nikon couldn't have provided some way to use my expensive D700 big battery charger and Nikon batteries in the D800 series. I bought the NIkon grips for D800e and D810, but I bought $70 batteries with the built-in endplates and included charges. Still working fine now, but these batteries don't give the in-camera charge level indication. (I'm thinking you may not be able to do a firmware update with one of these batteries as the camera doesn't know how much charge is in the battery).
Perhaps those with 3rd-party gear could edit this list to add prices, frame rate and an indication of whether there is any problem or not.