Color Calibrated Photo Software

olsenn

Forum Enthusiast
Messages
383
Solutions
2
Reaction score
98
I own a calibrated, wide-color gamut monitor (BenQ SW2700PT) which displays the full AdobeRGB color spectrum. However, I have tried numerous photo viewing applications, and all seem to render the colors differently in my images; even ones that say they make use of the monitor's color profile.

The default Windows 10 Photos application doesn't appear to be color corrected at all. Photoshop, FastStone Image Viewer, Fast Image Viewer, and the older Windows photo viewer all seem to render the images closer to reality. However, they all are slightly different! Can somebody please tell me why this is so?

I am looking for a quick, lightweight, and preferably free photo viewer which renders the photos in the exact same way Photoshop does. Any suggestions
 
I own a calibrated, wide-color gamut monitor (BenQ SW2700PT) which displays the full AdobeRGB color spectrum. However, I have tried numerous photo viewing applications, and all seem to render the colors differently in my images; even ones that say they make use of the monitor's color profile.

The default Windows 10 Photos application doesn't appear to be color corrected at all. Photoshop, FastStone Image Viewer, Fast Image Viewer, and the older Windows photo viewer all seem to render the images closer to reality. However, they all are slightly different! Can somebody please tell me why this is so?

I am looking for a quick, lightweight, and preferably free photo viewer which renders the photos in the exact same way Photoshop does. Any suggestions
I would read over your monitor manual & as well, check the monitor's software settings. Next, you need to explain more about your images & color management. It is not enough to say that your monitor is AdobeRGB capable & that is it. As well, you haven't said if you have chosen the factory default *.icm profile(s), which is NOT Adobe RGB, as your Windows SYSTEM profile. The other software, if they are color managed, will work of the Windows System profile. Normally, one does this via Color Calibration Hardware & Software, which creates a *.icm monitor profile that one can custom name & the software places it in the System folder for the OS & applications to use. Monitor profiles are DIFFERENT & not interchangeable with image profiles. Sorry if you know that.

Having said that, it doesn't sound like you know much about color management & so you are not clear on how to use AdobeRGB, or sRGB. Why not do a Google Search or a search of these forums for Color Management or monitor calibration tutorials. As well, you could search YouTube. All the info is here already, you just need to look for it. Also search for threads & links to "Digidog" or Andrew Rodney, as he has some great info on his website.

Just having a factory calibrated monitor & turning it on isn't going to solve all your problems. Most of the time you are going to be using the monitor in sRGB mode & NOT AdobeRGB. You will use the latter mode ONLY for image editing in Photoshop or Lightroom after that, you'll most of the time output the edited image to sRGB for browser or web viewing or printing. My point is, that it's a big topic & you are just starting your learning curve.

So, read the monitor manual & look for other documents & tutorials from the manufacturer, look for tutorials online by using Google Search & also check out this forum & YouTube. Also, do some research on color calibration hardware & software, which you should buy & learn how to use. It will solve some problems for you & keep your monitor profiles current, as monitors do age & degrade over time, so your factory calibration is time limited, sort of like breaking in a new pair of shoes, which will change over time from new.

Search first, ask questions later.
 
Last edited:
I am looking for a quick, lightweight, and preferably free photo viewer which renders the photos in the exact same way Photoshop does. Any suggestions
See this post. Free and lightweight: Windows Photo Viewer, IrfanView, XnViewMP, Picasa. Very fast and not too expensive: FastPictureViewer. They won't be 100% the same as Ps because the latter uses the proprietary ACE rendering, whereas the free ones frequently rely on LittleCMS, but the differences will be subtle/negligible.

--
Marcin
 
Last edited:
What you need is color managed software. This means the software reads the color space saved in the image - sRGB, Adobe RGB, Pro Photo RGB, etc. and send the correct color information to the monitor for display. You also need to calibrate your monitor using monitor calibration equipment so the monitor will display correct colors.

A lot of software is not color managed and assumes all images are in sRGB color space. If you are using non color managed software and view an image that is something other than sRGB color space the colors will not be correct.
 
What you need is color managed software. This means the software reads the color space saved in the image - sRGB, Adobe RGB, Pro Photo RGB, etc. and send the correct color information to the monitor for display. You also need to calibrate your monitor using monitor calibration equipment so the monitor will display correct colors.

A lot of software is not color managed and assumes all images are in sRGB color space.
If only! Software that isn't colour managed doesn't make any assumption about the colour space. It sends the pixel data unaltered to the monitor. Unless the monitor just happens to have an identical colour space to the image (which is not likely) then the colours will be wrong on the screen.
If you are using non color managed software and view an image that is something other than sRGB color space the colors will not be correct.
 
I own a calibrated, wide-color gamut monitor (BenQ SW2700PT) which displays the full AdobeRGB color spectrum. However, I have tried numerous photo viewing applications, and all seem to render the colors differently in my images; even ones that say they make use of the monitor's color profile.

The default Windows 10 Photos application doesn't appear to be color corrected at all. Photoshop, FastStone Image Viewer, Fast Image Viewer, and the older Windows photo viewer all seem to render the images closer to reality. However, they all are slightly different! Can somebody please tell me why this is so?

I am looking for a quick, lightweight, and preferably free photo viewer which renders the photos in the exact same way Photoshop does. Any suggestions
Windows 10 Photos App isn't colour-managed. Photoshop and the older Windows photo viewer are colour managed, FastStone can be, but I think by default it's not - you have to set some option.

If the monitor is correctly calibrated/profiled (with a colorimeter - i1 Display Pro, for example) then colour managed programs should all display with very similar results. Non colour managed programs may be all over the place.

When you calibrate/profile your monitor make sure you set the software to create "v2" profiles, not "v4". There'll be an option somewhere. Some software doesn't work properly with v4 profiles.

I'm not familiar with Benq monitors, but it probably has various modes for calibration, including Adobe RGB, sRGB and native. Native mode generally gets the most accurate profiles. Remember that a profile reflects the state of a monitor with particular settings. Change any settings (brightness, tone curve, colour gamut...) and you need also to change the profile.
 
I own a calibrated, wide-color gamut monitor (BenQ SW2700PT) which displays the full AdobeRGB color spectrum. However, I have tried numerous photo viewing applications, and all seem to render the colors differently in my images; even ones that say they make use of the monitor's color profile.

The default Windows 10 Photos application doesn't appear to be color corrected at all. Photoshop, FastStone Image Viewer, Fast Image Viewer, and the older Windows photo viewer all seem to render the images closer to reality. However, they all are slightly different! Can somebody please tell me why this is so?

I am looking for a quick, lightweight, and preferably free photo viewer which renders the photos in the exact same way Photoshop does. Any suggestions
Do you have a colour profile for the monitor loaded into Windows?



1b9d7d47d1fe4d35a3fa575525c9bf81.jpg

Ian
 
Windows 10 Photos App isn't colour-managed. Photoshop and the older Windows photo viewer are colour managed, FastStone can be, but I think by default it's not - you have to set some option.
FastStone does not respect monitor profiles. IrfanView or XnViewMP need to be told to use them (it's not on by default).
 
Windows 10 Photos App isn't colour-managed. Photoshop and the older Windows photo viewer are colour managed, FastStone can be, but I think by default it's not - you have to set some option.
FastStone does not respect monitor profiles. IrfanView or XnViewMP need to be told to use them (it's not on by default).
 
The Settings panel in Windows 10 doesn't show the color profile for me.
The Settings panel in Windows 10 doesn't show the color profile for me.

However, there is a color profile installed
However, there is a color profile installed
 
Just so we're all on the same page in regards to what I am seeing here, below is a screenshot that shows the color differences between Photoshop and FastStone Image Viewer.



b582e561112f4e9f93c9b3095cbad19a.jpg

Interestingly, FastStone appears closer to being color calibrated when the 'Enable Color Management System' checkbox is unchecked in the CMS tab of the settings panel (as is with above screenshot). Enabling this feature makes colors far too vivid, indicative of it being uncalibrated.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top