Nikon D5500 decent amateur looking for budget zoom lens for dance recitals

Here are a couple of different ideas: a used 24-85mm lens or a 50/1.4. What either would do (especially the 50mm) is to let you shoot at low iso. This would allow you to "zoom" by cropping your 24mp image while maintaining good IQ.
Cropping always reduces IQ, both resolution and noise, and increases DoF.
In many cases, I'll bet you'd get a much nicer result cropping a 100-200 ISO 50mm/1.8 shot than anything at 800+ ISO from a slow zoom lens at, say, 150mm. Unless you're far away, you probably don't need much more than 150mm equivalent anyway.
Let's look at an example where you need 150mm to frame the shot at 1.8m high. You will probably be using f/5.6. If instead you use 50mm at f/1.8 and then crop to the same framing, you will use only 1/9 of the sensor, so only 1/9 of the pixels and 1/9 of the light you captured. That about 3 1/3 stops. So about the same as if you used an aperture of f/5.6 and a 2.6MP sensor So you gained nothing with regard to noise and lost a lot of resolution.

I wouldn't recommend a 50mm f/1.8 unless you could get within about 6m of the stage. Row K won't cut it. for a 50mm.
Hi,

Op wrote based on his experience

quote

I dont mind cropping the shots to focus on my daughter. This is what I do now with the 55 and it works okay.

unquote
I would expect that when he used the 18-55mm he was withing 7m of his daughter.

In the example discussed he'd be about 17m from his daughter, which happens to be around row K.
IMO then it will be okay (not worse then with his 18-55 kitlens) to with a 50mm prime lens (no VR) IF he uses high enough shutterspeed ( at least 1/100 sec imo or higher for moving subjects ).

--
Greetings,
Marc
 
Hi,

Op wrote based on his experience

quote

I dont mind cropping the shots to focus on my daughter. This is what I do now with the 55 and it works okay.

unquote
I would expect that when he used the 18-55mm he was withing 7m of his daughter.

In the example discussed he'd be about 17m from his daughter, which happens to be around row K.
I cannot measure this exactly, but I think that is a fair measurement. I can get 18-105 in my budget, but the 18-140 is a stretch unless I go used on Ebay.

I may go with a prime as well, but I may lean towards a 35MM. In all likelihood that will be another purchase for another time.
 
Last edited:
Easy enough to find out, ask. Large enough batch of other variables actual lighting, distance, etc. Much to be considered.
 
I have been researching for a budget zoom lens for my Nikon D5500. I have been scouring the internet and I am flipping back and forth. If I still lived in NYC I would swing by B&H and ask questions, but I am nowhere near any good camera store for advice. So I would appreciate any advice:

Presently I only have the Nikon D5500 with the kit 18-55 lens which has served me quite well for family pics, etc.

My budget is $250 (absolute max, but would like to spend a bit less) a refurb or used from Amazon would be okay

I am a decent amateur (and dad) looking to take pics and video of daughter’s dance recitals.
You want to do photos and video. If for video I would only take into consideration AF-P lens which is way better for video than AF-S lens.

And of course you need a tripod for doing video with long lens.
 
otos and video. If for video I would only take into consideration AF-P lens which is way better for video than AF-S lens.

And of course you need a tripod for doing video with long lens.
Thank you for the note. I cannot use a tripod since I am sitting in the seats. I have been doing this for a few years now, so I do a pretty good job of holding my arms in. I will admit i never heard of AF-P, but I will check it out.

The 18-55 kit worked pretty well, I just wish I had more of a reach. I think 300mm is WAY to much. I am trying to get the 105 or 140, but I will check out AF-P lens and see
 
Is there any chance you could go to the dress rehearsal and shoot as close as you wish? The 105 is a nice as a carry around/all around but for me it just didn't give me enough reach. Tough decision for you, good luck. We did all of this with our kids, now we are doing it with grandchildren, how did that happen?
 
Is there any chance you could go to the dress rehearsal and shoot as close as you wish? The 105 is a nice as a carry around/all around but for me it just didn't give me enough reach. Tough decision for you, good luck. We did all of this with our kids, now we are doing it with grandchildren, how did that happen?
HA. I know the years go by too fast!

I do both. I go to dress rehearsal and the performance. I take vids and shots during both. During dress rehearsal I am right up to the stage, so reach is not a problem.

During the show day, I do perform a "daddy daughter" dance so I am in the show with several other dads and daughters as well! I enjoy it and I will miss it when it is over.

She does not play sports so I don't need any 70-300 reach.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top