Hello!
... maybe you can help me out.
I always wonder why a strictly theoretical approach is taken and not a practical (subject oriented) one, like in "I do have scene A, want to frame it in way B with perspectice B1, with an evenly as possible (for example) exposure with the least amount of lost highlight data and the least amount of blocked darks - how do I shoot that with FF camera C, APS-C camera D, 4/3s camera E, 1" camera F" - would that not speak more loudly than all theoretical talk (and show the potential differences for everyone to see)?
Oddly enough you skipped one thing: the choice of DOF.
I often hear that ISO does not matter at all and wonder if this is (practically speaking) true in every case? Will I really get the same file to work with when shooting a given scene with (deliberately chosen) "correct" exposure (= the one I want for that very scene) at ISO 100, 200, 300... with shutter speed adjusted accordingly?
You will get a similar result with the same scene
A, with the same perspective
B1, with a similar FOV due to an
equivalent focal length choice resulting in a similar framing way
B. When you choose a DOF look
G you are after, you get that by choosing the same aperture, which results in
equivalent f-stops.
You then get similar DOF, FOV, framing and perspective.
With the larger sensors, you will be able to get less noise.
If, for some or whatever reason, it is important to use the same exposure time (it can be to stop motion, or to capture motion, for instance, or something more mundane as to avoid camera shake induced motion blur), you can achieve that by using
equivalent ISO settings.
With these simple fundamental rules, you can get what you are after with any camera, the only thing that some camera choices offer over other camera choices is shallower DOF options.
If for whatever reason you want to use strangely high DR from RAW to cram that in a lower DR range for print or screen (tonal mapping), that then is another thing where some camera choices are better for that than others.
Time to go do some testing I guess.
Best,
Alex
--
carpe diem, quam minimum credula postero