To me the Trivial Pursuit picture looks like an obvious composite. If there is any 3D effect it is of the die floating above the flat board. The board piece also looks flat. There is also a contradiction between the lighting of the die and the lighting of the board. I think that helps to keep them disjoint (as apposed to a cohesive 3D image).
-
Welcome to the new forums! Please read this first. For known issues we are working to resolve, click here.
3D pop, am I doing it right?
- Thread starter mkstr7
- Start date
- Status
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
Same result, although i don't think every photo looks as good without color.
--
"burn the bed, consummated
rest the head, it just holds us back now
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I hate as much
wet the lips, and shut your pretty mouth
use the kiss, tomorrow fails to exist
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I...
it all surfaces in this light, it all surfaces
words under my breath
taking my time, breaking your smile
feed the wish, and let it flourish
head for shore, and let me haunt you
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I hate as much
I will sleep, throughout the infection
fast asleep, where nothing can find me
words under my breath, taking my time
breaking your smile, everyone goes away
I cant even try, I watched you slip away
words under my breath, taking my time
breaking your smile, every one goes away
i won't ever try, i watched you slip away"
-Effigy 23
Reilly Diefenbach
Forum Pro
My pics back up what I say just fine. Yours prove what they show: that 3D pop doesn't exist, at least in your pictures. We're in full agreement there. You can't or won't afford better gear, so, like a number of participants in this forum, you're determined to drag everyone down to your level of sub mediocrity. Whatever floats your boat, but talk about a huge waste of time which would be much better spent out in the field. Sheesh!
And now this:
Martin.au
Forum Pro
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
Brad Bohland
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 6,356
- Solutions
- 1
- Reaction score
- 2,566
Nicely done.
I've noticed, though, that both your dog shot and this are about f/4, which seems like a middle of the field aperture, not too little, not too much.
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
Yes for two reasons. First off, i think the sharper you can get the subject the more you can get it to stand out, even if it's at the cost of some BG blur. Also, deeper DOF is sometimes needed to get the sharpness to reach the edges, which are sometimes further away than where we focus (usually at the front of an object).Nicely done.
I've noticed, though, that both your dog shot and this are about f/4, which seems like a middle of the field aperture, not too little, not too much.
It all depends on the depth of the subject, how much space is in the BG, and camera to subject distance. Also sharpness of the lens matters as some may need to be stopped down less to get super sharp.
--
"burn the bed, consummated
rest the head, it just holds us back now
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I hate as much
wet the lips, and shut your pretty mouth
use the kiss, tomorrow fails to exist
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I...
it all surfaces in this light, it all surfaces
words under my breath
taking my time, breaking your smile
feed the wish, and let it flourish
head for shore, and let me haunt you
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I hate as much
I will sleep, throughout the infection
fast asleep, where nothing can find me
words under my breath, taking my time
breaking your smile, everyone goes away
I cant even try, I watched you slip away
words under my breath, taking my time
breaking your smile, every one goes away
i won't ever try, i watched you slip away"
-Effigy 23
Martin.au
Forum Pro
It's not a composite. It's a single shot.
It uses live composite, but that's only so I could light it with an iPad, rather than needing to get out the lights.
It uses live composite, but that's only so I could light it with an iPad, rather than needing to get out the lights.
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
Your pics, two of them which were shown in this thread, are the same as mine; using defocus blur to show depth.
Maybe you are just not capable of seeing it? But then you never thought of that bc you have a huge ego and can't imagine there's anything you don't already know huh?
Mackiesback
Forum Pro
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
I think that makes sense. For me at least, im used to light being camera to subject, aka front lit subjects. So the closer the item is to the camera, the brighter it will be via light falloff. I think this is natural, relating to the link the other guy showed about red vs blur and how color affects our perception (the red was brighter than the blue).
So the brighter die and the sharper die all lend to the perception of it being closer. Contrary to what Reiley Doofenbach has been saying, i don't see how that has anything to do with the lens and magical pixie dust.
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
Reilly Diefenbach
Forum Pro
Is English not your first language?
idiotic
A troll's delight for sure. I think we're done here.
Brad Bohland
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 6,356
- Solutions
- 1
- Reaction score
- 2,566
Personally, I like the Marx Brother in the turban.
Reilly Diefenbach
Forum Pro
Between the annoying avatar and the ridiculous sig, there's a lot to dislike.
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
Yes a few months back, in honor of SJW and PC culture, i decided i identify as a middle aged arab man. Before that i was a 20 something gay white male. The beauty is they don't dare call me out on it bc that would be judgmental and they have no right to tell me how i feel. :-D
--
"burn the bed, consummated
rest the head, it just holds us back now
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I hate as much
wet the lips, and shut your pretty mouth
use the kiss, tomorrow fails to exist
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I...
it all surfaces in this light, it all surfaces
words under my breath
taking my time, breaking your smile
feed the wish, and let it flourish
head for shore, and let me haunt you
and still she keeps on looking, of course, of course
and now there's nothing I hate as much
I will sleep, throughout the infection
fast asleep, where nothing can find me
words under my breath, taking my time
breaking your smile, everyone goes away
I cant even try, I watched you slip away
words under my breath, taking my time
breaking your smile, every one goes away
i won't ever try, i watched you slip away"
-Effigy 23
Last edited:
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
That avatar is my identity, how dare you judge me. Im calling the PC police !!!
Martin.au
Forum Pro
And how many other banned accounts before those?
Max Iso
Veteran Member
- Messages
- 8,652
- Reaction score
- 10,214
Still holding a grudge?
- Status
Keyboard shortcuts
- f
- Forum