So as of now, I am compelled to forget DPREVIEW’s a6300’s Telephoto Continuous AF test “catching ups”- as an overhype review. If we are buying any camera based on a review site alone, then we are in a trap.
Sony a6300 is an excellent, compact, all round value based camera - to a certain level handicapped by availability of lenses, user friendliness, battery life and finally overhype reviews.
"I'm thinking perhaps DP Review and Brian Smith may over hyped the potential and possibilities and thus the reason why people now are more dissatisfied with the performance/results. Or maybe the right word is not over hyped but gave us eager beavers too much hope. And from all the reviews seen thus far, at least for me, it hasn't been as I had hoped as well".
The above said opinion in Italics from
Elwes01 S - regarding Sigma MC-11 Adapter in the fallowing review - and I also felt it is true.
that1cameraguy - a Sony shooter, reviewer.
Sigma MC-11 Adapter Updated Review with Video and Autofocus Samples on a6300
Your opinion is valid, as any other person's is...and a good bit of your conclusions are fair. I would at least throw in a word in disagreement for one particular part of your opinion - that the performance of the focus system is 'overhyped'. All of your other reasons sound valid - lens availability, buffer, battery life, etc - and keeping the comparison with pro bodies out of the picture as that's just an entirely different class of camera. But to say that the A6300 was overhyped and cannot perform for something like birding or sports is doing as much a dis-service as you feel Dpreview did, but in the opposite direction. The truth is in the middle.
“
This is a really impressive result: the closest we've seen to a 100% hit-rate in this test so far. The Canon 1D X II and Nikon D5 may well be able to match this performance, but there isn't a DSLR that can focus so far out towards the edge of the frame as this. What's all the more impressive is that there aren't any complex settings that need to be configured to get this result - it's essentially point and shoot.”
They didn't compared it to even 7DMII - My instinct can't accept this.
Dan Bracaglia of DPREVIEW wrote,
@Interestingness We obviously understand the need for a standardized set of AF tests and it is something we are working toward.
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/can..._source=mainmenu&utm_medium=text&ref=mainmenu
So, we can’t rely on their AF tests – after so many cries, DPREVIEW agreed!
Any way I love this site and learned many things from here, so this opinion as a student.
The AF performance, tracking capabilities, and accuracy of the A6300's focus system is overall quite excellent, and very much capable of keeping up with the fastest and most erratic of subjects, with excellent accuracy...IF the photographer has the skill and experience, and as long as the light is reasonable. In VERY low light conditions, it will fall down in comparison to high-level DSLRs, and in overall levels of user control it will also fall down in comparison for high-skill users.
I say this as a long-time wildlife and bird photographer, who shoots with the A6300 AND a DSLR. The A6300 can positively perform exactly as claimed by Sony and Dpreview's review - it's superbly accurate, has no trouble continuously focusing on small and large, fast and slow birds alike, at up to 11fps, and no matter the background. What it can't do is attach a native 400mm or higher lens, shoot 4,000 frames on one battery, shoot in a hard downpour for hours with no damage, or allow the photographer to set various focus limit parameters, focus 'stickiness', or as easily handle multiple settings at once due to the smaller body and fewer controls and dials.
But again, you are entitled to your opinion. I offer the above just to offer a counter-point to that one part of your conclusion which I feel you may be jumping a little too far in reaching.
--
Justin
galleries:
www.pbase.com/zackiedawg
Trying to be perfect is the instinct.
But, nothings can be 100% perfect, so different people, different ways. But to every doings, we are going to get it back.
I value your experience and openness.
But, going through different opinions and reviewing sites, my instinct forced me to that opinion. And I felt, it is my duty to do that.
In ALMIHTY's name wish to happen good things
With regards and love
--
pktk