Reading mode: Light Dark

Is a shot taken at 1/4 second shutter speed still a "moment"?

Go to last post
M

mostlyboringphotog

Forum Pro
Messages
10,475
Reaction score
4,003
How about photos taken with Bulb setting?
 
Last edited:
mostlyboringphotog said:
How about photos taken with Bulb setting?
Click to expand...
All still pictures, regardless of shutter-open duration, are "moments", in that they represent a condensation of a certain amount of time at a certain place into a single impression. Whether they are "momentous" is another matter, however.

Dave
 
Moment of truth?

Moment of silence?

Moment of inertia?

What do you mean by "moment"?
 
cpkuntz said:
Where is my 5.39 x 10^-44 s setting on my shutter speed dial???
Click to expand...
I'm reminded of a photo taken with a pinhole camera with an aperture something like of f/infinity-1 that recorded a year of light on a bridge scene in England, I think it was. Just as with your infinitesimal shutter speed, that represents just a moment of time for that city, and whatever came before it and whatever happens after.

Aaron Ralston scratched on the cliff wall next to the boulder that had inexplicably fallen at the moment needed to trap his arm, "Geological time includes now". Indeed.

Dave
 
mostlyboringphotog said:
How about photos taken with Bulb setting?
Click to expand...
And that, too.

Moment does not mean sub-millisecond. A sunset can be a moment, as can the play of shadows on a mountain side be. A moment will be gone, eventually. That's why we want to capture it. But it can be gone in seconds, minutes or even hours.

Regards, Mike
 
so what is a moment ?

--
The Camera is only a tool, photography is deciding how to use it.
The hardest part about capturing wildlife is not the photographing portion; it’s getting them to sign a model release
 
Last edited:
To have an idea of what a moment means you need context.

If my wife tells me that she will be ready in a moment, I expect that to be less than 45 sec , however if I spot an interesting camera shop and I tell her that I'll be a moment, that would be 45 minutes .

Then there is the other type , so photographically speaking capturing a moment is not directly related to time but atmosphere or emotion, an event.

The photo of the guy in front of a tank in Tiananmen square captured a moment in time , how long was that ?
 
Last edited:
FrancoD said:
To have an idea of what a moment means you need context.

If my wife tells me that she will be ready in a moment, I expect that to be less than 45 sec , however if I spot an interesting camera shop and I tell her that I'll be a moment, that would be 45 minutes .

Then there is the other type , so photographically speaking capturing a moment is not directly related to time but atmosphere or emotion, an event.

The photo of the guy in front of a tank in Tiananmen square captured a moment in time , how long was that ?
Click to expand...
Wow, when my wife is going to be a moment it is around 30 minutes.
 
FrancoD said:
To have an idea of what a moment means you need context.

If my wife tells me that she will be ready in a moment, I expect that to be less than 45 sec , however if I spot an interesting camera shop and I tell her that I'll be a moment, that would be 45 minutes .

Then there is the other type , so photographically speaking capturing a moment is not directly related to time but atmosphere or emotion, an event.

The photo of the guy in front of a tank in Tiananmen square captured a moment in time , how long was that ?
Click to expand...
Which should really be the kind of thing these discussions come down to unless a photograph expressly depends on reflecting absolute reality.

Otherwise a lot of the focus on absolute reality for me comes across more as being reacting against a technique they haven't been willing/able to master
 
mostlyboringphotog said:
How about photos taken with Bulb setting?
Click to expand...
I think your question leads down a wrong path. A 'moment' is a concept of human perception and memory in which time is totally elastic and sometimes irrelelvant.

When people use the word 'moment' in a photographic context as in 'capture the moment', I would argue that what is meant is to capture something that is perceived as transient or fleeting. For most people that would mean a juxtaposition of subjects/background that is ephemeral.
 
No. Now is an upcoming thing...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

LouMeluso
Photography and the Paradox of Now
2
Replies
28
Views
177
Ellis Vener
Ellis Vener
G
  • Question Question
A7RV setting shutter to 1/50 second
Replies
5
Views
214
Logan Nolag
L
Alan Sh
X-E5 and shutter speeds
Replies
2
Views
3
Alan Sh
Alan Sh
P
A1 Mk II with Firmware 3.0 bulb not working?
Replies
10
Views
11
Peter Precht
P
T
  • Question Question
E-M1 Mark III has a short delay
Replies
17
Views
78
Bassam Guy
B

Keyboard shortcuts

f
Forum
m
My threads
Mobile site
About
Editorial content
Cameras & Lenses
Community
All content, design, and layout are Copyright © 1998–2025 Digital Photography Review All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or part in any form or medium without specific written permission is prohibited.
When you use DPReview links to buy products, the site may earn a commission.
©GPS Media - Guides, Products, Services.
Back
Top