My very first DSLR purchase......I really need some expert advice!

There is no wisdom in not buying something you want to buy.

The T5i will take wonderful pictures, you want one, go buy one.

Become a photographer, not a do-nothing teckiephile.

BAK
exactly I got the 1100d and was told it was terrible but the photos i took and what it does I find it an awesome camera all be it old.
I've seen great images that were taken by a Iphone.

I have seen terrible images taken with a D810.

That doesn't change the fact that the competing Nikon bodies offer better AF and better technical image quality then the competing Canon's. especially at the price of a t5i/700d.

Or higher up the ladder with the Nikon D610/d750 vs 6d
Best bet get down to a shop and pick up a few and see what u like.
They feel more or less the same. A pastic body with some but not great direct control.

The Nikon lenses turn the other way arround and the Canon has a touchscreen.

The customer will get used to both but the Nikon remains technically the better camera here.

At least until Canon makes some improvements after 3 years of total stagnation in this part of the market.
 
Last edited:
I agree. I am a Canon shooter but no way would I buy one now. Canon has been really slow in making improvements in sensors and image quality. At this point, I would recommend Nikon. I am not a Sams Club member but at Costco there are always lots of well priced Nikon kits.
I would not recommend going to Nikon until you see what the new Rebel line brings this spring.
 
I agree. I am a Canon shooter but no way would I buy one now. Canon has been really slow in making improvements in sensors and image quality. At this point, I would recommend Nikon. I am not a Sams Club member but at Costco there are always lots of well priced Nikon kits.
I would not recommend going to Nikon until you see what the new Rebel line brings this spring.
It's always smart to wait with a purchase until after a major photography event.

Especialy when cp+ is arround the corner.
But if Canon dissapoints there. The conclusion for new users should be clear.
 
I agree. I am a Canon shooter but no way would I buy one now. Canon has been really slow in making improvements in sensors and image quality. At this point, I would recommend Nikon. I am not a Sams Club member but at Costco there are always lots of well priced Nikon kits.
I would not recommend going to Nikon until you see what the new Rebel line brings this spring.
It's always smart to wait with a purchase until after a major photography event.

Especialy when cp+ is arround the corner.
But if Canon dissapoints there. The conclusion for new users should be clear.
I would have said exactly the same thing......several years ago. I even had hopes for the 7DII. Now the best I am expecting is Canon trying to match the Sony sensors.
 
I want to thank EVERYONE that contributed their thoughts and suggestions to me on this forum post.......it's much appreciated, and when I make my decision, I'll let you know which camera I've chosen. Thanks again, too, for the time and effort my friends here on dpreview.com took to respond to me......great advice all around!

With appreciation,
Doug
 
I agree. I am a Canon shooter but no way would I buy one now. Canon has been really slow in making improvements in sensors and image quality. At this point, I would recommend Nikon. I am not a Sams Club member but at Costco there are always lots of well priced Nikon kits.
Thing is will a beginner dslr user be able to notice and actually use any small difference in dynamic range? It's raw only and only at low iso. nikon has 39 points but very few are cross type sensitivity while all 9 of the T5i's Af points are cross type and are more spread out than nikon's cross types.
 
I agree. I am a Canon shooter but no way would I buy one now. Canon has been really slow in making improvements in sensors and image quality. At this point, I would recommend Nikon. I am not a Sams Club member but at Costco there are always lots of well priced Nikon kits.
Thing is will a beginner dslr user be able to notice and actually use any small difference in dynamic range? It's raw only and only at low iso. nikon has 39 points but very few are cross type sensitivity while all 9 of the T5i's Af points are cross type and are more spread out than nikon's cross types.
An improvement in dynamic range is very noticeable. The improvement does not depend on the skill of the photographer. It is built in to the capability of the system and does not require any operator involvement. Dynamic range is a characteristic of the sensor which would affect raw and jpeg captures.

I have no idea which system has the best AF. A lot of focus points would be useful for BIF and sports photography. For the vast majority of my shooting I only use one point so that I can select the object in focus. I am not happy with the system in my Canon since it will not handle macro shooting. Again, I have no idea if the Nikon works better for macro photography. It could hardly be worse.

The other issue is resolution. A jump from 18 to 24 is helpful. It helps for cropping and making large prints. It also improves sharpness for small prints or monitor displays.

I would also recommend Nikon over Canon, because at least Nikon is trying to make sensor improvements even if that means buying from a third party. Canon seems to be milking the old technology and then wondering why sales are dropping.
 
I agree. I am a Canon shooter but no way would I buy one now. Canon has been really slow in making improvements in sensors and image quality. At this point, I would recommend Nikon. I am not a Sams Club member but at Costco there are always lots of well priced Nikon kits.
Thing is will a beginner dslr user be able to notice and actually use any small difference in dynamic range? It's raw only and only at low iso. nikon has 39 points but very few are cross type sensitivity while all 9 of the T5i's Af points are cross type and are more spread out than nikon's cross types.
An improvement in dynamic range is very noticeable. The improvement does not depend on the skill of the photographer. It is built in to the capability of the system and does not require any operator involvement. Dynamic range is a characteristic of the sensor which would affect raw and jpeg captures.

I have no idea which system has the best AF. A lot of focus points would be useful for BIF and sports photography. For the vast majority of my shooting I only use one point so that I can select the object in focus. I am not happy with the system in my Canon since it will not handle macro shooting. Again, I have no idea if the Nikon works better for macro photography. It could hardly be worse.

The other issue is resolution. A jump from 18 to 24 is helpful. It helps for cropping and making large prints. It also improves sharpness for small prints or monitor displays.

I would also recommend Nikon over Canon, because at least Nikon is trying to make sensor improvements even if that means buying from a third party. Canon seems to be milking the old technology and then wondering why sales are dropping.
 
jrkliny wrote:

............

I have no idea which system has the best AF. A lot of focus points would be useful for BIF and sports photography. For the vast majority of my shooting I only use one point so that I can select the object in focus. I am not happy with the system in my Canon since it will not handle macro shooting. Again, I have no idea if the Nikon works better for macro photography. It could hardly be worse.

............
 
jrkliny wrote:

............

I have no idea which system has the best AF. A lot of focus points would be useful for BIF and sports photography. For the vast majority of my shooting I only use one point so that I can select the object in focus. I am not happy with the system in my Canon since it will not handle macro shooting. Again, I have no idea if the Nikon works better for macro photography. It could hardly be worse.

............
 
RedFox88 wrote:.. Autofocus at 1:1 handheld is a exercise in frustration.
At least with my Canon that is true. I see no reason that should be the case. That was not the case with my Canon G9. It could focus very close and the AF continued to work.
 
Most that use a macro lens near 1:1, regardless of brand, are using a tripod and manual focus.
No longer true. It's trivially easy to get every shot in perfect focus with my 100L, all the way to 1:1 and beyond (with short extension tubes), and perfectly sharp with flash at max. sync. for illumination.
Autofocus at 1:1 handheld is a exercise in frustration.
Not in servo with a single AF point. It's even better with cameras like the 7Ds and 70D, which double the AF sampling rate in macro situations.
 
I will try servo mode even though that does not seem to make sense since the focus never seems to lock.
 
I will try servo mode even though that does not seem to make sense since the focus never seems to lock.
That's the point! :-)

You don't want a fixed focus because you're always moving. A good camera and lens combination (60D + 100L in my case, but even a 40/2.8 STM on an extension tube...) will handle that fine.

--
Check out the unofficial Rebel Talk FAQ.
 
Last edited:
Friends, I wanted to thank all of you for your constructive and helpful advice, so I finally decided on this terrific deal for my first DSLR purchase....

http://shop.usa.canon.com/shop/en/c...ras/eos-sl1-18-55-is-stm-lens-kit-refurbished

I decided on the SL1 based on expert and owner reviews of the camera, and since this is my first DSLR purchase, I didn't think I needed a camera with a lot of bells and whistles as I'll be on a steep learning curve with this camera. I know I'm going to be happy with it!

Thanks again,
Doug
 
Last edited:
Friends, I wanted to thank all of you for your constructive and helpful advice, so I finally decided on this terrific deal for my first DSLR purchase....

http://shop.usa.canon.com/shop/en/c...ras/eos-sl1-18-55-is-stm-lens-kit-refurbished

I decided on the SL1 based on expert and owner reviews of the camera, and since this is my first DSLR purchase, I didn't think I needed a camera with a lot of bells and whistles as I'll be on a steep learning curve with this camera. I know I'm going to be happy with it!

Thanks again,
Doug
Congrats! As a very happy owner of an SL1, I think you'll have great fun with it.
 
Congratulation! Great choice, IMO. I love my SL1 and hope you enjoy your just as much.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top