X-T1 Dials: Perfectly Flawed

EngiNerd27

Active member
Messages
57
Reaction score
9
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
 
can be tricky to hit center weighted
I agree with you that it is a pleasure to see all these controls and no need to dig up the menus :)

As for the metering - be advised that there is no center-weighted unless you mean "spot" (that is more like center-weighted in other cameras) :)

There are three metering modes in Fujifilm cameras:

Spot - meters from the center of the frame, regardless of your AF point

Average - takes a whole frame into account

Multi - multi/matrix/whatever you call it - the scene recognition metering that works quite well in Fujifilm cameras.

Regards
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
Keep in mind you're comparing to the NEX system which might be the worst camera interface ever created. Even the folks at Sony have essentially admitted as much by abandoning that whole interface and not even calling their new cameras "NEX" for fear of negative connotation.
 
Last edited:
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
that's the double truth Ruth! i am absolutely in love with the physical controls on the xt-1. the fact that i can adjust settings i need for the situation without even turning the camera on is just awesome
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
Good post, I concur completely, it's so easy to reconfigure the camera without needing to do mental gymnastics it makes it a simple camera to shoot, and I'm all for that.
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
We're all different. The XT-1 dials were a *nightmare* for me. Each time I tried to change ISO, I unvoluntarily changed the drive mode, ended up in Pano or self-timer or whatever, then when I wanted to change the speed, I'd accidentally knock the metering dial off and suddenly be in spot metering. Not too mention the exp comp dial was super stiff and acutally needed a slight angle to be turned. Horrible all the way. I know a lot of people love it, but it was as counter intuitive to me as can be. I've been shooting the NEX7 for over two years and I can do so half awake, it's just totally natural. Not to say one is better than others, just different stuff for different shooting styles. The X-A and X-M are the only Fujis I can consider as they offer a traditional (to me !) two free spinning digital wheels set-up....
 
I couldn't agree with you more. My XT1 is on its first holiday in the South Island. It is so easy to use especially when on a tripod. What settings do I have? Oh yes, that''s it. While I loved my NEX7, this XT1 works so well for me.

Interestingly, I broke my XE2 as a second body to avoid lens changes. It's been out of my bag twice - in error as I grabbed the wrong body. When I did try to use it, it really came home how wonderful the XT1 is. I think my XE2's days are numbered now. It will be more useful to me contributing to paying for its big brother.
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
We're all different. The XT-1 dials were a *nightmare* for me. Each time I tried to change ISO, I unvoluntarily changed the drive mode, ended up in Pano or self-timer or whatever, then when I wanted to change the speed, I'd accidentally knock the metering dial off and suddenly be in spot metering. Not too mention the exp comp dial was super stiff and acutally needed a slight angle to be turned. Horrible all the way. I know a lot of people love it, but it was as counter intuitive to me as can be. I've been shooting the NEX7 for over two years and I can do so half awake, it's just totally natural. Not to say one is better than others, just different stuff for different shooting styles. The X-A and X-M are the only Fujis I can consider as they offer a traditional (to me !) two free spinning digital wheels set-up....
ROTFL! Not sure what will happen when they have to match the competition's 1/8000 sec shutter speed - smaller letters on the shutter dial, or a bigger dial perhaps. :)

Michael Reichmann of Luminous Landscape is correct when he points to the lack of custom setting on the X-T1. The following is a quote from his site on a discussion of the limitations of manual controls: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/fuji_x_t1_further_thoughts.shtml

"But, as the saying goes, be careful what you wish for. It wasn't long after the first blush of passion had passed that I realized that this oh-so-desirable design had a dark side. The camera has no customization settings for shooting modes. This means that when you want to quickly change from one type of shooting to another, every applicable control has to be individually altered. Let me explain.

You are standing out in the field in the late afternoon light taking a shot of your girlfriend posing demurely by a fence. You've set the camera to either manual focus, or maybe single button AF. The shutter speed is moderate, because you're hand holding, the ISO is low for optimum quality, and you have set the aperture fairly wide for shallow depth of field. You're using average zone metering because she is side lit. Drive mode is set to single frame, and metering for matrix.

All of a sudden, an amazing flock of Canada Geese appears behind her. Their wings are illuminated by the low sun, but they're flying fast in chevron formation. What a shot! What do you do?

With the X-T1 you turn the dial to change the shutter speed to something fast, say 1/1500 sec. You then turn the aperture dial to something on the wide side, because you don't want to have to use too high an ISO. The metering mode needs to be changed from average to spot, and the drive mode from single frame to high speed with focus tracking. Finally, the ISO needs to be boosted, because of the high shutter speed, or maybe reset to Auto.

Sadly, by the time that you've done all this, the geese have gone back to Canada and have begun to raise their families."


At least on my X-A1 I can program one custom setting on the mode dial. :) My old Canon G7 has two positions, and this is the case for many advanced cameras with standard mode dials. With all of the manual dials on Fuji's advanced cameras, the only place to put custom settings would be in a menu.
 
Dials. I have never tried using a Nikon Df, but the dials are more then likely easer to grab, because they are larger. Every one wants a small camera, a camera the size of a point and shoot with EVF and FF. Well if this is to be dials will get smaller. Go to camera store or pond shop and look at a Nikon F to F6. You can grab them dials. Small cameras small dials a fact of life.
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
We're all different. The XT-1 dials were a *nightmare* for me. Each time I tried to change ISO, I unvoluntarily changed the drive mode, ended up in Pano or self-timer or whatever, then when I wanted to change the speed, I'd accidentally knock the metering dial off and suddenly be in spot metering. Not too mention the exp comp dial was super stiff and acutally needed a slight angle to be turned. Horrible all the way. I know a lot of people love it, but it was as counter intuitive to me as can be. I've been shooting the NEX7 for over two years and I can do so half awake, it's just totally natural. Not to say one is better than others, just different stuff for different shooting styles. The X-A and X-M are the only Fujis I can consider as they offer a traditional (to me !) two free spinning digital wheels set-up....
ROTFL! Not sure what will happen when they have to match the competition's 1/8000 sec shutter speed - smaller letters on the shutter dial, or a bigger dial perhaps. :)

Michael Reichmann of Luminous Landscape is correct when he points to the lack of custom setting on the X-T1. The following is a quote from his site on a discussion of the limitations of manual controls: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/fuji_x_t1_further_thoughts.shtml

"But, as the saying goes, be careful what you wish for. It wasn't long after the first blush of passion had passed that I realized that this oh-so-desirable design had a dark side. The camera has no customization settings for shooting modes. This means that when you want to quickly change from one type of shooting to another, every applicable control has to be individually altered. Let me explain.

You are standing out in the field in the late afternoon light taking a shot of your girlfriend posing demurely by a fence. You've set the camera to either manual focus, or maybe single button AF. The shutter speed is moderate, because you're hand holding, the ISO is low for optimum quality, and you have set the aperture fairly wide for shallow depth of field. You're using average zone metering because she is side lit. Drive mode is set to single frame, and metering for matrix.

All of a sudden, an amazing flock of Canada Geese appears behind her. Their wings are illuminated by the low sun, but they're flying fast in chevron formation. What a shot! What do you do?

With the X-T1 you turn the dial to change the shutter speed to something fast, say 1/1500 sec. You then turn the aperture dial to something on the wide side, because you don't want to have to use too high an ISO. The metering mode needs to be changed from average to spot, and the drive mode from single frame to high speed with focus tracking. Finally, the ISO needs to be boosted, because of the high shutter speed, or maybe reset to Auto.

Sadly, by the time that you've done all this, the geese have gone back to Canada and have begun to raise their families."


At least on my X-A1 I can program one custom setting on the mode dial. :) My old Canon G7 has two positions, and this is the case for many advanced cameras with standard mode dials. With all of the manual dials on Fuji's advanced cameras, the only place to put custom settings would be in a menu.
I thought about this myself but the problem with custom settings is it's easy to forget what you've set them to, or they're not set to exactly what you want for that unexpected shot anyway. I can very quickly change the settings on the XT-1 because they're right there and I can see how the camera is set up straight away, this really is a non-issue if you know your camera.
 
...

Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7.
Totally agreed. This is precisely why I chose a Fuji. When I shoot, I feel more conscious of what I an doing. With the physical dials I can see exactly which value I am choosing among which others.

This is strange, but I think it works for the same reason that Japanese train drivers use the "pointing and calling" method to stay fully aware of what they are doing.

 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
We're all different. The XT-1 dials were a *nightmare* for me. Each time I tried to change ISO, I unvoluntarily changed the drive mode, ended up in Pano or self-timer or whatever, then when I wanted to change the speed, I'd accidentally knock the metering dial off and suddenly be in spot metering. Not too mention the exp comp dial was super stiff and acutally needed a slight angle to be turned. Horrible all the way. I know a lot of people love it, but it was as counter intuitive to me as can be. I've been shooting the NEX7 for over two years and I can do so half awake, it's just totally natural. Not to say one is better than others, just different stuff for different shooting styles. The X-A and X-M are the only Fujis I can consider as they offer a traditional (to me !) two free spinning digital wheels set-up....
ROTFL! Not sure what will happen when they have to match the competition's 1/8000 sec shutter speed - smaller letters on the shutter dial, or a bigger dial perhaps. :)

Michael Reichmann of Luminous Landscape is correct when he points to the lack of custom setting on the X-T1. The following is a quote from his site on a discussion of the limitations of manual controls: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/fuji_x_t1_further_thoughts.shtml

"But, as the saying goes, be careful what you wish for. It wasn't long after the first blush of passion had passed that I realized that this oh-so-desirable design had a dark side. The camera has no customization settings for shooting modes. This means that when you want to quickly change from one type of shooting to another, every applicable control has to be individually altered. Let me explain.

You are standing out in the field in the late afternoon light taking a shot of your girlfriend posing demurely by a fence. You've set the camera to either manual focus, or maybe single button AF. The shutter speed is moderate, because you're hand holding, the ISO is low for optimum quality, and you have set the aperture fairly wide for shallow depth of field. You're using average zone metering because she is side lit. Drive mode is set to single frame, and metering for matrix.

All of a sudden, an amazing flock of Canada Geese appears behind her. Their wings are illuminated by the low sun, but they're flying fast in chevron formation. What a shot! What do you do?

With the X-T1 you turn the dial to change the shutter speed to something fast, say 1/1500 sec. You then turn the aperture dial to something on the wide side, because you don't want to have to use too high an ISO. The metering mode needs to be changed from average to spot, and the drive mode from single frame to high speed with focus tracking. Finally, the ISO needs to be boosted, because of the high shutter speed, or maybe reset to Auto.

Sadly, by the time that you've done all this, the geese have gone back to Canada and have begun to raise their families."


At least on my X-A1 I can program one custom setting on the mode dial. :) My old Canon G7 has two positions, and this is the case for many advanced cameras with standard mode dials. With all of the manual dials on Fuji's advanced cameras, the only place to put custom settings would be in a menu.
I thought about this myself but the problem with custom settings is it's easy to forget what you've set them to, or they're not set to exactly what you want for that unexpected shot anyway. I can very quickly change the settings on the XT-1 because they're right there and I can see how the camera is set up straight away, this really is a non-issue if you know your camera.
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
We're all different. The XT-1 dials were a *nightmare* for me. Each time I tried to change ISO, I unvoluntarily changed the drive mode, ended up in Pano or self-timer or whatever, then when I wanted to change the speed, I'd accidentally knock the metering dial off and suddenly be in spot metering. Not too mention the exp comp dial was super stiff and acutally needed a slight angle to be turned. Horrible all the way. I know a lot of people love it, but it was as counter intuitive to me as can be. I've been shooting the NEX7 for over two years and I can do so half awake, it's just totally natural. Not to say one is better than others, just different stuff for different shooting styles. The X-A and X-M are the only Fujis I can consider as they offer a traditional (to me !) two free spinning digital wheels set-up....
ROTFL! Not sure what will happen when they have to match the competition's 1/8000 sec shutter speed - smaller letters on the shutter dial, or a bigger dial perhaps. :)

Michael Reichmann of Luminous Landscape is correct when he points to the lack of custom setting on the X-T1. The following is a quote from his site on a discussion of the limitations of manual controls: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/fuji_x_t1_further_thoughts.shtml

"But, as the saying goes, be careful what you wish for. It wasn't long after the first blush of passion had passed that I realized that this oh-so-desirable design had a dark side. The camera has no customization settings for shooting modes. This means that when you want to quickly change from one type of shooting to another, every applicable control has to be individually altered. Let me explain.

You are standing out in the field in the late afternoon light taking a shot of your girlfriend posing demurely by a fence. You've set the camera to either manual focus, or maybe single button AF. The shutter speed is moderate, because you're hand holding, the ISO is low for optimum quality, and you have set the aperture fairly wide for shallow depth of field. You're using average zone metering because she is side lit. Drive mode is set to single frame, and metering for matrix.

All of a sudden, an amazing flock of Canada Geese appears behind her. Their wings are illuminated by the low sun, but they're flying fast in chevron formation. What a shot! What do you do?

With the X-T1 you turn the dial to change the shutter speed to something fast, say 1/1500 sec. You then turn the aperture dial to something on the wide side, because you don't want to have to use too high an ISO. The metering mode needs to be changed from average to spot, and the drive mode from single frame to high speed with focus tracking. Finally, the ISO needs to be boosted, because of the high shutter speed, or maybe reset to Auto.

Sadly, by the time that you've done all this, the geese have gone back to Canada and have begun to raise their families."


At least on my X-A1 I can program one custom setting on the mode dial. :) My old Canon G7 has two positions, and this is the case for many advanced cameras with standard mode dials. With all of the manual dials on Fuji's advanced cameras, the only place to put custom settings would be in a menu.
I thought about this myself but the problem with custom settings is it's easy to forget what you've set them to, or they're not set to exactly what you want for that unexpected shot anyway. I can very quickly change the settings on the XT-1 because they're right there and I can see how the camera is set up straight away, this really is a non-issue if you know your camera.
This is an implementation issue, not a custom setting issue. One of the reasons that I've stuck with Canon for as long as I have is because all my cameras are hacked to provide a lot of additional functionality. For instance, with the 400plus hack on the XTi, you can program up to 16 named custom settings (each using all of the camera settings). You can then assign seven of these settings at a time on the useless scene positions on the mode dial). When you switch to a custom position on the mode dial, the name of the setting is displayed on the LCD. This setup is perfect for someone who's shooting is varied in a session. Each setting can be fine tuned after selection. On the XTi, I don't even bother with the PASM modes anymore.
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
We're all different. The XT-1 dials were a *nightmare* for me. Each time I tried to change ISO, I unvoluntarily changed the drive mode, ended up in Pano or self-timer or whatever, then when I wanted to change the speed, I'd accidentally knock the metering dial off and suddenly be in spot metering. Not too mention the exp comp dial was super stiff and acutally needed a slight angle to be turned. Horrible all the way. I know a lot of people love it, but it was as counter intuitive to me as can be. I've been shooting the NEX7 for over two years and I can do so half awake, it's just totally natural. Not to say one is better than others, just different stuff for different shooting styles. The X-A and X-M are the only Fujis I can consider as they offer a traditional (to me !) two free spinning digital wheels set-up....
ROTFL! Not sure what will happen when they have to match the competition's 1/8000 sec shutter speed - smaller letters on the shutter dial, or a bigger dial perhaps. :)

Michael Reichmann of Luminous Landscape is correct when he points to the lack of custom setting on the X-T1. The following is a quote from his site on a discussion of the limitations of manual controls: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/fuji_x_t1_further_thoughts.shtml

"But, as the saying goes, be careful what you wish for. It wasn't long after the first blush of passion had passed that I realized that this oh-so-desirable design had a dark side. The camera has no customization settings for shooting modes. This means that when you want to quickly change from one type of shooting to another, every applicable control has to be individually altered. Let me explain.

You are standing out in the field in the late afternoon light taking a shot of your girlfriend posing demurely by a fence. You've set the camera to either manual focus, or maybe single button AF. The shutter speed is moderate, because you're hand holding, the ISO is low for optimum quality, and you have set the aperture fairly wide for shallow depth of field. You're using average zone metering because she is side lit. Drive mode is set to single frame, and metering for matrix.

All of a sudden, an amazing flock of Canada Geese appears behind her. Their wings are illuminated by the low sun, but they're flying fast in chevron formation. What a shot! What do you do?

With the X-T1 you turn the dial to change the shutter speed to something fast, say 1/1500 sec. You then turn the aperture dial to something on the wide side, because you don't want to have to use too high an ISO. The metering mode needs to be changed from average to spot, and the drive mode from single frame to high speed with focus tracking. Finally, the ISO needs to be boosted, because of the high shutter speed, or maybe reset to Auto.

Sadly, by the time that you've done all this, the geese have gone back to Canada and have begun to raise their families."


At least on my X-A1 I can program one custom setting on the mode dial. :) My old Canon G7 has two positions, and this is the case for many advanced cameras with standard mode dials. With all of the manual dials on Fuji's advanced cameras, the only place to put custom settings would be in a menu.
I thought about this myself but the problem with custom settings is it's easy to forget what you've set them to, or they're not set to exactly what you want for that unexpected shot anyway. I can very quickly change the settings on the XT-1 because they're right there and I can see how the camera is set up straight away, this really is a non-issue if you know your camera.
 
Yes my metering dial sticks and can be tricky to hit center weighted and yes, the ISO dial would be less work if it only locked on A. Yet I've noticed as I continue to use the hell out of my X-T1 that the persistence of these controls is a big part of what makes taking pictures with the X-T1 feel so much more intuitive and less abstract than it did with my Nex-7. If a situation arises where shutter speed matters, I was so used to "OK what mode am I in? Ok which shortcut key? Ok which dial? Ok, which speed? Ok Perfect! What am I doing again?". Three quarters of that process had nothing to do with my desired end result and no matter my muscle memory, it always made for a distinct lack of flow (even if I didn't know it). With the X-T1, I may fumble now and again with the physical element of changing settings, but mentally, I'm no longer playing "how do I get there from here" hopscotch and for me, this has been huge. Just my two cents!
We're all different. The XT-1 dials were a *nightmare* for me. Each time I tried to change ISO, I unvoluntarily changed the drive mode, ended up in Pano or self-timer or whatever, then when I wanted to change the speed, I'd accidentally knock the metering dial off and suddenly be in spot metering. Not too mention the exp comp dial was super stiff and acutally needed a slight angle to be turned. Horrible all the way. I know a lot of people love it, but it was as counter intuitive to me as can be. I've been shooting the NEX7 for over two years and I can do so half awake, it's just totally natural. Not to say one is better than others, just different stuff for different shooting styles. The X-A and X-M are the only Fujis I can consider as they offer a traditional (to me !) two free spinning digital wheels set-up....
ROTFL! Not sure what will happen when they have to match the competition's 1/8000 sec shutter speed - smaller letters on the shutter dial, or a bigger dial perhaps. :)

Michael Reichmann of Luminous Landscape is correct when he points to the lack of custom setting on the X-T1. The following is a quote from his site on a discussion of the limitations of manual controls: http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/fuji_x_t1_further_thoughts.shtml

"But, as the saying goes, be careful what you wish for. It wasn't long after the first blush of passion had passed that I realized that this oh-so-desirable design had a dark side. The camera has no customization settings for shooting modes. This means that when you want to quickly change from one type of shooting to another, every applicable control has to be individually altered. Let me explain.

You are standing out in the field in the late afternoon light taking a shot of your girlfriend posing demurely by a fence. You've set the camera to either manual focus, or maybe single button AF. The shutter speed is moderate, because you're hand holding, the ISO is low for optimum quality, and you have set the aperture fairly wide for shallow depth of field. You're using average zone metering because she is side lit. Drive mode is set to single frame, and metering for matrix.

All of a sudden, an amazing flock of Canada Geese appears behind her. Their wings are illuminated by the low sun, but they're flying fast in chevron formation. What a shot! What do you do?

With the X-T1 you turn the dial to change the shutter speed to something fast, say 1/1500 sec. You then turn the aperture dial to something on the wide side, because you don't want to have to use too high an ISO. The metering mode needs to be changed from average to spot, and the drive mode from single frame to high speed with focus tracking. Finally, the ISO needs to be boosted, because of the high shutter speed, or maybe reset to Auto.

Sadly, by the time that you've done all this, the geese have gone back to Canada and have begun to raise their families."


At least on my X-A1 I can program one custom setting on the mode dial. :) My old Canon G7 has two positions, and this is the case for many advanced cameras with standard mode dials. With all of the manual dials on Fuji's advanced cameras, the only place to put custom settings would be in a menu.
I thought about this myself but the problem with custom settings is it's easy to forget what you've set them to, or they're not set to exactly what you want for that unexpected shot anyway. I can very quickly change the settings on the XT-1 because they're right there and I can see how the camera is set up straight away, this really is a non-issue if you know your camera.
This is an implementation issue, not a custom setting issue. One of the reasons that I've stuck with Canon for as long as I have is because all my cameras are hacked to provide a lot of additional functionality. For instance, with the 400plus hack on the XTi, you can program up to 16 named custom settings (each using all of the camera settings). You can then assign seven of these settings at a time on the useless scene positions on the mode dial). When you switch to a custom position on the mode dial, the name of the setting is displayed on the LCD. This setup is perfect for someone who's shooting is varied in a session. Each setting can be fine tuned after selection. On the XTi, I don't even bother with the PASM modes anymore.
Which is great if you need/want it, but ties you to that camera and brand. I'm more a keep it simple stupid kind of guy, that works for me, so instead of it being an implementation issue, it's an implementation strength for me personally.
 
I think custom settings presets lead to poor/lazy photography - some of the time, not all of the time. If one becomes dependent on a preset/profile/whatever, it becomes more difficult to decide to change to the best possible settings for a situation.

In the situation described earlier in which the photographer changes from photographing a girlfriend to geese, I would not have a "fast-moving distant object" preset. That would be sort of a crazy thing for me (personally) to have, since I don't normally shoot something like that. Even if I did have that preset, it would take me far too much time to figure out which preset was the correct one.

In that same situation, I am much faster with the two dials (and ISO mapped to a button) on my X-E1 than I would be with a preset. That's without the benefit of an ISO dial. Of course, this is not the main advantage to working this way. The main advantage is that I _must_ remain conscious of my exact exposure settings and what they do. It keeps me in a constant state of learning, artistic control, and general awareness of the photographic situation around me.

I can also imagine an argument that one can be more consistent, perfectly skilled, and specialized if limited to a few presets. That makes sense. It's probably also a great way of working. Daido Moriyama has worked similarly and produces excellent work.
 
I think custom settings presets lead to poor/lazy photography - some of the time, not all of the time. If one becomes dependent on a preset/profile/whatever, it becomes more difficult to decide to change to the best possible settings for a situation.

In the situation described earlier in which the photographer changes from photographing a girlfriend to geese, I would not have a "fast-moving distant object" preset. That would be sort of a crazy thing for me (personally) to have, since I don't normally shoot something like that. Even if I did have that preset, it would take me far too much time to figure out which preset was the correct one.

In that same situation, I am much faster with the two dials (and ISO mapped to a button) on my X-E1 than I would be with a preset. That's without the benefit of an ISO dial. Of course, this is not the main advantage to working this way. The main advantage is that I _must_ remain conscious of my exact exposure settings and what they do. It keeps me in a constant state of learning, artistic control, and general awareness of the photographic situation around me.

I can also imagine an argument that one can be more consistent, perfectly skilled, and specialized if limited to a few presets. That makes sense. It's probably also a great way of working. Daido Moriyama has worked similarly and produces excellent work.
I think it's just the opposite - I think people who successfully leverage custom pre-sets are people who understand the camera in detail, and know exactly how they want it to behave in certain circumstances, and they know when to use those presets and when to switch to manual.

But yes, I agree with the comments pertaining to the KISS philosophy of the UI of the Fujis, and that presets are at odds with that philosophy. If one wants a lightweight highly customizable ILC, one should look to Olympus. Nothing wrong, or right, with that. It's just the nature of the decisions made by the design teams behind the respective systems, and one has to choose which is more appropriate for their needs.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top