"Grammar Police" why ?

johnierebel

Senior Member
Messages
2,138
Reaction score
789
Location
MO, US
Saturday I was flagged for 'hole' instead 'whole', guilty, lack of coffee, & I'm OK with 'give the other guy hell' over stupid. Today I was flagged for placing a space before a coma. Really? My critic had nothing to say as to the thread. I think that's rude at least to the OP. P.S. I hope I haven't made any mistakes, 3 strikes & your out.
 
But I get your point, I would not bother to comment except that it is a thread about grammar :)
 
I have to admit that I get annoyed about bad grammar (mine it awful)....and bad spelling, even when the person writings language is not English, I get cross. It is irrational because so long as the intent of the communication is clear why worry......BUT

Imagine if we all started to post in text speak.....how bloody irritating would that be???

:-)

Mike
 
Saturday I was flagged for 'hole' instead 'whole', guilty, lack of coffee, & I'm OK with 'give the other guy hell' over stupid. Today I was flagged for placing a space before a coma. Really? My critic had nothing to say as to the thread. I think that's rude at least to the OP. P.S. I hope I haven't made any mistakes, 3 strikes & your out.
I'm completely anal about my own spelling and grammar, I even proofread text messages... many people on the forums speak English as a second or third language, many errors are simply due to auto correct. Unless you want to put someone down because you need to feel better about yourself, there's no point in correcting the spelling/grammar in someone's post.

P.S. You put a space before a coma? OMG, really? That's just shameful :-) Oops, I just used two spaces after a question mark and I'm not even going to fix it ;-)
 
Does it hurt ?

In fact it's useful to people ( in business, etc. ) to develop their writing skills and learn to get things right.

It shouldn't bother you. Look on it as positive that someone out there cares enough about your writing to not only read it, nut analyze it in detail.

And it keeps these dictionary nuts off the streets. :-)
 
Saturday I was flagged for 'hole' instead 'whole', guilty, lack of coffee, & I'm OK with 'give the other guy hell' over stupid. Today I was flagged for placing a space before a coma. Really? My critic had nothing to say as to the thread. I think that's rude at least to the OP. P.S. I hope I haven't made any mistakes, 3 strikes & your out.
People, from a country where English is not the native language, who are smart enough and who speak English well enough to communicate on these forums, have always impressed me.

People from an English speaking country, who constantly make spelling and grammar errors, are less impressive.

With that said, I make quite a few errors myself so, I can't be too critical.
 
I , for one , have always placed spaces between words and punctuation marks ( with the exception of apostrophes used to indicate abbreviation or possession ) : that being the way we were taught at school , and having had it drummed into us by our tutor that it was one of the hallmarks of a professional typist .

These days it would seem that poor spelling , bad or no punctuation and that grammar is an abbreviation for grandmother all seem commonplace ! Perhaps this is in some way due to the computer age with many becoming reliant on software to correct their errors ; being Scottish it does sometimes mildly irk me when software corrects my correct British English spelling into American English , which is sometimes different .

While I try to spell and punctuate my own scribblings to a reasonable standard , I tend not to go around picking on the writing of others , unless it is a post written entirely in ' txt spk ' or otherwise so poorly punctuated or misspelled that it is very difficult or tiring to read ; even then I tend to pause to consider whether the writer is a non native speaker or might have learning difficulties .

As we say here in Scotland : Wha's like us ?
 
Does it hurt ?

In fact it's useful to people ( in business, etc. ) to develop their writing skills and learn to get things right.

It shouldn't bother you. Look on it as positive that someone out there cares enough about your writing to not only read it, nut [sic] analyze it in detail.

And it keeps these dictionary nuts off the streets. :-)
Ahem...

Regards, Mike
--
Wait and see...
 
Saturday I was flagged for 'hole' instead 'whole', guilty, lack of coffee, & I'm OK with 'give the other guy hell' over stupid. Today I was flagged for placing a space before a coma. Really? My critic had nothing to say as to the thread. I think that's rude at least to the OP. P.S. I hope I haven't made any mistakes, 3 strikes & your out.
You're honestly blaming your errors on the need for coffee? You are an English speaker from a civilised English-speaking country which theoretically offers a decent educational system, and you should be able to do better. Your complaint, above, contains at least 3 or 4 spelling or grammatical errors. Fire up your Mr Coffee machine; use a strong blend.
 
I , for one , have always placed spaces between words and punctuation marks ( with the exception of apostrophes used to indicate abbreviation or possession ) : that being the way we were taught at school , and having had it drummed into us by our tutor that it was one of the hallmarks of a professional typist .
You, for one, and your teacher, for at least one more, are completely wrong. There should never be a space before any punctuation mark. I'm not aware of any language in which your so-called professional hallmark is true, and I'm fluent in six.
 
I , for one , have always placed spaces between words and punctuation marks ( with the exception of apostrophes used to indicate abbreviation or possession ) : that being the way we were taught at school , and having had it drummed into us by our tutor that it was one of the hallmarks of a professional typist .

These days it would seem that poor spelling , bad or no punctuation and that grammar is an abbreviation for grandmother all seem commonplace ! Perhaps this is in some way due to the computer age with many becoming reliant on software to correct their errors ; being Scottish it does sometimes mildly irk me when software corrects my correct British English spelling into American English , which is sometimes different .

While I try to spell and punctuate my own scribblings to a reasonable standard , I tend not to go around picking on the writing of others , unless it is a post written entirely in ' txt spk ' or otherwise so poorly punctuated or misspelled that it is very difficult or tiring to read ; even then I tend to pause to consider whether the writer is a non native speaker or might have learning difficulties .

As we say here in Scotland : Wha's like us ?
 
Saturday I was flagged for 'hole' instead 'whole', guilty, lack of coffee, & I'm OK with 'give the other guy hell' over stupid. Today I was flagged for placing a space before a coma. Really? My critic had nothing to say as to the thread. I think that's rude at least to the OP. P.S. I hope I haven't made any mistakes, 3 strikes & your out.
Those individuals who speak English as a first language but cannot complete basic sentences and paragraphs without numerous grammatical mistakes usually do not have anything useful to add to a discussion. If a person can't be bothered to type properly why should I be bothered to pay them any mind?

However, some posters care about other people more than I do and because of that feel it worthwhile to help them improve themselves. I guess I wouldn't start a thread complaining about people who care. But hey, that's just me.
 
Why grammar police? Some people have nothing else to add, and they're always looking for mistakes. You complete them. If they were the least bit courteous, they'd express their gratitude at the very least.
 
I have run fora, both as a moderator and as a university lecturer. One of the rules for flow is to stay on topic. Posts about grammatical and spelling errors are not topical. If the errors impart ambiguity, then it is sensible, maybe even ethical and courteous, to seek clarification for the sake of other learners or people merely looking-on. That can be done out in the open. When I think I can correct someone's facts or grammar/spelling, especially in a non-learning environment such as these types of fora, I do it via PM (private message). That way, I don't call out and diminish those whose error I have seen, and I don't appear to aggrandize myself in the process.
 
Ize wrote 5 boocks thats selz on Amazon so Ize knows the importents of good gramer and spellin.

More seriously than the preceding line, mistake proof writing takes time as the editors of my books have told me not to mention my English teacher wife. I think that writing in a forum is generally done too fast because we all want to move on to a new topic or thread. We also have to recognize that not everyone has good writing skills. It’s a shame but a fact. Still I have learned a good bit here from people who do not spell well, understand proper punctuation, or organize their messages well. However the content is frequently informative.

A few months ago on another forum website I read a denunciation of an OP’s writing. The critic was B grade writer. The OP was a D grade. Turned out that the OP was from eastern Europe and had only been speaking and writing English for a few years. When the OP pointed that out, the critic failed to apologize. As far as he was concerned one should not write in a foreign language unless proficient at it. The guy should win the critical dork award. We need a little more tolerance from many more people and lot more more tolerance from a very few more people.--

Richard Weisgrau
www.drawnwithlight.com
www.show-my-house.com
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top