Where to print photos. Wal-Mart vs Target. Glossy vs Matte.

thomasw333

Leading Member
Messages
512
Solutions
2
Reaction score
80
Location
Myrtle Beach, SC, US
My pictures are jpeg fine, from my Canon SX50HS. They are put into Microsoft Photo Gallery and I use auto-correct and they usually look great and I consider them ready to print. Today I went to Wal-mart and printed some 4x6 photos. I printed all the pics glossy. I let the HP machines (that they use) do there own auto correcting on top of my auto-corrected pics from Microsoft Photo Gallery. The I printed 2 more pictures without doing the auto correct. To me the pictures that I corrected in Microsoft look better, HP made the pics look worse. But then again they had already been auto-corrected on my laptop. Then i printed 2 pics in matte, I printed them with my original auto-correct settings and with HP settings. Again my pics from Microsoft Auto-correct looked better. And the Matte pics looked so much better. So I would say if you print and Wal-Mart, use your own settings and print Matte. The HP machines there use HP Vivid Photo Paper.

Then I went to Target and used there Kodak Machines. I printed all of the same pictures, they have no option for matte that I could see, so the pictures are glossy. They did not have any option for auto-correct. They are printed on Kodak XTRALIFE paper, and they looked really good, better than anything from Wal-Mart. So I guess I will be printing from Target. But they was one problem with Target, Two of the pictures had been cut-off slightly more than the ones from Wal-mart. I am talking about an 1/8th of an inch from the bottom. Also one of the pictures had a tiny piece of string fall onto it, and it is imbedded in the pic.

Wal-mart has a better set-up in that they give you a ticket to scan, and when you pics are done you can open a sliding door and your pictures fall down from the machine into the tray, basically the pictures are printed inside of a machine, they are protected. The Kodak machines on the other hand, are very open, the pics pop out one at a time right there by your knees into a tray, it seems to me that dust is more likely to get into the printer, also no security so you have to wait for your pics or someone could take them, when I was at Target today the first machine did have somebody's pictures sitting there for anyone to see or take. Target is nice though if you ask for an envolpe they have very study posterboard like ones to give you in several different sizes, at Wal-Mart you have to hold your pictures there is no envelopes. And finally one of my black and whites had a very obvious line going through the top of the pic about 1/3 of the way down, it looks like the printer did not print a few lies right in that area.

I printed 14 pictures, some B&W some full color. At the end of the day I like the colors I get from Target so I guess I will go there. I am also waiting from some pics from Mpix.com, but with shipping it is more money and I like getting my pictures right away, but I will add a note here when I get the pictures from them, I am hoping they will be here by Friday. From Mpix, I uploaded the same pictures and told them they could do there technician based auto-correction. I am hoping the pictures look even better and the paper is even nicer because I will pay a little more and wait if they look that much better.

So anyone else have any experience with photo kiosks? What do you do what do you use, who orders online etc...
 
Just found this at Kodak.com In the FAQ section. Kodak auto-corrects your pictures no matter what. Unfortunately I cannot copy and paste into this text box I do not know why. Also at Kodak and HP Kiosks they ask you to verify that you are not printing out copy right images. I said no because I am not, and no one said anything at Target when I was checking out, but at Wal-Mart the guy said he had to look at my pictures to make sure they were not copy righted of professionally done. I was thinking wtf, I said they were mine, he said "ok then if you do not want me to see them you have to sign this waiver," thats fine I signed the waiver. I don't want some guy at Wal-mart bending and putting finger-prints on my pics, I just do not trust that he will be careful with them. I don't mind signing a waiver I just think it is funny that I already "e-sign" the waiver at the kiosks but Wal-Mart is really serious about copy right photos, and they want to see your pics. I am also thinking how does he know if they are pro pics or not. What is he going to say, "this pic is too good you didn't take it," or "this pic is a pro pic, even if you took it, you cannot print it here." I don't know anyone else have any ideas?
 
thomasw333 wrote:

My pictures are jpeg fine, from my Canon SX50HS. They are put into Microsoft Photo Gallery and I use auto-correct and they usually look great and I consider them ready to print. Today I went to Wal-mart and printed some 4x6 photos. I printed all the pics glossy. I let the HP machines (that they use) do there own auto correcting on top of my auto-corrected pics from Microsoft Photo Gallery. The I printed 2 more pictures without doing the auto correct. To me the pictures that I corrected in Microsoft look better, HP made the pics look worse. But then again they had already been auto-corrected on my laptop. Then i printed 2 pics in matte, I printed them with my original auto-correct settings and with HP settings. Again my pics from Microsoft Auto-correct looked better. And the Matte pics looked so much better. So I would say if you print and Wal-Mart, use your own settings and print Matte. The HP machines there use HP Vivid Photo Paper.

Then I went to Target and used there Kodak Machines. I printed all of the same pictures, they have no option for matte that I could see, so the pictures are glossy. They did not have any option for auto-correct. They are printed on Kodak XTRALIFE paper, and they looked really good, better than anything from Wal-Mart. So I guess I will be printing from Target. But they was one problem with Target, Two of the pictures had been cut-off slightly more than the ones from Wal-mart. I am talking about an 1/8th of an inch from the bottom. Also one of the pictures had a tiny piece of string fall onto it, and it is imbedded in the pic.

Wal-mart has a better set-up in that they give you a ticket to scan, and when you pics are done you can open a sliding door and your pictures fall down from the machine into the tray, basically the pictures are printed inside of a machine, they are protected. The Kodak machines on the other hand, are very open, the pics pop out one at a time right there by your knees into a tray, it seems to me that dust is more likely to get into the printer, also no security so you have to wait for your pics or someone could take them, when I was at Target today the first machine did have somebody's pictures sitting there for anyone to see or take. Target is nice though if you ask for an envolpe they have very study posterboard like ones to give you in several different sizes, at Wal-Mart you have to hold your pictures there is no envelopes. And finally one of my black and whites had a very obvious line going through the top of the pic about 1/3 of the way down, it looks like the printer did not print a few lies right in that area.

I printed 14 pictures, some B&W some full color. At the end of the day I like the colors I get from Target so I guess I will go there. I am also waiting from some pics from Mpix.com, but with shipping it is more money and I like getting my pictures right away, but I will add a note here when I get the pictures from them, I am hoping they will be here by Friday. From Mpix, I uploaded the same pictures and told them they could do there technician based auto-correction. I am hoping the pictures look even better and the paper is even nicer because I will pay a little more and wait if they look that much better.

So anyone else have any experience with photo kiosks? What do you do what do you use, who orders online etc...
I've uploaded photos to walmart for printing. easy pick up and the pics looked good.
 
thomasw333 wrote:

But they was one problem with Target, Two of the pictures had been cut-off slightly more than the ones from Wal-mart. I am talking about an 1/8th of an inch from the bottom.
If the aspect ratio of your camera is different from the aspect ratio of the prints, you may want to prepare "print copies" of your photos (with the same aspect ratio as prints) at home before going to a kiosk. That way, you can control the composition rather than leaving it up to a machine.
 
thomasw333 wrote:

at Wal-Mart the guy said he had to look at my pictures to make sure they were not copy righted of professionally done. I was thinking wtf, I said they were mine, he said "ok then if you do not want me to see them you have to sign this waiver,"
Those types of policies are an incoherent mess:

1. They assume that professional photos are copyrighted, and that yours aren't. That's not how copyright works. Photos that you take are automatically copyrighted, too. So why isn't the store concerned about protecting your copyrights? If their policies are based on principle, why would they want to allow your photos to be infringed by any John or Jane Doe?

2. Just because a picture was taken by a professional photographer or has an explicit copyright notice does not automatically mean that you have no rights to copy it. For instance, if you had a 25-year-old daughter and you were trying to copy a school photo taken when she was 8, it would be a hard case to make that this was not Fair Use. But a store that recognized the photo as being a school photo would refuse service, presumptively labeling you as a wannabe infringer. While a store can refuse service without valid justification, it's not a good way to treat customers.

3. Markings on photo paper can be misleading. I have some Epson Professional Inkjet paper that I got because I like the quality of the output on it. This paper says on the back something to the effect "Professional photograph. Do not duplicate." The only trouble is, that notice doesn't speak for me. When I print family photos on that paper, I have no objection to family members making more copies for non-commercial personal use.

4. It is not a store's job to police you, or to presume that you are an infringer.

5. These same stores that want to police your copying of photos are more than happy to sell you things like hunting knives that can be used for stabbing people, strong ropes that can be used for strangling them, noxious chemicals that can be used for poisoning them, and other items that could be deadly when in the hands of a murderer. The stores also sell accessories for cars, like the ones bank robbers use to make getaways. I guess that as you step over the fresh pool of the latest victim's blood, you can comfort yourself knowing that the photo lab didn't let you make that copy of your dear, departed mother's wedding photo. :-)
 
Tom_N wrote:
thomasw333 wrote:

But they was one problem with Target, Two of the pictures had been cut-off slightly more than the ones from Wal-mart. I am talking about an 1/8th of an inch from the bottom.
If the aspect ratio of your camera is different from the aspect ratio of the prints, you may want to prepare "print copies" of your photos (with the same aspect ratio as prints) at home before going to a kiosk. That way, you can control the composition rather than leaving it up to a machine.
Yeah I already had my prints made out at 4x6, but the machine had a glitch and cut off a tiny bit of at least one picture, a tiny bit from the bottom.
 
jess shudup wrote:

Which one has a McDonalds nearby?

(matte goes better with egg mcmuffin, glossy with big mac).

Definitely choices to make.

;)
I guess you do not make prints, too bad.
 
I found that the only way to consistantly get prints that I'm happy with is to print them myself. I use a relatively inexpensive HP printer that I'm very happy with. I tried Walgreens, CVS, Target, and a couple of independents and found that they were sometimes good and sometimes awful.



I print glossy on HP paper. For 4x6 I use Advance Paper, but for 8x10 I use Premium Plus Paper.
 
Last edited:
Thomasw333 what a joker are.

4x6 prints, Wal-Mart vs Target, Glossy vs Matte, and you talking them about.

Better to choice between Big Mac or Egg McMuffin, are equally so good.
 
Ok, finally got the pics from mpix.com. I do not have any pics with me to compare, but at first glance they look about the same as the Kodak prints I get from Target. The prints from Mpix.com are printed on Fujifilm, FujiColor Professional Paper. I will have to go home and look at some pics side by side to see if these are any better, but I do not think so. So for me it seems that going to Target and gettting my prints immediately is the best option. They are cheaper at Target since I do not have to pay for shipping, and I get them right then.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top