Don't take photos of oil storage tanks

Thanks Mike, that makes me feel better.
I did not feel my rights were infringed upon in any way, and if
they are this thorough on all reports, they are going to be
successful in catching bad guys.

M.
I had to show my receipts for my new 1D, show them the photos--to
exif data confirmed I was where I said I was--and otherwise prove I
was an artist and not someone to worry about.
You said that you HAD to show them receipts for your new camera,
which I think needs a little clarification. Did they force you to
produce it or in any other way coerce you? What would have happened
if you said "Sorry, but respectfully that's none of your business,
so get off my property." ?

I have a feeling the conversation went more like this:
MIB: "Oh you got a new camera? I'm sorry to ask, but would you mind
showing us the receipt?"
Mike: "Oh no problem, I have nothing to hide."

If that's the case, it's unfair to the FBI and misrepresentative to
imply that they compelled you to do something, as this brings up
some serious constitutional issues. However, if they threatened you
and said that you would be hauled to Camp X-Ray if your story
didn't check out, then I'd say that would be crisis.

If it was the case that they just asked and you complied
willinging, then yes, it's still a somewhat chilling reminder of
the state of the world, but IMO it speaks more to admirable
dilligence than to police state.
--
1D, Tokina 28-80 2.8, 28-105USM, 50 1.8
 
Funny thing is--I needed to get out the receipt anyway because today the camera is going to canon for a piece of dust on the sonsor that absolutely is not coming off...M.
Where do you live? Did you ever see the World Trade Center site
after the attack? Maybe you should have. Please ask the families
of those victims if they would support your foolish position.

Your whole approach to what the FBI is doing is childish and very
lame. I would love to be a fly on the wall when you started to
obstruct them. I would love to see you getting arrested and have
you spend a night or two in jail. I would love to see your face
when you get the bill for your lawyer. Just because you wanted to
be an obstinate fool.

JL
If it happened to you, you would cooperate with the FBI and only if
you were and a_hole to them would you end up in jail.
I doubt I would dig through my papers looking for a camera receipt
for them unless they had a warrant. They would have no choice but
to arrest me since they would have no way of determining that I'm
not a terrorist.
--
1D, Tokina 28-80 2.8, 28-105USM, 50 1.8
 
See, the FBI actually helped you.

JL
Where do you live? Did you ever see the World Trade Center site
after the attack? Maybe you should have. Please ask the families
of those victims if they would support your foolish position.

Your whole approach to what the FBI is doing is childish and very
lame. I would love to be a fly on the wall when you started to
obstruct them. I would love to see you getting arrested and have
you spend a night or two in jail. I would love to see your face
when you get the bill for your lawyer. Just because you wanted to
be an obstinate fool.

JL
If it happened to you, you would cooperate with the FBI and only if
you were and a_hole to them would you end up in jail.
I doubt I would dig through my papers looking for a camera receipt
for them unless they had a warrant. They would have no choice but
to arrest me since they would have no way of determining that I'm
not a terrorist.
--
1D, Tokina 28-80 2.8, 28-105USM, 50 1.8
--
Jonathan Lefcourt
Some winter pics taken in NY State
http://www.pbase.com/jlefcourt/some_winter_shots&page=all
 
because I'm GLAD Mike had a knock on the door from the feds!

I live in the oil capital city of the US, where petroleum & chemical refineries/storage/processing facilities & headquarters built this city. Any industrial accident, or more imporantly terrorist sabotage, can bring loss of life, become a local environmental disaster, and have financial implications felt throughout the country, and world. I have been to most of these facilities (for my business), and even in non-war times the refinery plant security is equal to or even exceeds government standards used at DOD and DOE facilities across the nation. How do I know?.... over 15 years as a contractor for nasa and other spook sites requiring security clearances.

Cameras are not allowed in these oil & chemical facilities, nor on any of the premises or property, period. I routinely have my briefcase and car checked every single time I enter a facility. Nobody gains access thru the gates unless the folks you're visiting come & meet you ... and this occurs during non-war times. And I'm glad.... just imagine the consequences some nitwit can create.

I'm pleasantly suprised the plant security contacted the FBI & they followed thru. Excellent security, I can only hope they do the same in my hometown. The US has experienced horrific terrorist attacks, with very recent threats of homeland terrorism from both Iraq & al Qaeda. An ounce of prevention.....

Excuse my long & rambling post, just utilizing my FREEDOM our boys are fighting for, and realize it can not be taken for granted.
 
I did not feel my rights were infringed upon in any way, and if
they are this thorough on all reports, they are going to be
successful in catching bad guys.
Actually, they won't if they continue to waste time in this way. I'm shocked by how many photographers seem to think that photographing industrial sights is 'suspicious' activity. There's an entire genre of such photography.
 
You think visiting a museum will help us fight terrorism?

Yes, because that way stupid FBI agents won't waste time and hassle someone with twenty pounds of medium and/or large format equipment, who is a citizen, who is not trying to conceal his or her activity, and who is obviously not a member of any ethnic group that may originate from a country of concern. By your logic our best and brightest should be shaking down homeless people who panhandle near Federal buildings because they obviously can observe the building all day, which is certainly suspicious. Why would someone want to be across from a Federal building all day? Sounds very suspicious. And what about the dune buggy crowd heading toward those power lines and gas lines on BLM land in the Southwest during the weekends? Or the thousands of hikers in the San Gabriel mountains outside of Los Angeles? Jee, you can hike across some huge gas lines going into Los Angeles through the mountains. Better put the FBI on all the trail heads as well.
 
Thanks for the feedback. Now I'm curious. I'll check it out.

Ever see the movie, "Seige"? I hope "in the interests of national security" we don't end up with something like that kind of scenario. I wish I could remember the quote I read shortly after 9/11 – something about giving up our freedom for security – and being neither free nor secure in the long run.
If you value your freedom and national security, go ahead and take
whatever pictures you want. If the police or FBI show up asking
questions, be polite and as cooperative as you deem necessary and
convenient. Just DON'T be scared away from doing something that you
have a right to do.
Knock, knock.

I hope not.
Last night, 2 FBI agents came to my house to discuss photos I was
taking of the oil storage tanks near my house. They are quite
beautiful, painted a bright white which stands out from the rest of
this residential area.

It seems like there is a security risk for photographing things
like this. These officers were very serious. Definitely not
people to joke around with. They mentioned having to investigate
other photographers who take pics of birds because there was a
controversial site in the distance.

I had to show my receipts for my new 1D, show them the photos--to
exif data confirmed I was where I said I was--and otherwise prove I
was an artist and not someone to worry about.

Interesting and scary. M.
--
1D, Tokina 28-80 2.8, 28-105USM, 50 1.8
--
Tom
Photography – you gotta love it. All kinds of flavors and enough
for everyone. :-)
--
Tom
Photography – you gotta love it. All kinds of flavors and enough
for everyone. :-)
 
And there's an entire genre of enthusiasts who design and make fireworks. So I guess it'd be silly for the FBI to be investigating folks ordering quantities of explosives-making materials.

Nothing personal, and yes the above is pretty silly, but your argument strikes me the same way. It's like you're saying that "well, there's a bunch of folks who do this all the time, so there's no point in ever checking up on someone who appears like they might possibly be doing that same thing."

-- Lew
Actually, they won't if they continue to waste time in this way.
I'm shocked by how many photographers seem to think that
photographing industrial sights is 'suspicious' activity. There's
an entire genre of such photography.
--
Any DSLR beats unexposed film.
 
However, I've decided that would probably not be a wise thing to be
doing right now. :)
Sounds like the terrorists have already beaten you....
Umm... no. If it sounds that way you're not listening very well.
What am I not hearing? The terrorists want to take away freedoms like taking pictures, including pictures of oil drums, airplanes whatever.

Now it seems they have succeded because you are too intimidated to take pictures of things you want to, for fear of being a suspect.
That to me sounds like the terrorists have won.
Any DSLR beats unexposed film.
 
And there's an entire genre of enthusiasts who design and make fireworks. So I guess it'd be silly for the FBI to be investigating folks ordering quantities of explosives-making materials.

Lew,

If it's legal in their state to make home-manufactured fireworks then what's the problem? And your argument is a straw man argument, te are tight controls on explosive materials in the U.S. Even large quantities of nitrogen fertilizer are regulated. So where exactly do these enthusiasts order mass quantities of black powder? Please enlighten me.
 
Oh I see now, all is becoming clear, the Iraqi's must be our enemies because they live in the middle east, and so do some folks from Al Queida (don't get much more concrete than that!) and they must have chemical weapons that they are going to give to their middle eastern buddies because a 12 year old wrote a report on it!!!

I am waiting for the news to show the "chemical weapons" whilst they display a picture of a bottle of Toilet duck next to Saddam Husseins presidential toilet.

What a bunch of sheep some people are to believe this very poor propaganda show.

"They are the enemy because our dumb president told us they are...."

and remember...

"Please don't burn your oil fields...please? because my buddy Chainey and his old work buddies want to come into Iraq and tap all that lovely oil!!"
Which regime? I am easily confused and can't keep up with who Bush
points the finger at from one day to the next.
--
Canon 1D
 
I guess you cannot read very well. Please read his original and subsequent posts. The FBI did not "catch" him in the act fool. Please read the posts before you post your nonsense.

JL
You think visiting a museum will help us fight terrorism?

Yes, because that way stupid FBI agents won't waste time and hassle
someone with twenty pounds of medium and/or large format equipment,
who is a citizen, who is not trying to conceal his or her activity,
and who is obviously not a member of any ethnic group that may
originate from a country of concern. By your logic our best and
brightest should be shaking down homeless people who panhandle near
Federal buildings because they obviously can observe the building
all day, which is certainly suspicious. Why would someone want to
be across from a Federal building all day? Sounds very suspicious.
And what about the dune buggy crowd heading toward those power
lines and gas lines on BLM land in the Southwest during the
weekends? Or the thousands of hikers in the San Gabriel mountains
outside of Los Angeles? Jee, you can hike across some huge gas
lines going into Los Angeles through the mountains. Better put the
FBI on all the trail heads as well.
--
Jonathan Lefcourt
Some winter pics taken in NY State
http://www.pbase.com/jlefcourt/some_winter_shots&page=all
 
Please go back to the Sigma forum to spew your foolish nonsense. Genre or not, people and the police, think it is suspicious to photograph a site that might be a terror target. Please remove your head from the sand and take a good look around.
they are this thorough on all reports, they are going to be
successful in catching bad guys.
Actually, they won't if they continue to waste time in this way.
I'm shocked by how many photographers seem to think that
photographing industrial sights is 'suspicious' activity. There's
an entire genre of such photography.
--
Jonathan Lefcourt
Some winter pics taken in NY State
http://www.pbase.com/jlefcourt/some_winter_shots&page=all
 
because I'm GLAD Mike had a knock on the door from the feds!

I live in the oil capital city of the US, where petroleum &
chemical refineries/storage/processing facilities & headquarters
built this city. Any industrial accident, or more imporantly
terrorist sabotage, can bring loss of life, become a local
environmental disaster, and have financial implications felt
throughout the country, and world. I have been to most of these
facilities (for my business), and even in non-war times the
refinery plant security is equal to or even exceeds government
standards used at DOD and DOE facilities across the nation. How do
I know?.... over 15 years as a contractor for nasa and other spook
sites requiring security clearances.

Cameras are not allowed in these oil & chemical facilities, nor on
any of the premises or property, period. I routinely have my
briefcase and car checked every single time I enter a facility.
Nobody gains access thru the gates unless the folks you're visiting
come & meet you ... and this occurs during non-war times. And I'm
glad.... just imagine the consequences some nitwit can create.

I'm pleasantly suprised the plant security contacted the FBI & they
followed thru. Excellent security, I can only hope they do the same
in my hometown. The US has experienced horrific terrorist attacks,
with very recent threats of homeland terrorism from both Iraq & al
Qaeda. An ounce of prevention.....

Excuse my long & rambling post, just utilizing my FREEDOM our boys
are fighting for, and realize it can not be taken for granted.
--
Jonathan Lefcourt
Some winter pics taken in NY State
http://www.pbase.com/jlefcourt/some_winter_shots&page=all
 
because I'm GLAD Mike had a knock on the door from the feds!

I live in the oil capital city of the US, where petroleum &
chemical refineries/storage/processing facilities & headquarters
built this city. Any industrial accident, or more imporantly
terrorist sabotage, can bring loss of life, become a local
environmental disaster, and have financial implications felt
throughout the country, and world. I have been to most of these
facilities (for my business), and even in non-war times the
refinery plant security is equal to or even exceeds government
standards used at DOD and DOE facilities across the nation. How do
I know?.... over 15 years as a contractor for nasa and other spook
sites requiring security clearances.

Cameras are not allowed in these oil & chemical facilities, nor on
any of the premises or property, period. I routinely have my
briefcase and car checked every single time I enter a facility.
Nobody gains access thru the gates unless the folks you're visiting
come & meet you ... and this occurs during non-war times. And I'm
glad.... just imagine the consequences some nitwit can create.

I'm pleasantly suprised the plant security contacted the FBI & they
followed thru. Excellent security, I can only hope they do the same
in my hometown. The US has experienced horrific terrorist attacks,
with very recent threats of homeland terrorism from both Iraq & al
Qaeda. An ounce of prevention.....

Excuse my long & rambling post, just utilizing my FREEDOM our boys
are fighting for, and realize it can not be taken for granted.
--
Jonathan Lefcourt
Some winter pics taken in NY State
http://www.pbase.com/jlefcourt/some_winter_shots&page=all
 
I guess you cannot read very well. Please read his original and
subsequent posts. The FBI did not "catch" him in the act fool.
Jonathan,

In case you're reading this (when you sign on as yourself), I just wanted to let you know that some ss has highjacked your account and is posting some rather embarrassing comments in your name.
 
You apparently read only my first paragraph and missed the second. It was very clearly and explicitly stated that it was a silly example.

What I don't understand is how you can go from the existance of a "genre" of photography involving photographing industrial sites to declaring that there's no possiblility that anyone photographic such sites might have ill intent.

-- Lew
And there's an entire genre of enthusiasts who design and make
fireworks. So I guess it'd be silly for the FBI to be investigating
folks ordering quantities of explosives-making materials.

Lew,

If it's legal in their state to make home-manufactured fireworks
then what's the problem? And your argument is a straw man argument,
te are tight controls on explosive materials in the U.S. Even large
quantities of nitrogen fertilizer are regulated. So where exactly
do these enthusiasts order mass quantities of black powder? Please
enlighten me.
--
Any DSLR beats unexposed film.
 
The US are now
gradually starting to learn what terrorism is really all about and
how it affects the public life.
How very true. It's also interesting watching the knee-jerk reaction.

The UK mainland has been under threat of terrorist attack for years (the IRA) and while there are security cordons in London it doesn't stop people taking pictures.

We've also now attracted the unecessary attention of world terrorists thanks to our participation in this unnecessary war. However, once again, it doesn't stop me from going to airfields, oil depots or other infrastructure and taking pictures. I live near an airfield and saw a plane spotter with camera and tele lens last week (it wasn't a Canon ;-)

It doesn't mean security is not in place - it just means that it's subtle and doesn't involve hassling people on bridges or calling on people at home to give them a hard time when any background check will show that they are unlikely to be a threat.

dd
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top