External HD enclosure choice

OwenG

Leading Member
Messages
588
Reaction score
1
Location
UK
Can anyone recommend a four bay external hard drive enclosure please. I have a number of old drives on the loose around my office and would like to gather them all up and have access to them at will. Will be used just for backup purposes only, Any connection eSATA, FW, USB will do.

Thanks
--
http://500px.com/oweng
 
My friend has a Sans Digital 4-bay eSATA enclosure that's almost silent and has given him good service for a few years now. They make USB 2.0 and 3.0 versions as well. You can get a USB 2.0 version without PCIe card for around $100.

--
'No matter where you go, there you are.'
 
Another vote for OWC. They are my go-to folks for drive enclosures. "Plug-and-play" vs. "plug-and-pray"...

Pardon my ignorance, but do multi-drive enclosures require identical size drives? I'm asking just in case the OP has varying sized drives...
 
Thanks all.

I like OWC but I have to pay import tax and their base unit is already quite expensive.

Had a look at IcyBox but ruled them out after reading quite a few negative reviews from users.

So have narrowed it down to either Sans Digital or StarTech. Amazon currently has a near 50% discount on the StarTech 4 bay Raid USB/FW/eSATA so tempted with that but the Sans Digital has USB 3.0 which would be nice to connect to my MBP retina.

Cheers
--
http://500px.com/oweng
 
I went this route a few years ago and almost immediately went back to separates. A few things to consider: Typically the multi-drive enclosure have fans. Mine, which was a brand mentioned in prior comments, was noisy. It's a lot simpler grabbing a single drive and take it wherever. Redundancy. I have well over 10 terrabytes of drive space and, over the years have had about 6 drives go down. 5 were failures with the enclosures (all were from a brand mentioned in prior comments). Flexibility. Singles are easier to stack, flip on their sides and package in available space. Multiway drives not only tend to have larger footprints but are a lot less flexible in space utilization. The downside of singles are all the cables and power supplies that are get piled in a heap and tangled up with eachother.
 
I went this route a few years ago and almost immediately went back to separates. A few things to consider: Typically the multi-drive enclosure have fans. Mine, which was a brand mentioned in prior comments, was noisy. It's a lot simpler grabbing a single drive and take it wherever. Redundancy. I have well over 10 terrabytes of drive space and, over the years have had about 6 drives go down. 5 were failures with the enclosures (all were from a brand mentioned in prior comments). Flexibility. Singles are easier to stack, flip on their sides and package in available space. Multiway drives not only tend to have larger footprints but are a lot less flexible in space utilization. The downside of singles are all the cables and power supplies that are get piled in a heap and tangled up with eachother.
Good feedback.

I have a friend who had multiple drives in a single enclosure, presumably to save money by avoiding multiple enclosures... One day the enclosure failed (presumably a bad chip...) and all her image files were unavailable until she could replace the enclosure. If she had kept her redundant data backups in separate enclosures she would have avoided a major inconvenience.

The new OWC MiniStack enclosures are worth a look.
 
I have a friend who had multiple drives in a single enclosure, presumably to save money by avoiding multiple enclosures... One day the enclosure failed (presumably a bad chip...) and all her image files were unavailable until she could replace the enclosure. If she had kept her redundant data backups in separate enclosures she would have avoided a major inconvenience.
Drobos have been pretty notorious for screwing people this way, since their data storage algorithm is proprietary. I think (not sure) that if you use a more standard RAID configuration, it's easier to recover the data? Anyone confirm?

Anyway, Drobos even got the best of Scott Kelby: "I'm done with Drobo."
http://scottkelby.com/2012/im-done-with-drobo/
Because for the fourth time one of my drobos is a brick.

Wait, are all the hard drives installed in my drobo still working? Yup. Can I access my photos? Nope. Not a one.
 
It wasn't a problem with the data on the drives. The enclosure itself failed so the data could not be accessed. Once the drives were installed in a new enclosure the data was fine.
 
Synology makes good external HD enclosures.

--
Regards,

Jeremy
 
I went this route a few years ago and almost immediately went back to separates. A few things to consider: Typically the multi-drive enclosure have fans. Mine, which was a brand mentioned in prior comments, was noisy. It's a lot simpler grabbing a single drive and take it wherever. Redundancy. I have well over 10 terrabytes of drive space and, over the years have had about 6 drives go down. 5 were failures with the enclosures (all were from a brand mentioned in prior comments). Flexibility. Singles are easier to stack, flip on their sides and package in available space. Multiway drives not only tend to have larger footprints but are a lot less flexible in space utilization. The downside of singles are all the cables and power supplies that are get piled in a heap and tangled up with eachother.
My experience pretty much exactly. Here's another reason: Footprint aside, quad enclosures are HEAVY and clunky. They immediately went out of the loop of enclosures I would sneaker-net around the floor. I ended up keeping an OWC dual enclosure and two OWC single ones (all bought as full external drives originally), and that's plenty for shuttling bare drives around into.

I had even gone so far as to mount two stacks of bare drives in CoolerMaster type enclosures with no electronics, open backed with the idea of just moving a drive adapter to each one as needed. Abandoned that after a month. It was like moving an elephant from the closet to the desk and back every night. And the adapters were always being finicky.

I went back to unattached bare drives, smaller OWC enclosures and FW800 and have been much happier. Naturally if one desires RAID or etc. that's different, but I don't.
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top