*** Mini Challenge 247: Follow the rules! ***

ParietalPenguin

Senior Member
Messages
3,465
Solutions
1
Reaction score
377
Location
St Louis, US
Welcome to MC 247. The topic for this challenge is "Following the Rules."

Often, we're told in photography to go ahead and 'break the rules.' In order to do this though, you have to know what the rules are. What I'm looking for in this challenge, is a photo that illustrates one (or more) rules of photography. As I have a pretty good sense of humor, a shot that creatively illustrates what not to do is also acceptable (e.g. the tree growing out of grandma's head!)
If you're a little shaky on the "rules," here are some sites for ideas:

http://www.photographymad.com/pages/view/10-top-photography-composition-rules

http://www.blackcatphotoproducts.com/rules_of_thumb.html

http://gawno.com/2009/05/78-photography-rules/

http://www.advancedphotography.net/breaking-rules-photography-break-rules/

MC 247 starts now and ends on Thursday, December 15th, at 8pm CST.

RULES

NEW RULE JUST FOR THIS CHALLENGE: You must state the rule you are illustrating or the photo will not be included for judging! (See examples to follow.)

1) Enter up to 3 photos from any camera taken at any time. Let us know about equipment, settings and processing if you like.

2) The winner chooses the next mini challenge theme and selects the next winner and so on...

3) Please post your entries by replying to this original post rather than under someone else’s post - and change the subject line to ‘My entry’ or ‘Entry Number1’ or something like that to separate your picture posts from comments that someone may make about your post.

4) In the spirit of the previous challenge, I would like to nominate the previous host to take over my role in the event that I am unable to continue. The nomination carries an instant second, and the rules close out further nominations!

5) The challenge is open immediately, and will close for entries and exhibitions on Thursday, December 15th at 8 pm CST. Results will be posted asap.

6) As usual, exhibition entries are encouraged if you have interesting images to share beyond your three entries, or should you feel you are not able to host the challenge in the event that you win.

7) All entrants should check the results of the challenge and be ready to jump in with the next competition if they are the winner.

8) PLEASE feel free to make as many comments as possible. This adds to the fun and keeps people coming back.

--



Karen
 
"Dew Drop"
Rule of Thirds



"Watching Big Red"
Another Rule of Thirds



"Glacier Bay"
Rule: don't put the horizon in the center of the shot



"Perigee Moon"

HALF MOONEY 8- Use shutter speed of 1/ISO setting and an aperture of 8 for pictures of a half moon



"Old Yellow"
Rule #1: Diagonals are attractive
Rule #2: Having all 3 primary colors in a shot is a winner



"Primary Peppers"
Rule: groups of 3 things are desirable



"Young Photographers"

Rule: if you have a grouping of 2 items, have them close together to avoid presenting a split interest



"Hold on Tight"
Rule #1: Leading lines are good

Rule #2: English readers (and other Western languages) read from left to right; we also "read" pictures from left to right: in this shot, the coaster leads you into the shot - sometimes flipping a picture can help lead you into it instead of leading you out

"The One That Got Away"
Rule #1: "S" curves are attractive and lead you into a shot

Rule #2: Strong contrast in B&W images is desirable, with good whites and good blacks

"Blue Skies"
Rule: Fill the frame
(Okay, this is an example of a poor example!)



(I had this all typed in, then the site stopped working just as I tried to post it, so I had to start all over again!)
--



Karen
 
Great topic, Karen.

This one has both a "rule" and a "strength element"



--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
Following one and breaking another:



--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
At least three rules/strength elements:



--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
Oh, Jerry! This is so cute! I (naturally) love penguins and puffins run a close second. The colors are so vivid on this and you had great timing. Nicely done!
--



Karen
 
This shot is perfect for the challenge! Good illustration of the rule of thirds and keeping your horizon out of the center. The leading lines of the sand draw your eye right in.

Jerry, if you're able to edit once you see this, could you give a little more info about your rules? I thought this could help beginners reading through, to see the rule stated (e.g. "Rule of Thirds" or "Leading Lines") and a picture illustrating it.
Thank you!
--



Karen
 
Awesome shot! I hope to be able to see this sometime (and hope even more to have my camera ready!) This is a great capture, both in timing and beautiful color.
--



Karen
 
Hello Karen, very interesting theme.

This Photo is called Grand....

High contrast monotone, eliminate distracting backgrounds, strong diagonal, give subjects a space to look into, get in close, overlapping subjects, give it a title.

[On a friend's monitor the boy's hair looks overexposed, but it looks fine on mine and I have left it as original]



--
http://www.pbase/ndh00
 
this image demonstrates the rule of thirds in that the horizon is on or close to the upper thrids line of the frame, making the image roughly 2/3 land/water and 1/3 sky. Also, the lines in the sand make for very strong leading lines - leading the eye into the picture.

--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
In this one, I'm breaking the "rule" that says the horizon should generally not be placed in the middle of the frame, but following the rule of thirds by placing the whale on the left thirds line.
--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
In this shot, the far left bird is close to the upper left thirds intersection, the three birds are aligned on a diagonal (a strength element) and it's recommended that, when photographing multiple subjects, odd numbers seem to work better then even numbers of them - in this case, three.
--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
and demonstrating so many "strength elements" as you point out.

The child's hair looks perfect on my LCD screen - and I have it at max brightness.
--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
Love the perspective on this shot, Marti! I also love the image I have in my head of you laying sprawled on the ice to get it (although I know probably it was only the camera! :) )
--



Karen
 
I don't have an entry but I have looked at the amazing entries so far and I am learning so much I just wanted to say thank you Karen.
Diane
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top