E5 or K5

Hi Adam,

In my opinion, your question is depended on which lenses you want to use, not a choice between E-5 or K-5.

Olympus has amazing "zoom lenses" line up. The SHG and HG lenes are all outstanding and hard to beat.

Pentax has those light weight, well-built, outstanding image quality prime lenses.

I like Zuiko lenses rather than Pentax lenses, but I like K-5 more than E-5.

P.S. I would not sugget you to use K-5 with DA*16-50mm. If you really want to try K-5, please use 31mm, 43mm, and DA*50-135mm.

Mark
 
K5

Handled it and played with it. Nice camera. A little smaller and lighter than my E-3, with almost as good a viewfinder.

But it not feel to be nearly as well-built or solid-feeling as either my E-1 or my E-3, and the controls, while pretty well located, also suggested (even) more trouble to handle with (real) gloves on than the E-3. The E-1 was/is a champion in this regard.

With lenses it is just no contest! IMHO, fixed focal length lenses have mostly become special-purpose optics: fisheyes, pancakes, macros, very fast teles, and even here, my 50f2 macro and 150f2 are superb lenses, and my 25mm pancake and 8mm FE are certainly more than adequate. And the Zuiko zooms are perhaps the strongest argument for choosing Olympus. Even the store manager, who carries mainly Pentax and Nikon, raved about the quality of a Zuko 11-22 he'd tried. He stated flat out that o that it and the 12-60 and 50-200 are a combination of IQ, brightness, useful range, close-focusing, relative compactness and light weight and weather sealing and price that no other brand could quite match.

The Nikon D7000 is an impressive camera and a real bargain for its feature-set, though, it, too doesn't feel quite as robust. And I've owned Nikon and know that there is some truly great Nikon glass. But one real try of the heft and bulk of the latest incarnation of the classic Nikon 70-200, and a look at the price, and then at the range of lenses I'd need to match my Zuiko outfit, and, again, their total size and weight and price have more or less eliminated that option for me.

I really wish that Olympus had had - or committed - the resources to do a fair bit more with the E-5. Heck, I wish they'd found a way to marry the E-3 pentaprism and swivel LCD with an E-1-sized body. But as a rugged, portable, weather-proof system with excellent IQ in most situations, it still appears to give the best bang for the buck even for those who haven't already bought into the system,

--
erichK
saskatoon, canada

http://erichk.zenfolio.com/

http://www.fototime.com/inv/7F3D846BCD301F3

underwater photos:
http://www.scubaboard.com/gallery/showgallery.php/cat/500/ppuser/5567
 
Good Morning!
It could be that the OP likes the ergonomics of the Pentax / Oly cameras better, or other "intangibles" or even some things not mentioned.
Really? And what actually should "better" ergonomics be? By the way I owned the E-1 and lots of Zuiko glasses...
For the D7000 combo - sorry, but neither the 18-200 nor the 18-105 are going to hold a candle to the 12-60 for IQ - they're going to get stomped. Yes, I actually own the 18-105 (I bought it as a separate lens even!), and it's a great little walkaround lens, but even my 14-54 II spanks it for IQ. The 12-60 will equal or beat my 14-54 II, meaning it's going to beat the 18-105.
And your logic is???

Olympus E-5: 1699 Euros plus 12-60 f4.0 lens - 1099 Euros

NIKON D7000: 1099 Euros plus 24-70 f2.8 (!!!) lens - 1649 Euros

So, if I am calculating correct you have 50 Euros left for a 1 stop faster lens and actually I don't think that one if not the best Nikon zoom lens has less quality then the 12-60.

just my 2 cents,

AND NO - I don't want to start another of the thousands brand flame wars here...

Just stop all those fanboy-trashing and let the OP think about it...I don't want to convince anyone to buy any specific brand, but facts should stay facts...

Michael S.
 
..12-60 can be bought for E 899,- at the moment (and that's E40 more than I paid for it 3 years ago). 24-70 F2.8 is sold for E 1379 at the moment. I'm talking Euro's and in The Netherlands.

Beside the IQ it's the reach I like a lot about my 12-60SWD. What about a 24-70 F2.8 on a D7000?

Beside that, I think that jl_smith talked about the ergonomics of the Olympus E5 the OP COULD like better. He doesn't know...en neither do you. Jl_smith does not say anything about ergonomics actually being better.
Facts should stay facts...
 
..12-60 can be bought for E 899,- at the moment (and that's E40 more than I paid for it 3 years ago). 24-70 F2.8 is sold for E 1379 at the moment. I'm talking Euro's and in The Netherlands.
I have NOT, like you, sought for the cheapest available - BUT taken ONE (!) retailer I do know - and took ALL the prices from there...

And all your words are NOT facts, just speculation - missed the topic - sit down, grade 5, 6 or E minus or whatever you have in the Netherlands...

--
Michael S.
Austria/EUROPE; dpreview since 2001
NIKON NPS Member
(check equipment via profile)

http://www.pbase.com/bountyhunter
 
you have a great camera and you want to switch to the E-5.

You have to ask yourself why, what do you dislike about the Pentax so much and what you like about the Olympus so much.

The Pentax to me looks like a great camera.
And the E-5 isn't a nice camera?
That the E-5 isn't a nice camera?

The point is why someone already having a nice camera would switch systems. That's why I raised both questions: dislike for the Pentax and like for Olympus. These questions aren't sarcastic, these questions are for the OP to answer for himself to help clear this choice.
--
Raist3d (Photographer & Tools/Systems/Gui Games Developer)
Andreas Feininger (1906-1999) 'Photographers — idiots, of which there are
so many — say, “Oh, if only I had a Nikon or a Leica, I could make great
photographs.” That’s the dumbest thing I ever heard in my life. It’s
nothing but a matter of seeing, and thinking, and interest. That’s what
makes a good photograph.'
--
http://www.flickr.com/photos/zeegee/
--
Raist3d (Photographer & Tools/Systems/Gui Games Developer)
Andreas Feininger (1906-1999) 'Photographers — idiots, of which there are
so many — say, “Oh, if only I had a Nikon or a Leica, I could make great
photographs.” That’s the dumbest thing I ever heard in my life. It’s
nothing but a matter of seeing, and thinking, and interest. That’s what
makes a good photograph.'
 
Thnxs for your reaction.

What makes you think, I was looking for the cheapest option possible? Like you, I took a look on the site of one reputable camerashop here in the Netherlands (one I visit often and is close to where I live). No, not more...only one, and took all prices from there. Again, what makes you think I sought for the cheapest available?
These prices are facts and I can give you the adress.

My words are not facts, but speculation? I really would love you to tell me what words you mean; where is it NOT fact but speculation?
I'm merely a teacher, so I do not know about grades or anything:-)
Hope you can clarify.
Thank you.
 
don't tell me you "left the building"?
I'm eager to learn, and you might have some answers...
 
Not my level - just to say: YOU were the one who wrote what others thought the OP could, maybe, sometimes, under certain circumstances, from the point of view...have, possibly meant...

end of conversation - cause their is none, just blind following a brand.

I am not discussing (cause it's not possible, THAT's another fact) with fanboys...

Waste of time,

enjoy your coffee-shop...
don't tell me you "left the building"?
I'm eager to learn, and you might have some answers...
--
Michael S.
Austria/EUROPE; dpreview since 2001
NIKON NPS Member
(check equipment via profile)

http://www.pbase.com/bountyhunter
 
..that you do not seem able to answer 2 simple questions. Too difficult for you?There is no discussion to avoid; turning your back is a bit cheap though. Is that the way you are making your point?

I'm not a special Olympus fanboy, but maybe you can educate me by telling me where I went wrong?
Oops again 2 more questions....sorry Michael

Yours Sincerely
Mujana
p.s. What do coffeeshops have to do with photography?
Ow well, probably another question you cannot answer.
I do not expect you to answer....so don 't hesitate to ignore me:-)
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top