polarizers and D60 Metering

bbchucks

Forum Enthusiast
Messages
326
Reaction score
0
Location
NY, US
Hi, after my 2 week trip to Shanghai and Guilin with extensive uses of the Sigma 17-35mm on the D60 with polarizer filter, the 17-35mm is exhibiting weird METERING problems.

After a few sky shots (AF aimed at something with contrast) when i look through the viewfinder there is like another layer, the layer is a blackish with some black dots (very small). The AF won't focus on anything, even when aimed at buildings, or other things with contrast. The D60 metering is WAY OFF, eg. should be f5.0 1/200, it meters for f5.0 1/50.

i would have to do the followings to get the metering back to normal,
1. change to higher ISO
2. popup flash
3. change from 35mm to 17mm or visversa
4. remove lense, then reattach lense

once the picture is taken (under this slight blackish layer) the viewfinder suddenly turns back to normal without layer and the scene is brightly lit. The picture taken is WAY OVER exposed.

Weird enough, if i put on a 50mm prime, with polarizer filter and aim at the sky/clouds i can taken hundreds of pictures without the blackish layer/bad metering.

i can only think its the 17-35mm being bad, is that possible?

Not sure what other information i can provide here to anyone else who might seen this problem or know anything about this strange problem.

--
Thanks,
Chucks
 
I have the 16-35L and a circular polarizer B+W Slim and I don't have this kind of problem - I also use the the same polarizer on my 70-200L without problem. I know that a polarizer should be (have to?) circular to avoid any metering problem (AF could also be in trouble).

The interesting question here is that with your 50 prime you do not have a problem - so it is either a lens problem (but how) or your polarizer used with a wide lens (is it circular?) - also did you experience this problem at any zoom settings (17 - 24 - 28 - 35) ?

Francois

--
Francois
http://www.pbase.com/francoisroux
 
Sound like you are using a LINEAR polarizer rather than i CIRCULAR polarizer.

The linear versions does not work with modern cameras that has semitransparent mirrors.

The circular versions filter the incoming polarized light just like the linear version, but the de-polarizes it again before the light leaves the filter.

--
Kjeld Olesen
http://www.acapixus.dk
 
I'm using a CIRPolarizer, but after some tests, even without a filter in front of the lense the problem occurs sometimes now too.
Sound like you are using a LINEAR polarizer rather than i CIRCULAR> polarizer.> > The linear versions does not work with modern cameras that has> semitransparent mirrors.> > The circular versions filter the incoming polarized light just like> the linear version, but the de-polarizes it again before the light> leaves the filter.> > > --> Kjeld Olesen> http://www.acapixus.dk--Thanks,Chucks
 
I have the 16-35L and a circular polarizer B+W Slim and I don't> have this kind of problem - I also use the the same polarizer on my> 70-200L without problem. I know that a polarizer should be (have> to?) circular to avoid any metering problem (AF could also be in> trouble).> > The interesting question here is that with your 50 prime you do not> have a problem - so it is either a lens problem (but how) or your> polarizer used with a wide lens (is it circular?) - also did you> experience this problem at any zoom settings (17 - 24 - 28 - 35) ?> > Francois> > --> Francois> http://www.pbase.com/francoisroux--Thanks,Chucks
 
nope, Assuming this is the only lense that has this problem, It's the lense's fault. It probably needs repair.

As a test, When you are seeing the dark image in the viewfinder, look back through the front of the lense , If you see the diaphragm stopped down, then that would be your problem.

Doug
It sounds to me like the aperture diaphragm is
sticking closed.> > Doug
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top