Please put this in your window America

As another Canadaian, I apologize for the previous post by PB. It is totally understandable that not everybody agrees with US foreign policy, but I feel it is in very bad taste to flame Americans on their national day of mourning.

Best Regards
Toad
well ron you can save yourself the money, because i am an
australian. not everyone in the world is an american...

and yes i was talking about freedom of speech, which is supposedly
one of the US's greatest "achievements". i just think it's pretty
extreme to make it illegal to make a non-violent political protest
of burning a flag.

and FWIW i have never burnt any flag- but if i chose to do so, for
whatever reason, that should be my choice, not yours.
It's illegal to burn a flag? Sadly, people do that all the time,
and some Americans don't like that one bit at all.
Maybe in your country... but NOT mine! I'm an American and will
not tolerate such a dispicable act. There are many other ways to
show that you disagree with your countries policies. IMO, this is
tantamount to resorting to SHOCK VALUE to get attention. Has
nothing to do with expressing your opinion about the subject
matter. Simply the easiest way that I can think of to get a swift
kick in the butt out of the US of A!!!

Not my opinion, my belief!
I'm a Canadian and laugh at you. Bush Jr. already has advance
information that OBL will hit USA some nine months before 91101
(which, in reverse, is the US zip code for the World Trade Center).
Right after two jets crashed into WTC, Bush Jr. shipped every
member of the OBL's family out of USA using US government jets so
FBI couldn't interrogate them. Then Robert Mueller got blamed for
not doing enough.

And I thought that 91101 and Bush Jr. Cheney's work histories were
shocking enough.


Oh, by the way, US of A-hole is asking for World War III the moment
it attacks Iraq.
--
http://printerboyweb.net/G2
 
The reason the original post caused a problem IMO is that it
follows a trend often seen when SOME Americans post on the Internet
or Usenet. And that is they assume they are talking to Americans,
everyone knows it and whatever their knowledge of the outside
world, they post as if the world revolves around them.

What do I mean? Go and look at Usenet rec.photo.digital and a
large proportion of the posts are written from a solely American
perspective.

I find that arrogant.
This is one thing I have tried to be very conscious about.. when I post a US store like "You can get this at Best Buy (US)" I make sure I include the "US."

I know what you mean.
  • Raist
 
well ron you can save yourself the money, because i am an
australian. not everyone in the world is an american...

and yes i was talking about freedom of speech, which is supposedly
one of the US's greatest "achievements". i just think it's pretty
extreme to make it illegal to make a non-violent political protest
of burning a flag.

and FWIW i have never burnt any flag- but if i chose to do so, for
whatever reason, that should be my choice, not yours.

have a nice life!
Maybe in your country... but NOT mine! I'm an American and will
not tolerate such a dispicable act. There are many other ways to
show that you disagree with your countries policies. IMO, this is
tantamount to resorting to SHOCK VALUE to get attention. Has
nothing to do with expressing your opinion about the subject
matter. Simply the easiest way that I can think of to get a swift
kick in the butt out of the US of A!!!
As far as I understand, burning an American flag has upheld in court as constitutional. Personally I would not burn the American flag, but I do think that if we have to resort to censorship in the name of nationalism, then yes, I think Freedom Of Speech(TM) starts to end.

The fact someone burns a flag should be a topic of discussion and debate, the why's, etc. not of censorship.

And no, I don't see myself burning a flag (any).
  • Raist
Not my opinion, my belief!
Freedom of Speech? Freedom of Speech is alive and well but people
like you who burn the flag by choice is a punch in the face to the
many servicemembers like me currently serving our great nation
overseas (and at home). I suggest if you don't have respect for
the people that are fighting for your freedom and for what they
stand for and are protecting, then you move to a different country
(I would even buy you a one way ticket. -- Ron
--
John in Omaha
 
First, I agree with those that say this post isn't appropriate for this forum (although the original post that started it all is, most of the posts that have followed aren't). I also agree that burning a flag should be a freedom but for an american to do it is a stab in the back to all of the armed forces that fight all over the world every day to protect it (including our allies-I work for NATO so I am familiar with our ties to other nations). That was my only point. My post didn't apply to non-americans and I should have added that so I'm sorry if I offended anyone. --- Ron
well ron you can save yourself the money, because i am an
australian. not everyone in the world is an american...

and yes i was talking about freedom of speech, which is supposedly
one of the US's greatest "achievements". i just think it's pretty
extreme to make it illegal to make a non-violent political protest
of burning a flag.

and FWIW i have never burnt any flag- but if i chose to do so, for
whatever reason, that should be my choice, not yours.

have a nice life!
Maybe in your country... but NOT mine! I'm an American and will
not tolerate such a dispicable act. There are many other ways to
show that you disagree with your countries policies. IMO, this is
tantamount to resorting to SHOCK VALUE to get attention. Has
nothing to do with expressing your opinion about the subject
matter. Simply the easiest way that I can think of to get a swift
kick in the butt out of the US of A!!!
As far as I understand, burning an American flag has upheld in
court as constitutional. Personally I would not burn the American
flag, but I do think that if we have to resort to censorship in the
name of nationalism, then yes, I think Freedom Of Speech(TM) starts
to end.

The fact someone burns a flag should be a topic of discussion and
debate, the why's, etc. not of censorship.

And no, I don't see myself burning a flag (any).
  • Raist
Not my opinion, my belief!
Freedom of Speech? Freedom of Speech is alive and well but people
like you who burn the flag by choice is a punch in the face to the
many servicemembers like me currently serving our great nation
overseas (and at home). I suggest if you don't have respect for
the people that are fighting for your freedom and for what they
stand for and are protecting, then you move to a different country
(I would even buy you a one way ticket. -- Ron
--
John in Omaha
 
Humm.... reading your post I'm wondering what makes you write such statements toward the Americans in such generality in reaction to a single post? Why didn't you ignore the original post if it bothered you so much? You have a problem my friend to react in such a strong way. What is it? You certainly don't speak in the name of all Europeans, why react in such a way as to critizise the all US national "thing" as you called it?

Oh BTW I am European myself. I am not a US citizen. So back off, don't make Europeans look like fools.
I have tried to think a bit on why I did react to this posting.

1. I think I experienced this post as inappropriate, in two ways:
A. It was posted in a forum first of all dedicated to canon
photography. Why did I react then: Because this forum is about
canon photography, not US-sorrow.

B. It was posted in a forum that I at least experience as a very
international one. Why did I react then: I felt it to be a typical
US-thing, to be US-centric, about US-sorrow, in an international
site dedicated to something completely different (it confirmed my
prejudices - my mythos if you like - against US-citizens, as very
self-centric, then).

And as much as I admire the US-citizens remarkable way of reacting,
and keeping together, and being (positively understood) completely
convinced about their own issues, it really astonishes me that they
can be (seemingly) so blind to other perspectives, even though they
have a deep sorrow.

I feel that some of the rather exited answers here, just go to
prove mine and others points on this.

***
I would like to say, that I mourn with you, and respect you all for
taking a stand against the terrorists attacks. It was not my
intention to be disrespectful over and against your sorrow.
***

But it was my intention to:
  • Show all the US-citizens that there are a lot of other sadness,
suffering, and sorrowful happenings in the rest of the world also
(and why is this ttack on innocent people any worse than other
attacks on innocent people). This is not of course the same as
saying that I do not understand your sorrow in this respect also.
  • Say that there are different perspectives on the reasons /
grounds for the attacks and hate towards US, than the ones for
example President Bush is propagating. This of course is not the
same as saying terrorist attacks is ok. It is never ok, and it is
no more ok either, when happening to the US.
  • Say that using this forum, for this message, maybe was
disrespectful towards the rest of the forums non-US users (and
therefore got disrespectful answers). This is not of course, not
to say that I don’t respect the US-citizens sorrow –
I do respect your sorrow.

Yours,
Anders Holt
 
I think some of the Non-US comments have been quite interesting. It has certainly made me more aware of exactly how we are viewed by our planetary community. I love the fact that this forum is international, and as a US citizen, I am sorry if I have been arrogant, ignorant or insular in any way! Of course, I hope I haven't been, but if I have, I will try to be more aware and conscious. I only speak for myself, so fellow US citizens, please don't jump to defend yourselves! : )
The reason the original post caused a problem IMO is that it
follows a trend often seen when SOME Americans post on the Internet
or Usenet. And that is they assume they are talking to Americans,
everyone knows it and whatever their knowledge of the outside
world, they post as if the world revolves around them.

What do I mean? Go and look at Usenet rec.photo.digital and a
large proportion of the posts are written from a solely American
perspective.

I find that arrogant.
This is one thing I have tried to be very conscious about.. when I
post a US store like "You can get this at Best Buy (US)" I make
sure I include the "US."

I know what you mean.
  • Raist
 
I think some of the Non-US comments have been quite interesting. It
has certainly made me more aware of exactly how we are viewed by
our planetary community. I love the fact that this forum is
international, and as a US citizen, I am sorry if I have been
arrogant, ignorant or insular in any way! Of course, I hope I
haven't been, but if I have, I will try to be more aware and
conscious. I only speak for myself, so fellow US citizens, please
don't jump to defend yourselves! : )
Leezah,

You are an excellent example of what we, US citizens, should strive to be more like!
  • Raist
 
Raist,

Thank you for your kind words! : )
I think some of the Non-US comments have been quite interesting. It
has certainly made me more aware of exactly how we are viewed by
our planetary community. I love the fact that this forum is
international, and as a US citizen, I am sorry if I have been
arrogant, ignorant or insular in any way! Of course, I hope I
haven't been, but if I have, I will try to be more aware and
conscious. I only speak for myself, so fellow US citizens, please
don't jump to defend yourselves! : )
Leezah,

You are an excellent example of what we, US citizens, should strive
to be more like!
  • Raist
 
US Guys,

what feelings do you expect from me, Russian, by looking at your flag? or what feelings do you expect from my friend from Yougoslavia whom you bombed couple of years ago with this same flag? or from his friend from Palestina, or her friends who now live in Iraq?
They all here, they all real, so what do you expect? Sorrow? Grief?

At the same time we all perfectly well know what it is to loose relatives and friends! and know the importance of memory and respect to them!

So please, next time, if you decide to mourn and brodcast it for the whole world, think of it, and come up with the symbol which would mean the same for every person on this planet! Otherwise please wave your flag in the USA.

regards,
Dmitry
 
Dmitry, thats a perfectly valid point. I guess since Russia lost some 10% of its population in World War 2, it is used to dealing with tragedy.

Like one expert recently stated, Bush will never defeat terrorism, because to defeat terrorism is to remove all causes for grievance. Its a bloody cycle that will go on and on until someone with the will, the justice and the power does something about it.

I still can't help but think of the kids who died whilst typing this.

But hey...this is a photographic forum! I'll be out at the weekend using up my memory cards and batteries, can't wait.
--
My G2 collection on pbase:
http://www.pbase.com/natinha/galleries
 
I understand why people burn the flag. In my opinion, they are
going to the extrme to prove a point. But as a U.S. servicemember
I feel that those that go to that extreme should be kicked out of
the country and sent somewhere else where maybe they don't have the
freedom to do as they please. Then maybe they will learn to
appreciate the flag and what it stands for. I realize it is their
right to do so but it is also what our country stands for and what
the U.S. military fights to protect all over the world. Terrorists
enjoy burning our flag also. --- Ron
"what the U.S. military fights to protect all over the world"
Q: What have the U.S. military done all over our Asian continent?

A: Spread Agent Orange and raped little teenage girls, besides acting as if they have guaranteed diplomatic immunity.

grabs popcorn and watches as U.S. bombers drop precision-bombs on civilians
--
http://printerboyweb.net/G2
 
I think, what made me write it, was exatly the reasons I myself gave for writing it.

I think Dave here is formulating these issues rather good, please read him to:
http://www.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1010&message=3372033

Yours,
Anders
I have tried to think a bit on why I did react to this posting.

1. I think I experienced this post as inappropriate, in two ways:
A. It was posted in a forum first of all dedicated to canon
photography. Why did I react then: Because this forum is about
canon photography, not US-sorrow.

B. It was posted in a forum that I at least experience as a very
international one. Why did I react then: I felt it to be a typical
US-thing, to be US-centric, about US-sorrow, in an international
site dedicated to something completely different (it confirmed my
prejudices - my mythos if you like - against US-citizens, as very
self-centric, then).

And as much as I admire the US-citizens remarkable way of reacting,
and keeping together, and being (positively understood) completely
convinced about their own issues, it really astonishes me that they
can be (seemingly) so blind to other perspectives, even though they
have a deep sorrow.

I feel that some of the rather exited answers here, just go to
prove mine and others points on this.

***
I would like to say, that I mourn with you, and respect you all for
taking a stand against the terrorists attacks. It was not my
intention to be disrespectful over and against your sorrow.
***

But it was my intention to:
  • Show all the US-citizens that there are a lot of other sadness,
suffering, and sorrowful happenings in the rest of the world also
(and why is this ttack on innocent people any worse than other
attacks on innocent people). This is not of course the same as
saying that I do not understand your sorrow in this respect also.
  • Say that there are different perspectives on the reasons /
grounds for the attacks and hate towards US, than the ones for
example President Bush is propagating. This of course is not the
same as saying terrorist attacks is ok. It is never ok, and it is
no more ok either, when happening to the US.
  • Say that using this forum, for this message, maybe was
disrespectful towards the rest of the forums non-US users (and
therefore got disrespectful answers). This is not of course, not
to say that I don’t respect the US-citizens sorrow –
I do respect your sorrow.

Yours,
Anders Holt
--
http://www.holt.no/digi/
http://www.photosig.com/
 
I prefer to be called an American myself, but whatever suits you.
what feelings do you expect from me, Russian, by looking at your
flag?
How about these feelings....here are some figures on financial aid the U.S.A has been pumping into Russia.

Direct bilateral aid $3.96 billion
U.S. 18.3% share of $20 billion in IMF cash loans signed to date $3.66 billion
Export-Import Bank financing $1.80 billion
Overseas Private Investment Corporation $1.97 billion
U.S. Department of Agriculture finance & insurance $0.42 billion
NASA and NASA-related cash payments $0.68 billion
U.S. direct buyout of Russian uranium from Minatom $12.00 billion
Total $24.49 billion

Total in cash to the Russian central government (implemented, pending, and pledged) $16.34 billion
or what feelings do you expect from my friend from
Yougoslavia whom you bombed couple of years ago with this same
flag?
Sooooo, what your saying was that the U.S.A should have sat back and watched the genocide take place in Kosovo?
or from his friend from Palestina, or her friends who now
live in Iraq?
Iraq??? You got to be kidding me to even bring them up.
They all here, they all real, so what do you expect? Sorrow? Grief?
At the same time we all perfectly well know what it is to loose
relatives and friends! and know the importance of memory and
respect to them!
The original poster directed the thread towards Americans. Maybe this isn't the best forum to do it in, but I've seen many other posts that had not a single thing to do with photography. By the way, I don't want your sorrow, grief, or pity. I wouldn't except it if you tried.
So please, next time, if you decide to mourn and brodcast it for
the whole world, think of it, and come up with the symbol which
would mean the same for every person on this planet!
Like I said, the original post was directed towards America. If you don't like it, you shouldn't have looked. :-)
Otherwise please wave your flag in the USA.
Just what I'll do.....wave my flag and wave it proud.

Regards,
Sergeant Chris Elkins
US Army
Fort Bragg, NC (Home of the Airborne)
regards,
Dmitry
--
Chris
 
That a lot of people, and I mean A LOT of people in the US DO NOT
care at all about what goes in the world.
A lot of people in all nations do not care about what happens
outside their nation. True. Thank God for the growth of the
American initiated ARPA/internet. It will/does help.
Please don't say it's ok becuase "others do it too." What I am
talking about happens quite a bit in the US. And witness the
example of how many times when in the internet people from other
countries were in a conversation many still assumed they were
talking only with Americans.
The following Americans inside USA don't give a damn about 91101:
1] KKK [ Who cares? The USA is messed up on all fronts. ]

2] Black people [ September 11? We live and die on the street, and not a single white man cared about our very existence. It's excellent that the white men finally received the same treatment they have been giving us for decades. ]

If 91101 is a really bad day, wait until you move to the Chicago ghetto.

P.S. To James Knowles: What does the growth of ARPANet/Internet has to do with the whole issue of people not caring about 10119?
A good example to me is our news. Usually when they talk about
international news is more like "international places where the US
has been."
I hate lemons so instead I eat oranges. Try one of the other
327,382 news sources. Have you read the "enlightened" foreign news
recently? Geez. All news, worldwide, is pretty bad.
I beg to differ.
American news sources typically do not mention such thorny issues as continued discrimination against coloured people or anything that is not "Americans are involved" or "sensational" or "shocking".
--
http://printerboyweb.net/G2
 
That's indeed a bunch of money! You seem to be attending your classes well :)

So tell my sergeant, why the life in Russia is getting worse with each your billion pumped in?

Пока!
Dmitry
 
what feelings do you expect from me, Russian, by looking at your
flag?
How about these feelings....here are some figures on financial aid
the U.S.A has been pumping into Russia.

[all sorts of financial BS that most of the common world doesn't even give a damn about]
And your point is? Financial aids are BS any way you look at it, and they mean virtually nothing to the average Russian. Just looking at the statistics make me feel America has done a lot to help Russia financially and nearly nil on everything else.
or what feelings do you expect from my friend from
Yougoslavia whom you bombed couple of years ago with this same
flag?
Sooooo, what your saying was that the U.S.A should have sat back
and watched the genocide take place in Kosovo?
Thanks a lot for bombing us Chinese people right at the Chinese Embassy in Yugoslavia with American precision bombs. I hate people like you.
or from his friend from Palestina, or her friends who now
live in Iraq?
Iraq??? You got to be kidding me to even bring them up.
And your point is?
Otherwise please wave your flag in the USA.
Just what I'll do.....wave my flag and wave it proud.
And don't wave it here in Canada, Sir.
--
http://printerboyweb.net/G2
 
The following Americans inside USA don't give a damn about 91101:
1] KKK [ Who cares? The USA is messed up on all fronts. ]
2] Black people [ September 11? We live and die on the street, and
not a single white man cared about our very existence. It's
excellent that the white men finally received the same treatment
they have been giving us for decades. ]
Hmmmmmmm, every single black person I know cares about Sep. 11, though I'm in the military and they may be biased. And they don't sit back like you do and generalize every white person as "not caring about black people's very existence", a very ignorant phrase. If anyone lives and die's in the street, be it any ethnicity, it is there fault and no one elses. Oppurtunity abounds in this day and age, so go cry your river some where else.
If 91101 is a really bad day, wait until you move to the Chicago
ghetto.
I work hard for a living to keep my family out of the "Chicago ghetto", so no thanks, I think I'll pass on that.
P.S. To James Knowles: What does the growth of ARPANet/Internet has
to do with the whole issue of people not caring about 10119?
American news sources typically do not mention such thorny issues
as continued discrimination against coloured people or anything
that is not "Americans are involved" or "sensational" or "shocking".
--
http://printerboyweb.net/G2
--
Chris
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top