*** MINI CHALLENGE 167 - Three's The Number ***

TorontoH5

Senior Member
Messages
1,201
Solutions
1
Reaction score
1
Location
Toronto, ON, CA
Indeed, Mini Challenge 166 was a lot of fun. But also hard on the patience – waiting for a whole week in suspense. But isn’t that why Mini Challenges are fun? Thanks John for the fun ride.
Now on to my job …

I have always heard the saying that an odd number of subjects is preferable to an even number. After some research on the internet, I decided on the theme - “THREE’S THE NUMBER” for Mini Challenge 167.

The following website describes the odd/even compositional rule quite clearly, as quoted below:

http://www.takegreatpictures.com/odd_photos.fci

/ “There are lots of numbers that come into play with photography. Shutter speeds, f stops, focal lengths of lenses, digital sensor multiplying factors, and fill flash ratios are some of the more obvious ones. One number that doesn’t often pop into photographers’ minds is the number of subjects in a photo. The importance behind this deals with composition. /

There’s a compositional fact that states - when including an even number of similar subjects, it is more difficult to create a successful composition than when an odd number of subjects appear. The obvious even number that comes to mind is two. Unless it’s people, when two subjects are the primary elements in a photo, they tend to compete for attention. When the number of subjects is odd, the eye flows from one to the next rather than back and forth. This guideline dates back to the early painters and still stands today. Not that it’s written in stone, but more often than not, it works.

Using the example of two subjects, when one is on the left side of the frame and the other on the right, the eye bounces from one to the other and psychologically creates tension as to which one is the primary subject. The same holds true for subjects that are at the top and bottom of the frame. The exception is when you photograph two people in that it’s natural to photograph couples, parent and child, a bride and groom, etc. /

With an odd number of subjects, there’s a rhythm or pattern created by the subjects and the eye flows from one to the next and often winds up returning to the initial one that caught the viewer’s eye. Getting down to basics, the simple odd number of subjects to photograph is one. Three creates a nice repetition. Five subjects create a pattern as do seven and nine. Once you get past ten main elements, the importance of the number declines.”


I invite you to submit photos with only three subjects . The field is wide open. Anything goes – but the subject has to be in threes. So dazzle us! Show us your finesse in composition!

Rules and Samples will follow separately.

--
Danielle

http://www.pbase.com/dhurlbut
 
Here are the details for our next Mini Challenge 167: "THREE’S THE NUMBER"

The Mini Challenges are meant to be very informal & encourage participation by having few rules.

In keeping with that spirit, here are the guidelines for MC 167.

1. You may enter up to 3 photos.

2. Photos may be shot with any camera and may be taken at any time.

3. The winner of a mini challenge chooses the next challenge and selects the winner, who takes the baton and carries on with it.

4. Please post your entries by replying to this original post – rather than under someone else’s post - and change the subject line to “My entry” or “Entry #1 or something like that to separate your picture posts from comments that someone may make about your post.

5. In the spirit of the previous challenge, I too, would like to nominate the previous host, to take over my role in the event of something happening to me, and that would be John.

6. The challenge will end on Sunday, October 4 at 20:00 hours, EDT time (Eastern Daylight Savings Time, 4 hours behind GMT). I will do my best to announce the winners on the next day.

7. I hope to have plenty of entries to judge, as well as I hope the participants will also comment on their fellow contestants.

--
Danielle

http://www.pbase.com/dhurlbut
 
Here are some examples of the theme THREE’S THE NUMBER:

The Red Head Express



On a Hot Day



Orange in Threes



Spoonbilled Roseates at Lunch



Trailing African Daisies



--
Danielle

http://www.pbase.com/dhurlbut
 
Three sets of three?



And a matrix of 3X3? Lots of sets of three here...



If these aren't suitable, just say so and I'll try and find some "three only" ones.
--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
As you are probably aware, pBase has been down for a few days. If you want to submit photos in the challenge and pBase is still down, please note Glyn's offer below:

http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/read.asp?forum=1009&message=33173018

TorontoH5 wrote:
I hope that our participants are not going to be impacted by pBase's problems.

Hi Danielle

I'll be happy to host pics of those who might be otherwize prevented by this. They just need to send me attachments of the correct size and diensions. I'll put them on my site and send them the link so they can do their post.

r2orchid and gmail dot com is where they should send it.

All the best Glyn.

--
Danielle

http://www.pbase.com/dhurlbut
 
Dug deep into the shoe box to find this one, taken 4.5 years ago :-). The top flag is the South African Flag. I knew it would come in handy :-)

Tri Nations Ferris Wheel



Regards.

Ernest
--





May the Focus be with you
707,717,828,R1,P8,H9,A700
 
Thanks for jumping in to kick start this challenge. I would have thought that you would be holed up somewhere to recuperate from the rigours of hosting the last challenge.

Thanks for your three entries. All are good examples of the compositional rule of odd numbers.

Snowy Owls:

This composition creates a triangle between the three owls. My eyes are constantly moving from one owl to the next. However I keep coming back to the owl in the middle, perhaps because the outside owls are keeping a good eye on the middle owl.

Proud Mother:

Here we see an example of three subjects of different sizes - one large mother eagle and two very small eaglets.

Come Fly with Us:

This is a good example of three differing subjects - two geese and another very big, very different bird. My attention is brought to a complete halt by another characteristic. These birds are going in two different directions, with the big bird in the middle. This is very effective.

Thanks again for being the first!

--
Danielle

http://www.pbase.com/dhurlbut
 
Your photos indeed are good examples of 3 x 3.

I was actually thinking of only three subjects. Because the cadets form three separate lines, this photo will squeeze in!

However, the photo of the jets (Snowbirds?) is stretching it a bit too far. Maybe because there isn't enough space between each group of three. I hope that you can find another photo to replace this one.

But, let me comment on both photos:

Photo #1 - I like the use of colour in this photo. Also I enjoy the precision of the marchers - everyone matching each other. No discordance here.

Photo #2 - this photo is very pleasing to the eyes. Also, when you think of the various combinations of 3, you realize how complex is this formation.

Thanks for entering and please dig in your archives for a replacement photo.

--
Danielle

http://www.pbase.com/dhurlbut
 
Your photo is a very good example of how a composition is greatly enhanced by having an odd number of subjects. Just block off the photo with your hand to see just 2 of the ferris wheel buckets. See how the photo loses its impact?

Having 3 different flags in the photo adds additional interest.

I like some other compositional pluses in this photo - two curved lines and many diagonal lines.

Great going, Ernest!
--
Danielle

http://www.pbase.com/dhurlbut
 
Hi John,

I greatly envy your scenery. Nice capture. I have not seen owls from you before.

Rich
 
Point about the snowbird 3X3 matrix taken, Danielle. Here's a replacement for that one:



--
Jerry
Sony V1, H5 and A350... Still learning...

'The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera.'
-- Dorothea Lange

http://www.pbase.com/icicle50/root

 
One day during my stay in Mozambique, my Habitat for Humanity group taught the kids several American games, including wheelbarrow racing. The kids spoke Shona and we spoke English and there was no one to translate. So we demonstrated the game and they picked it up very fast. The races drew a crowd and more and more kids showed up from the countryside to play. I was a racer as soon I was done taking this picture. I very much miss my little friends - such sweet children.



--
Colleen



http://www.pbase.com/magneticfish
 

Keyboard shortcuts

Back
Top